- Home
- What we help with
- Cars, caravans and goods
- Faults the dealer will not fix
Faults the dealer will not fix
The car has been back to the dealer three times for the same fault. The dealer says it is fixed, or that it is a characteristic of the vehicle, or that the warranty does not cover it. Under the Australian Consumer Law the question is not what the warranty says but whether the vehicle has a major failure, and if it does the choice of remedy is yours. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Consumer guaranteesVehicles costing $100,000 or less, and any vehicle of a kind normally bought for personal use, carry the guarantee of acceptable quality regardless of the dealer's or manufacturer's warranty.
- Statutory warrantyMost used vehicles sold by a licensed dealer carry a statutory warranty of 3 months or 5,000 kilometres, or 1 month or 1,000 kilometres for vehicles more than 10 years old or with 160,000 kilometres or more.
- Major failureA fault that would have stopped a reasonable buyer purchasing, or that cannot be fixed within a reasonable time, is a major failure giving the right to reject and recover the price.
- QCATQCAT hears motor vehicle disputes against licensed dealers up to $100,000 under the statutory warranty or the consumer guarantees.
The disputes we see most
- A new or used vehicle has a recurring fault that repeated repairs have not fixed.
- The dealer says the fault is not covered, is normal for the model or was caused by you.
- The manufacturer has acknowledged a known defect but offers only repairs or a goodwill contribution.
- You want to reject the vehicle and the dealer says it is too late or that rejection is not available.
- The dealer has had the vehicle for weeks and you have no car and no answers.
- The vehicle was sold with a statutory warranty and the dealer is refusing or delaying repairs.
See which rules usually apply, in about two minutes.
For anyone who has bought a vehicle that has a fault. Answer up to ten questions and the checker will show general information about the rules that usually apply to sales of that kind in Queensland, including the statutory warranty and the consumer guarantees. It is not legal advice.
Your answers stay on this page unless you choose to add them to an enquiry.
This is general information about the rules that usually apply to sales of this kind. It is not legal advice and does not tell you whether you have a claim or what you should do.
The Queensland statutory warranty usually applies to sales of this kind.
Under the statutory warranty, the seller must repair at its own expense a covered defect that the buyer reports in writing before the warranty period ends. Whether it covers a particular vehicle and fault depends on the sale documents, the dates and what the fault is.
Whether the statutory warranty applies to sales of this kind depends on further details.
Some answers leave open a detail that the statutory warranty turns on. The points below set out the rule for each.
Where the statutory warranty does not apply, the consumer guarantees usually still do.
A vehicle bought from a dealer must be of acceptable quality under the Australian Consumer Law, whatever the dealer's or manufacturer's warranty says. Where a fault is a major failure, the buyer may reject the vehicle and choose a refund or a replacement, or keep it and claim compensation for its reduced value. Where it is not, the dealer must fix it within a reasonable time.
A vehicle sold on consignment usually has no statutory warranty.
A dealer selling on consignment sells as agent for the owner, and the statutory warranty applies only if the owner was a licensed dealer or auctioneer. Whether the consumer guarantees apply depends on who the owner was and how the sale was made, which the sale documents should show. A dealer that made false or misleading statements about the vehicle can still be liable for them.
A buyer's rights are generally more limited after an auction sale.
The consumer guarantees of acceptable quality, fitness for purpose and matching description generally do not apply to a sale at auction where the auctioneer acted as agent for the owner. The guarantees about title still apply, and a business that made false or misleading statements about what it was selling can still be liable for them.
A private sale carries no statutory warranty and no guarantee of acceptable quality.
Both apply to vehicles sold by a dealer, not by a private seller. A buyer's rights depend on what the seller said, how the vehicle was described and whether the seller had the right to sell it. These claims are generally brought in the Magistrates Court rather than QCAT.
Private sales that went wrongThe statutory warranty does not apply to goods of this kind, but the consumer guarantees usually do.
Boats, trailers other than caravans, tractors and farm machinery are not motor vehicles under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014, so the statutory warranty and QCAT's motor vehicle jurisdiction do not apply. Goods bought from a business for $100,000 or less, and goods of a kind ordinarily bought for personal use, carry the consumer guarantees. QCAT can decide these disputes up to $25,000, and larger claims go to the courts.
Caravans, boats and machineryNot a motor vehicle
Boats, trailers other than caravans, tractors and farm machinery are not motor vehicles under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014, so the statutory warranty does not apply.
New vehicles
The statutory warranty applies only to used vehicles. A new vehicle usually comes with a manufacturer's warranty, which is separate from the rights described here.
Caravans and camper trailers
The statutory warranty does not apply to caravans, which include camper trailers.
Motorcycles
The statutory warranty does not apply to motorcycles.
Commercial vehicles
The statutory warranty does not apply to a vehicle built mainly for carrying or hauling goods, or designed to carry more than 9 people.
Unregistered written off vehicles
A vehicle that was unregistered when sold, and was recorded as written off or could not be registered in Queensland because of its design, has no statutory warranty. Under the consumer guarantees, acceptable quality is judged in light of the price and what the buyer was told about the vehicle.
Restorable vehicles
A vehicle more than 20 years old and sold for restoration has no statutory warranty if the buyer signed the waiver notice before the contract. The consumer guarantees still apply, judged in light of the vehicle's age, its price and what it was sold for.
No statutory warranty at auction
A vehicle sold at auction has the statutory warranty only if a licensed dealer or auctioneer owned it. Vehicles auctioned for other owners, such as fleet operators, finance companies and private owners, do not have it, and the auctioneer must announce that immediately before the auction.
The warranty period
The statutory warranty requires written notice of the defect before the warranty period ends. The period is 3 months or 5,000 kilometres for a vehicle no more than 10 years old with less than 160,000 kilometres, and 1 month or 1,000 kilometres for any other, whichever comes first. It is extended by each day the vehicle was away for warranty repairs after written notice.
Excluded items
The statutory warranty does not cover some items, including tyres, batteries, airbags and audio equipment. The consumer guarantees, where they apply, have no list of excluded items.
Who sold the vehicle
The statutory warranty applies only where the seller was a dealer or auctioneer, and the guarantee of acceptable quality only where the seller sold in the course of a business. The contract or receipt should name the seller, and the Office of Fair Trading keeps a public register of licensed motor dealers. A person who trades in vehicles without a licence is still treated as a dealer for the statutory warranty.
How the vehicle was sold
Before the contract is made, a dealer must give the buyer a statutory warranty notice to sign for a vehicle that has the warranty, and must generally advertise or display a vehicle without it as having no statutory warranty. The contract should also show whether the dealer sold as owner or on consignment.
Consignment sales
The contract should show whether the dealer sold the vehicle as its owner or on consignment for someone else. On a consignment sale the claim may be against the owner rather than the dealer, and the consumer guarantees may not apply.
The auction paperwork
An auctioneer must announce immediately before the auction that a vehicle has no statutory warranty, and must give the buyer a statutory warranty notice to sign immediately after the sale of a vehicle that has one. The notice and the auction terms should show which applied.
Utes and load capacity
A ute with a nominal load carrying capacity of 1 tonne or less is covered by the statutory warranty. A ute built to carry more is generally a commercial vehicle, which has no statutory warranty.
Motorhomes and campervans
A motorhome is driven under its own power, so it is not a caravan under the Act and is generally covered by the statutory warranty.
Age and odometer reading
A vehicle no more than 10 years old with less than 160,000 kilometres on the day of sale has a warranty of 3 months or 5,000 kilometres, whichever comes first. An older vehicle, or one that had travelled further, has 1 month or 1,000 kilometres. Age runs from the built date shown on the vehicle.
What the warranty covers
The statutory warranty covers a part that does not perform its intended function, or that can no longer be relied on to do so, unless it is an excluded item. A written diagnosis from a mechanic usually settles which it is.
Who gives the warranty at auction
The statutory warranty is given by the licensed dealer or auctioneer that owned the vehicle immediately before the sale, which is not always the auction house. Written notice of the defect goes to that business.
Written notice and delivery
The statutory warranty requires written notice of the defect before the warranty period ends. The buyer must also deliver the vehicle to the seller, or to a repairer the seller nominates in writing, and is taken to have done so if reasonable efforts to deliver it are refused.
Written notice and delivery
The statutory warranty requires written notice of the defect before the warranty period ends. Telling the seller by phone or in person is not enough. The buyer must also deliver the vehicle to the seller, or to a repairer the seller nominates in writing, and is taken to have done so if reasonable efforts to deliver it are refused.
Where the seller refuses
Where the seller refuses to accept that a defect is covered, the buyer can apply to QCAT for an order that it is covered and that the seller repair it. If the buyer has the defect repaired elsewhere after a refusal, QCAT can order the seller to pay the reasonable cost.
Where the repair is not done or does not work
A seller that accepts a defect must repair it within 14 days unless it has a reasonable excuse, and the repair must leave the part able to be relied on to perform its intended function. If either fails, the buyer can apply to QCAT.
Where the seller does not answer
Once written notice has been given and the vehicle delivered, the seller has 5 business days to say in writing whether it accepts the defect. A seller that says nothing in that time is taken to have accepted it, and must then repair it within 14 days unless it has a reasonable excuse.
While a repair is under way
The warranty period is extended by each day the vehicle is away for warranty repairs after written notice. The repair orders, the dates the vehicle was dropped off and collected, and the odometer readings are the record of that.
The consumer guarantees apply as well
The statutory warranty sits alongside the consumer guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law and does not reduce them. If a fault is a major failure, the guarantees can give the right to reject the vehicle and choose a refund or a replacement.
If the statutory warranty does not apply
The consumer guarantees under the Australian Consumer Law usually still apply to a vehicle bought from a dealer. They require the vehicle to be of acceptable quality, and they are not limited to 1 or 3 months.
If the statutory warranty does not apply
Rights after an auction sale are more limited. The consumer guarantee of acceptable quality generally does not apply where the auctioneer sold as agent for the owner.
Where it is decided
QCAT decides statutory warranty claims worth up to $100,000, and larger claims go to the courts.
Vehicles bought for business use
The consumer guarantees cover a commercial vehicle that cost $100,000 or less, or that was bought mainly to carry goods on public roads. They do not cover a vehicle bought to resell.
Written records
A written record of when the fault was reported and what the buyer asked for is the starting point for a consumer guarantee claim.
Written records
A written record of when the fault was reported and what the buyer asked for is the starting point for a consumer guarantee claim. A complaint made only by phone or in person can be hard to prove later.
Where the dealer refuses
Where a dealer refuses to fix a fault covered by the consumer guarantees, the buyer may have it repaired elsewhere and recover the reasonable cost, or reject the vehicle. For a major failure the buyer may reject the vehicle without first giving the dealer the chance to repair it.
Where the repair is not done or does not work
A dealer must fix a fault within a reasonable time. If it does not, the buyer may have it repaired elsewhere and recover the reasonable cost, or reject the vehicle. Two or more faults can together amount to a major failure even where none would alone.
Where the dealer does not answer
A dealer that is asked to fix a fault and does not do so within a reasonable time is in the same position as one that refuses. The buyer may then have it repaired elsewhere and recover the reasonable cost, or reject the vehicle.
While a repair is under way
If a repair does not hold, the history of repair attempts becomes important evidence. The repair orders and the dates the vehicle was away are the record of it.
Where it is decided
QCAT's motor vehicle jurisdiction covers consumer guarantee claims worth up to $100,000 about cars, utes, vans, motorhomes, caravans and motorcycles. Larger claims go to the courts.
Rejecting a vehicle
To reject a vehicle, the buyer must tell the dealer that the vehicle is rejected and give the grounds for rejecting it. The right to reject is lost once the rejection period ends, which is the period from the supply of the vehicle within which the fault would reasonably be expected to become apparent. A rejection notice is an important document and needs to be drafted correctly. We can advise on whether a vehicle can be rejected and prepare the notice.
What the seller said
A private seller who made a false statement that led to the purchase, for example about the vehicle's accident history, kilometres or mechanical condition, can be liable for the loss. The advertisement and the messages are the main evidence.
Title and finance
A private seller must have the right to sell the vehicle. If it has finance owing or turns out to be stolen, the buyer usually has a claim against the seller whatever was said about its condition. A search of the Personal Property Securities Register shows any registered security interest.
Private sellers who trade as a business
A person who buys and sells vehicles as a business is treated as a dealer even without a licence, which can bring the statutory warranty and the consumer guarantees into play. A seller with several vehicles for sale may be in that position.
Purchases of $10,000 or less
We act in disputes about vehicles and goods worth more than $10,000. For a smaller purchase, QCAT is designed for people to run their own case, and the Office of Fair Trading takes complaints about businesses and may try to conciliate them.
Purchases of $10,000 or less
We act in disputes about vehicles and goods worth more than $10,000. For a smaller purchase, a community legal centre may be able to help.
Vehicles over $100,000
QCAT's limit of $100,000 applies to the amount claimed, not the price of the vehicle, and larger claims go to the courts. The consumer guarantees cover a vehicle that cost more than $100,000 only if it is of a kind ordinarily bought for personal use, or was bought mainly to carry goods on public roads.
Goods over $100,000
The consumer guarantees cover goods that cost more than $100,000 only if they are of a kind ordinarily bought for personal, domestic or household use. Otherwise the claim depends on the contract and on what the seller said.
If you would like advice on your situation, send these answers with an enquiry. A lawyer will read them and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step.
This is general information, not legal advice. The checker does not consider your contract, what was said before the sale, faults pointed out to you before you bought, or any other warranty. Time limits can be short, and they keep running while you decide what to do and while an enquiry is with us.
The consumer guarantees for vehicles
A vehicle bought from a dealer for $100,000 or less, or a vehicle of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use whatever the price, comes with the consumer guarantees in the Australian Consumer Law. The vehicle must be of acceptable quality, meaning fit for its ordinary purposes, acceptable in appearance and finish, free from defects, safe and durable, judged by what a reasonable consumer would regard as acceptable given its nature, price, age and kilometres and any statements made about it. It must be fit for any purpose the buyer made known, and it must match its description and any demonstration. The guarantees apply regardless of the manufacturer’s warranty, the dealer’s warranty or any extended warranty product, and they cannot be excluded. A used vehicle is not expected to be as good as a new one, but it is expected to be as reliable as its age, price and description would lead a reasonable buyer to expect.
Major failures and rejection
Where a vehicle has a major failure, the buyer may reject it and choose a refund or a replacement, or keep it and recover compensation for the reduction in its value. A failure is major where a reasonable consumer would not have bought the vehicle had they known of the fault, where the vehicle is substantially unfit for its ordinary purpose or a disclosed purpose and cannot easily and within a reasonable time be made fit, where it differs significantly from its description or demonstration, or where it is unsafe. Multiple minor faults can together amount to a major failure. Where the failure is minor, the dealer may repair within a reasonable time, but repeated unsuccessful repairs tend to show that the failure was major all along. Rejection must be exercised within the rejection period, which is the time from supply within which the fault would reasonably be expected to appear, and is lost if the vehicle has been damaged by something other than the fault. Consequential loss, such as hire car costs and towing, is recoverable in addition.
The Queensland statutory warranty
Most used vehicles sold by a licensed motor dealer carry a statutory warranty under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014. A class A warranty applies to vehicles with less than 160,000 kilometres and a built date no more than 10 years before the sale, and lasts 3 months or 5,000 kilometres, whichever comes first. A class B warranty applies to older or higher mileage vehicles and lasts 1 month or 1,000 kilometres. The buyer must give the dealer written notice of a defect before the warranty expires and deliver the vehicle to the dealer or a repairer the dealer nominates. The dealer must say in writing within 5 business days whether it accepts that the defect is covered, failing which it is taken to have accepted, and must repair an accepted defect within 14 days of accepting it unless it has a reasonable excuse. The warranty is extended for each day the vehicle is away for warranty repairs. Tyres, batteries, lights other than a warning light or hazard indicator, audio equipment, certain service items and paintwork or upholstery defects that should have been apparent on inspection are excluded. The warranty does not apply to motorcycles, caravans, commercial vehicles, vehicles sold on consignment for an owner who is not a licensed dealer or auctioneer, or unregistered written off vehicles. The statutory warranty operates alongside the consumer guarantees and does not reduce them.
Where these disputes are decided
QCAT has a dedicated jurisdiction for motor vehicle disputes between a buyer and a licensed dealer, under the statutory warranty or the consumer guarantees, for claims up to $100,000. Claims above that go to the courts. Claims against manufacturers for damages must be brought within 3 years of when the buyer became aware, or should reasonably have become aware, of the failure, and claims against dealers generally within 6 years. We act in disputes about vehicles worth more than $10,000.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on whether the fault is a major failure and what remedy follows. A properly drafted rejection notice changes the conversation with most dealers, because it is the step that starts the clock on refund. Where the dealer still refuses, we arrange independent assessment of the fault where needed, prepare the QCAT application and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Assess whether the fault is a major failure and advise you in writing on your rights against the dealer and the manufacturer, including rejection, refund, replacement and compensation.
- Prepare the written rejection or demand so that your rights are properly exercised and preserved, and deal with the finance company where the vehicle is financed.
- Arrange independent mechanical or engineering assessment where the fault or its cause is disputed.
- Prepare and run the QCAT motor vehicle dispute or court claim, including the evidence of the fault and the repair history.
Common questions
How many times does the dealer get to try to fix it?
For a minor failure, the dealer may repair, but must do so within a reasonable time. For a major failure the dealer has no right to insist on repair and the buyer may reject the vehicle. A fault that has not been fixed after a reasonable number of attempts, or that keeps recurring, is strong evidence that the failure is major because it cannot easily be remedied within a reasonable time. There is no fixed number, but a dealer that has had several attempts is usually out of time.
What is a major failure in a vehicle?
A failure is major if a reasonable consumer would not have bought the vehicle had they known of the fault, if the vehicle is substantially unfit for its normal purpose or a purpose you made known and cannot easily and within a reasonable time be made fit, if it differs significantly from its description, or if it is unsafe. A series of smaller faults can together amount to a major failure. Transmission, engine, electrical and safety system faults that recur, and defects that make the vehicle unreliable, are commonly found to be major.
Can I reject the vehicle and get my money back?
If the failure is major, yes. Where a vehicle is rejected, the dealer must refund the price or provide a replacement at your choice. The right to reject is lost once the rejection period ends, which is the time from supply within which the fault would reasonably be expected to appear, if the vehicle is lost or destroyed, or if it has been damaged after delivery by something other than the fault. A rejection notice is an important document and needs to be drafted correctly. We can advise on whether a vehicle can be rejected and prepare the notice. Where the vehicle is financed, the refund is applied to the loan and the finance company needs to be involved.
Does the statutory warranty add anything?
For most used vehicles bought from a licensed dealer, yes. The Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 gives a class A warranty of 3 months or 5,000 kilometres for vehicles no more than 10 years old with less than 160,000 kilometres, and a class B warranty of 1 month or 1,000 kilometres for older or higher mileage vehicles. The buyer must give the dealer written notice of the defect before the warranty expires and deliver the vehicle for repair. The dealer must say in writing within 5 business days whether it accepts the defect, and must repair an accepted defect within 14 days of accepting it unless it has a reasonable excuse. The warranty is extended by each day the vehicle is away for warranty repairs. Some items such as tyres and batteries are excluded, as are paintwork defects that should have been apparent on inspection, and the warranty does not apply to motorcycles, caravans, commercial vehicles or unregistered written off vehicles.
The manufacturer is offering a goodwill payment. Should I accept?
Not without advice. A goodwill payment is usually offered in exchange for a release of all claims, and where the vehicle has a major failure it may be far less than the refund or replacement you are entitled to. The guarantee of acceptable quality can be enforced against the manufacturer for damages as well as against the dealer for refund or replacement, and claims against manufacturers must be brought within 3 years of when you became aware, or should reasonably have become aware, of the failure.
Where is the dispute decided and how long do I have?
QCAT has a motor vehicle jurisdiction for disputes between buyers and licensed dealers up to $100,000, under the statutory warranty or the consumer guarantees, and it is the usual forum. Claims above that go to the courts. Claims under the consumer guarantees must generally be brought within 6 years, but the right to reject is lost once the rejection period ends, which can be much sooner.
Articles on faults the dealer will not fix
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about faults the dealer will not fix. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- The statutory warranty on used cars in Queensland: what it covers and how to enforce itMost used cars sold by licensed dealers in Queensland come with a statutory warranty under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014. This article explains class A and class B warranties, the defects and vehicles excluded, the defect notice process and how QCAT enforces the warranty for amounts up to $100,000.
- Rejecting a faulty car under the consumer guarantees: new and used vehiclesThe Australian Consumer Law applies to cars bought from dealers, new or used, and for a major failure allows the buyer to reject the vehicle and recover the price. This article explains what makes a vehicle fault major, the roles of dealer and manufacturer, the rejection process and QCAT's $100,000 motor vehicle jurisdiction.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.