Outgoings are the landlord’s costs of owning and running the building, passed on to the tenant on top of rent. In a retail shop lease in Queensland they are closely regulated by the Retail Shop Leases Act 1994, and the regulation is where many tenants find money they did not know they were owed.
What can be recovered
Section 7 defines outgoings as the landlord’s reasonable expenses directly attributable to the operation, maintenance or repair of the centre or building, and charges, levies, rates and taxes payable by the landlord in connection with it. Section 7(3) then excludes certain items altogether. A retail tenant cannot be required to pay land tax, and a lease provision requiring the tenant to pay or reimburse land tax is void under sections 17 and 24. Also excluded are expenditure of a capital nature, contributions to a sinking fund for capital items, insurance premiums for loss of profits, insurance excesses, contributions to a promotion or marketing fund (which are dealt with separately) and interest and charges on money borrowed by the landlord. A landlord who has recovered any of these as outgoings is liable to repay them.
The lease must specify
Under section 37 a tenant is not liable to pay an amount for outgoings unless the lease specifies the outgoings payable, how they will be determined and apportioned, and how they will be recovered. A lease with a general clause requiring the tenant to pay all costs of the building, without the detail, does not satisfy the section. Under section 38 the tenant’s proportion of outgoings that are not referable only to the tenant’s premises is generally the proportion that the premises’ lettable area bears to the total lettable area of the premises in the centre or building that benefit from the outgoing. Costs that benefit only other premises cannot be charged to the tenant, and areas occupied by the landlord or vacant are not excluded from the denominator.
Estimates and audited statements
Section 38A requires the landlord to give the tenant, at least one month before the start of each accounting period, an estimate of the outgoings for that period, itemised so that no single item is more than 5 per cent of the total, other than a charge, levy, rate or tax payable under an Act or an outgoing that cannot be itemised further. Section 38B requires an audited annual statement of the outgoings actually incurred within three months after the end of the period, with a reconciliation against the estimate. Where the statement shows the tenant was charged more than their share, the excess must be refunded or credited.
Section 38C gives the tenant a direct remedy. If the landlord has not given the estimate or the audited statement when required, the tenant may withhold payment of outgoings until it is given, without being in breach. Landlords who have fallen behind on statements should not serve default notices for outgoings until they have caught up.
Common disputes
The usual outgoings disputes concern the lettable areas used for apportionment, which should be checked against a survey; management fees charged at a percentage without a basis in the lease; repairs that are really capital replacements, such as a new air conditioning plant or a roof, charged as maintenance; charges for areas or services the tenant cannot use; and statements that are not audited or not reconciled. A tenant who asks for the invoices behind the statement is entitled to an explanation, and a landlord who cannot produce them is in a weak position.
Rent arrears and set off
Tenants in dispute about outgoings sometimes stop paying rent, which is a mistake. Rent and outgoings are usually separate obligations, and the right to withhold under section 38C applies to outgoings, not rent. A tenant who believes they have overpaid should pay rent, withhold or pay outgoings under protest as the section allows, and pursue the overpayment through the Small Business Commissioner’s mediation process and, if necessary, QCAT.
Non retail leases
These protections apply to retail shop leases only. A tenant of an office, warehouse or industrial premises pays whatever outgoings the lease specifies, including land tax if the lease says so, and the only limits are the terms of the lease and the general law. One exception survives for older leases: under section 83A of the Land Tax Act 2010, a provision requiring the tenant to pay or reimburse land tax is unenforceable in a lease entered into after 1 January 1992 and before 30 June 2009, and in a renewal, assignment or transfer of such a lease. A tenant still holding under a lease from that period, or an option renewal of one, should check the point before paying.
Practical steps
Collect every estimate and statement for the term, check the apportionment and the excluded items, and ask the landlord in writing to explain any discrepancies. A reconciliation over several years often produces a substantial credit.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.