Caravans, boats and machinery sit between cars and ordinary consumer goods in the way the law treats them. They are expensive, they are often bought for leisure or for a small business, and their faults are frequently structural or manufacturing defects that the selling dealer blames on the manufacturer. The consumer guarantees are the main protection, and they are stronger than most buyers realise.
Caravans and the statutory warranty
The statutory warranty for used vehicles under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 does not apply to caravans, which the Act defines as trailers fitted, equipped or used mainly for camping, as a dwelling or for carrying on a trade or business. Motorhomes, which are motor vehicles, are generally covered. A buyer of a used caravan from a dealer therefore has no statutory warranty period, and the dealer may lawfully say so. What the buyer does have is the consumer guarantees, which apply to new and used caravans bought from a dealer and cannot be excluded.
The guarantees for caravans, boats and machinery
A buyer acquires goods as a consumer where the price is $100,000 or less, or where the goods are of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, which covers most caravans and recreational boats whatever the price, or where they are a vehicle or trailer acquired mainly to transport goods on public roads. Machinery bought for a business is covered if the price is within the threshold. The guarantee of acceptable quality requires the goods to be free from defects, safe, durable and fit for their ordinary purposes, judged by the price, the description and any representations. Water ingress in a caravan, delamination, chassis cracking, a boat hull that leaks or an engine that fails well within its expected life are failures of that guarantee. Where the buyer made known a particular purpose, such as off road touring or offshore use, the goods must be fit for it.
Major failures and repeated repairs
Structural and water ingress defects in caravans are commonly major failures because a reasonable buyer who knew of them would not have bought, or because they cannot easily be fixed within a reasonable time. For a major failure the buyer can reject the goods and choose a refund or a replacement, or keep them and recover the reduction in value. The dealer cannot insist on repairing a major failure, and a history of repair attempts that have not fixed the problem is strong evidence that the failure is major. For a minor failure the dealer must repair within a reasonable time, and long delays waiting for parts or for the manufacturer’s approval can exceed that time.
Dealer and manufacturer
The dealer that sold the goods is responsible for the refund or replacement. Dealers frequently refer caravan and boat buyers to the manufacturer under its warranty, and that warranty is a useful additional right, but it does not displace the dealer’s obligations. The manufacturer is directly liable to the buyer for damages, including the reduction in value and consequential loss, and a buyer whose dealer has closed can pursue the manufacturer within three years after first becoming aware, or when they ought reasonably to have become aware, of the failure. Where the dealer and the manufacturer blame each other, the buyer can claim against the dealer and leave the dealer to seek indemnity from the manufacturer.
Consequential loss
Cancelled holidays, accommodation costs, storage, towing and the cost of hiring a replacement are recoverable where they were reasonably foreseeable, which for a caravan bought for touring they usually are. Keep receipts and a diary of the time the goods have been unusable.
Where claims are brought
A caravan is a motor vehicle for the purposes of QCAT’s motor vehicle jurisdiction under section 50A of the Fair Trading Act, so a consumer guarantee claim about a caravan bought from a dealer can be brought in QCAT for amounts up to $100,000. Section 50A also lists the action for damages against a manufacturer under section 271 of the Australian Consumer Law, so a damages claim against a caravan manufacturer can be brought in the same jurisdiction, subject to the same limit and to the orders QCAT is able to make. A caravan claim for more than $100,000 has to be brought in a court, and which court depends on the amount and the relief sought.
Boats, trailers other than caravans and machinery are ordinary goods for this purpose. Claims up to $25,000 can go to QCAT as consumer and trader disputes, and larger money claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. QCAT’s minor civil dispute jurisdiction depends on a claim arising out of a contract between a consumer and a trader, so a claim against a manufacturer that did not sell the goods to the buyer should be checked against that requirement before it is filed.
Evidence
An independent inspection report is usually important for structural and water ingress claims, because dealers often attribute damage to the buyer’s use. Obtain it before the goods go back to the dealer for another repair attempt, photograph everything and keep all repair records.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Queensland Government, Guarantees and warranties for used cars (vehicles not covered)
- Australian Consumer Law, ss 3, 54, 55, 259 to 263, 271 and 273
- QCAT, Motor vehicle disputes
- QCAT, Consumer and trader disputes
- Fair Trading Act 1989 (Qld), ss 50 and 50A
- Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014 (Qld), s 12 and schedule 1 s 3
- Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), schedule 3 (minor civil dispute)
- Magistrates Courts Act 1921 (Qld), ss 2 and 4 (civil limit $150,000)