- Home
- What we help with
- Money owed, debt and fraud
- Defending a debt claim against you
Defending a debt claim against you
A demand has arrived for money you do not think you owe, or do not owe in that amount, and it comes with a deadline. The worst response is no response, because debt claims are decided by default when the deadline passes. The best response is one that identifies the real defence and puts it in a way that the creditor, QCAT or the court has to deal with. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand, before the deadline.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- QCATA respondent to a minor debt claim has 28 days to respond. If they do not, the applicant can obtain a decision by default.
- Court claimsA defendant served with a Magistrates or District Court claim has 28 days to file a notice of intention to defend, failing which default judgment can be entered.
- Statutory demandsA company served with a statutory demand has 21 days to pay or to file and serve an application to set it aside. The deadline cannot be extended.
- LimitationA debt that fell due more than 6 years ago is generally unenforceable, unless it was acknowledged in writing or part paid in the meantime.
The disputes we see most
- You have received a letter of demand, a QCAT application or a court claim for money you dispute.
- The amount claimed is inflated by interest, fees or charges that were never agreed.
- The work or goods the invoice relates to were defective, incomplete or never delivered.
- The debt is old and you think it may be out of time.
- Your company has been served with a statutory demand, or you have been served with a bankruptcy notice.
- A judgment has been entered against you without your knowledge and you want it set aside.
Deadlines first
Debt claims are won and lost on deadlines. A respondent to a QCAT minor debt claim has 28 days from service to file a response, failing which the applicant can obtain a decision by default. A defendant served with a Magistrates, District or Supreme Court claim has 28 days to file a notice of intention to defend and a defence, failing which default judgment can be entered for the amount claimed, interest and costs. A company served with a statutory demand under the Corporations Act 2001 has 21 days to pay, secure the debt or file and serve an application to set the demand aside, and that period cannot be extended. An individual served with a bankruptcy notice has 21 days to comply or apply to set it aside. Default judgments can sometimes be set aside, but only on an application that explains the default, shows a real defence and is made promptly, and usually at the defaulting party’s cost. The first thing we do with any debt claim is identify the deadline and protect it.
The defences that work
Most successful defences fall into a short list. The debt is not owed because there was no agreement, the agreement was with a different entity or the goods or services were never supplied. The amount is wrong because payments or credits have not been accounted for, or because the creditor has added interest, fees or charges that were never agreed or that operate as penalties. The goods or work were defective or incomplete, which gives the debtor a set off against the amount claimed and sometimes a counterclaim that exceeds it. The creditor was not licensed to perform the work, which under the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 limits a building contractor’s recovery severely. The debt is statute barred because it fell due more than 6 years ago and has not been acknowledged in writing or part paid since. The terms relied on are unfair under the Australian Consumer Law and cannot be enforced. The right defence depends on the documents, and a defence that raises everything is weaker than one that raises the real point.
Statutory demands and bankruptcy notices
A statutory demand is designed for undisputed debts of $4,000 or more owed by companies. If the debt is genuinely disputed or the company has an offsetting claim, the Supreme Court or Federal Court will set the demand aside on an application filed and served within 21 days, and the creditor will usually be ordered to pay the costs. The application must be supported by an affidavit that sets out the dispute, and it must be filed and served in time. A bankruptcy notice requires an individual with a final judgment of $10,000 or more to pay within 21 days, and non compliance is an act of bankruptcy. It can be set aside where the debtor has a counterclaim, set off or cross demand that could not have been raised in the original proceedings and that equals or exceeds the judgment, or where the notice is defective. Where the judgment was obtained by default, applying to set the judgment aside is often the better course.
Settlement
Where the debt is owed in whole or part, the sensible outcome is usually a negotiated settlement or payment arrangement documented in a way that brings the dispute to an end, with any judgment set aside or the claim discontinued, and any credit listing dealt with. We negotiate those outcomes and document them so that the creditor cannot come back.
Where these claims are decided
Debt claims up to $25,000 are brought in QCAT, claims up to $150,000 in the Magistrates Court, claims up to $750,000 in the District Court, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027, and larger claims in the Supreme Court. Applications to set aside statutory demands are made in the Supreme Court or the Federal Court, and applications about bankruptcy notices in the Federal Circuit and Family Court.
What we do
- Review the claim, the agreement and the history and advise you in writing on whether the debt is owed, what defences and counterclaims are available and what the realistic outcomes are.
- Prepare the response to the demand, the QCAT response, or the notice of intention to defend and defence in court, within the deadline.
- Apply to set aside statutory demands and bankruptcy notices, and to set aside default judgments entered without proper service or where there is a real defence.
- Negotiate settlements and payment arrangements where the debt is owed in whole or part, documented so that the matter ends.
Common questions
I have received a letter of demand. Do I have to respond?
You are not legally required to, but you should. A letter of demand is not a court document and nothing happens automatically if the deadline passes, but ignoring it usually leads to a claim being filed, with the added costs that brings. A written response that disputes the debt with reasons, or proposes a resolution, often ends the matter or at least frames the dispute on your terms. If the demand is a statutory demand or a bankruptcy notice, the position is entirely different and the deadline is real.
What are the defences to a debt claim?
The common ones are that the money is not owed because there was no agreement or the agreement was with someone else; that the amount is wrong because of payments, credits, or interest and fees that were never agreed; that the goods or work were defective or incomplete, which gives a set off or counterclaim; that the creditor was not licensed to do the work, which can defeat a building claim; that the debt is out of time; and that the terms relied on are unfair or penal. Which applies depends on the documents, and we identify the real defence rather than raising everything.
What happens if I miss the deadline in QCAT or court?
The creditor can obtain a decision or judgment by default for the amount claimed plus interest and, in court, costs. A default judgment can be set aside, but you must show a satisfactory explanation for the default, that you applied promptly and that you have a real defence, and you will usually pay the costs of the application. It is far cheaper to respond in time.
My company has been served with a statutory demand. What now?
Act immediately. A company has 21 days from service to pay the debt, secure it to the creditor's satisfaction, or file and serve an application in the Supreme Court or Federal Court to set the demand aside on the basis that the debt is genuinely disputed, that the company has an offsetting claim, or that the demand is defective. The 21 days cannot be extended. If nothing is done, the company is presumed insolvent and the creditor can apply to wind it up. Where the debt is genuinely disputed, the creditor who served the demand usually ends up paying the costs of setting it aside.
I have been served with a bankruptcy notice. What are my options?
A bankruptcy notice requires an individual with a final judgment of $10,000 or more against them to pay within 21 days. Failing to comply is an act of bankruptcy on which a creditor's petition can be based. Within the 21 days you can pay, reach an agreement with the creditor, or apply to the Federal Circuit and Family Court to set the notice aside, for example because you have a counterclaim or set off that you could not have raised in the original proceedings or because the notice is defective. If the judgment itself was entered by default, setting it aside may be the better path.
Can a debt collector contact me at work or threaten legal action?
Debt collectors must comply with the ACCC and ASIC debt collection guideline and the Australian Consumer Law. They must not harass you, contact you at unreasonable times or frequencies, mislead you about the consequences of non payment, or contact your employer other than to confirm employment. If a collector has crossed the line, we can require them to deal only with us and raise the conduct with the regulators. That does not make the debt go away, but it changes the dynamic.
Articles on defending a debt claim
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about defending a debt claim. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Served with a claim: what to do in the first 28 daysA claim served by a Queensland court or QCAT starts a 28 day clock. This article explains what service means, the notice of intention to defend and defence, QCAT responses, what happens if you miss the deadline, how default judgments are set aside and the steps to take in the first week.
- Defences to a debt claim: limitation, set off, defective goods and the ones that do not workNot every invoice is owed. This article explains the defences available to a debt claim in Queensland, including the six year limitation period, set off and counterclaim, defective goods and services, lack of agreement, wrong party and payment, and why some common objections fail.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.