When a residential sale collapses, the deposit is often the only money in play, and both sides usually believe it is theirs. The agent or solicitor holding it is caught in the middle. This article explains how the law deals with that situation in Queensland.
Who is entitled to the deposit
The starting point is the contract. Under the REIQ standard conditions, if the seller terminates because the buyer failed to settle or otherwise defaulted, the seller may keep the deposit and, in addition, recover damages for any loss on resale and the costs of the second sale. If the buyer terminates under a condition such as finance, building and pest or the statutory cooling off right, or because the seller defaulted, the deposit must be refunded. The cooling off right carries a termination penalty of 0.25 per cent of the price, which the seller may deduct from the refund.
The hard cases are those where each side says the other was in default. A buyer who says the finance clause was properly used, and a seller who says the buyer never genuinely applied, cannot both be right. A seller who terminated by notice that turns out to have been premature or defective may have repudiated the contract, which hands the buyer the right to terminate and recover the deposit. The entitlement to the deposit follows the answer to that question, and the question is one of law and evidence.
What the stakeholder can do
Real estate agents hold deposits in trust under the Agents Financial Administration Act 2014. Sections 26 to 28 govern what the agent may do when the parties disagree. The agent must not pay the money out unless all the parties give written authority, a court orders the payment, or the agent has used the notice procedure.
Under that procedure, the agent may give written notice to everyone with a claim that it considers a stated party entitled to the deposit and that it intends to pay that party on a stated date, which must be at least 60 days after the notice. If a party starts a court proceeding about the deposit before that date and tells the agent, the agent must not pay the money out and must instead hold it or pay it into court. If no proceeding is started, the agent may pay the stated party on the stated date and is protected in doing so.
Solicitors who hold deposits as stakeholder are not governed by the same section but are bound by their trust account obligations and will not release disputed money without agreement or an order.
Starting the proceeding
A party who disagrees with the agent’s stated view has to act. The proceeding is usually a claim for a declaration that the contract was validly terminated and for an order for payment of the deposit, in the Magistrates Court for deposits up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. The District Court’s limit is $750,000 and rises to $1.5 million for proceedings started on or after 1 January 2027. Where the claim also seeks specific performance or damages for loss on resale, the proceeding is framed more broadly and the deposit forms part of it.
Can a court order a forfeited deposit to be repaid
A deposit of up to 10 per cent is treated as an earnest for performance, and a seller who validly terminates for the buyer’s default is ordinarily entitled to keep it even if the seller suffered no loss. The buyer’s avenues for recovering it are narrow. Section 84 of the Property Law Act 2023 allows a buyer to recover the deposit where the seller’s title is defective, and section 84(4) gives the court a general discretion, in any proceeding in which it refuses to order specific performance or in which the buyer seeks the return of the deposit, to order repayment of the deposit and any instalments. That discretion was introduced by the 2023 Act. It does not give a defaulting buyer a right to the deposit, and a buyer who defaulted should not assume the court will intervene because the seller later resold at a profit.
Deposits above the cap
Under the Property Law Act 2023 a deposit is a sum of not more than 10 per cent of the price, or 20 per cent for a proposed lot. A contract that requires the buyer to pay more than that before becoming entitled to a transfer is an instalment contract, which cannot be terminated for a default in payment until 30 days after a notice in the approved form and which gives the buyer other protections. A seller who tries to forfeit an oversized deposit without following those rules risks having the forfeiture set aside.
Practical steps
Do not tell the agent to pay the deposit out, and do not sign an authority, until you know your position. Ask the agent in writing to confirm that the money is held pending agreement or an order. If the agent gives a 60 day notice against you, diarise the date and take advice at once, because the only way to stop the payment is a proceeding started in time. Keep the contract, every notice given under it and the correspondence between the solicitors, because the dispute is decided on those documents.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Agents Financial Administration Act 2014 (Qld), ss 26 to 28
- Queensland Law Society, REIQ property contracts
- Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), ss 84 and 87 to 94 (recovery of deposit, deposits and instalment contracts)
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68 (monetary limit)
- Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 (Qld), ss 2 and 62 (District Court monetary limit $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027)