Car yards are built to produce decisions. Queensland law gives the buyer of a used car from a dealer one business day to reverse the decision, and tightly limits what the dealer can keep if they do. Outside that window, and for new cars, a deposit is governed by the contract and the ordinary law about deposits.
The cooling off period
A buyer of a used car from a licensed motor dealer has a cooling off period of one business day under the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Act 2014. A business day is a day, other than a Sunday or a public holiday, on which the dealership is open, so a contract signed on Friday at a dealership open on Saturday has a period that ends on Saturday. Under section 99, the period starts when the contract becomes enforceable against the dealer and ends when the dealer actually closes on its next business day, provided that is 5pm or later. If the dealer closes earlier than 5pm on that day, the period runs until the dealer’s usual closing time on the business day after it. If the dealer did not give the buyer the required cooling off statement immediately before the contract was signed, or the statement is defective in a material particular, section 104 allows the buyer to avoid the contract by written notice given within seven days after the day property in the vehicle passes to the buyer. Section 105 gives the same right where the contract does not contain the required cooling off clause.
The period does not apply to new vehicles, to vehicles bought at auction or privately, to vehicles sold on consignment for an owner who is not a motor dealer or chattel auctioneer, to caravans or to commercial vehicles built mainly to carry goods or designed to carry more than nine people, other than utilities with a load capacity of one tonne or less. A sale to another motor dealer is also excluded.
Ending the period early
The buyer loses the cooling off right by driving away with the vehicle during the period, other than to take it to an independent mechanic for inspection or for a test drive. Dealers who deliver the car on the day of sale know this. A buyer who wants to preserve the right should leave the car at the yard until the period expires.
How to cancel
The buyer cancels by giving the dealer written notice that they do not wish to proceed, delivered in person, by email or by fax before the period ends. The dealer cannot refuse to accept the notice. Once the period has expired without notice, or the buyer has taken the vehicle, the contract binds the buyer.
The deposit during cooling off
A dealer may treat no more than $100 of a deposit as non refundable during the cooling off period, that being the amount prescribed by section 10 of the Motor Dealers and Chattel Auctioneers Regulation 2014, and must tell the buyer in writing about that condition. If the buyer cancels, the dealer may keep some or all of that $100 and must refund the balance of any larger deposit. If the sale proceeds, the deposit is credited against the price. A dealer who keeps more than $100 from a buyer who cooled off validly is holding money it is not entitled to.
Deposits outside the cooling off period
Where there is no cooling off period, or it has expired, the deposit is governed by the contract. A buyer who withdraws without a legal right to do so is in breach, and a dealer may keep a deposit that is a genuine pre estimate of its loss or that was agreed as a true deposit of a reasonable amount. A dealer cannot keep a deposit where the dealer failed to perform, where the contract was subject to finance that was declined on the agreed terms, where the vehicle was not as described or where the dealer cannot deliver. Terms allowing the dealer to keep the whole deposit regardless of the reason for cancellation are candidates for unfair terms under the Australian Consumer Law and may be void.
Finance conditions are the usual battleground. Read the contract for the finance condition, the lender named and the date by which approval is required, and if finance is declined obtain the decline in writing and notify the dealer before the date.
New cars
There is no cooling off period for new vehicles in Queensland. A deposit on a new car ordered from a dealer is a contractual matter. Where the dealer cannot deliver within the time stated, or the price is increased in a way the contract does not permit, the buyer may be entitled to terminate and recover the deposit. Where the buyer simply changes their mind, the dealer’s rights depend on the contract and on whether its loss is genuine, bearing in mind that a new car ordered to specification can often be sold to another buyer.
Recovering a deposit
Write to the dealer setting out the basis on which the deposit is repayable and a date for payment. Claims up to $25,000 against a dealer are minor civil disputes in QCAT, and where the deposit relates to a dispute about a used vehicle the motor vehicle jurisdiction may apply instead. The Office of Fair Trading, which licenses motor dealers, accepts complaints about dealers who breach the cooling off rules.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.