Some of the most urgent consumer disputes are not about money but about possession. The mechanic will not release the car until a bill the owner disputes is paid. The caravan repairer has had the van for six months. The business that sold a boat has the money and the boat. In each case the owner needs to know whether the other party has any right to hold the goods and how fast they can be made to hand them over.
The repairer’s lien
A person who has improved goods by their work with the owner’s authority has a lien at common law: a right to keep possession of the goods until paid for the work. The lien secures only the charge for the work actually authorised, at the agreed price or, if none was agreed, a reasonable price. It does not secure unrelated debts, earlier unpaid invoices, or storage fees the repairer has unilaterally decided to charge while holding the goods. It is lost if the repairer gives up possession voluntarily, and it is not a right to sell the goods, which requires either a contractual term or a statutory procedure.
Where the bill is disputed, the owner’s practical course is usually to pay it under protest, in writing, stating that payment is made to recover the goods and that the amount is disputed, and then to pursue the overpayment in QCAT. Leaving the goods with the repairer while the dispute runs costs more than it gains, and the repairer’s claim to storage charges accumulates.
Where the repairer did work that was not authorised, or did it so badly that it has no value, the owner can dispute the lien itself, and QCAT or a court can order the goods returned and determine what if anything is owed.
Goods that were paid for and not delivered
A buyer who has paid for specific goods and not received them has a claim for breach of contract. Where the goods are identified and the property in them has passed, the buyer can also sue in detinue for their return. Section 52 of the Sale of Goods Act 1896 allows the court to order specific delivery of specific or ascertained goods where damages would not be an adequate remedy, which is relevant for unique or custom built items. Where the seller has become insolvent, the buyer’s position depends on whether property in the goods had passed, and prompt action matters.
Detinue and conversion
A person who holds another’s goods without right and refuses a proper demand for their return is liable in detinue, for which the court can order return of the goods or payment of their value, plus damages for the period of detention. A person who deals with the goods inconsistently with the owner’s rights, such as by selling them, is liable in conversion for their value. A clear written demand for the return of the goods, identifying them and the place and time for collection, is the step that turns possession into wrongful detention and should be made before any proceeding.
QCAT
In a consumer and trader dispute, QCAT can make an order requiring a party to return goods that relate to the claim and are in their possession or control to a stated person, provided the value of the goods is no more than $25,000, and can combine that order with an order about payment or relief from payment. That makes QCAT a practical forum for a dispute with a repairer or a seller about goods within that value. For goods worth more, the Magistrates Court and the District Court can order delivery up.
Vehicles
A dispute with a motor dealer about a vehicle it is holding, including a vehicle returned for warranty work, can fall within QCAT’s motor vehicle jurisdiction up to $100,000. A vehicle held by an independent repairer is a consumer and trader dispute. In either case, do not attempt to remove the vehicle without the holder’s consent, which can amount to an offence and will complicate the civil claim.
Storage and uncollected goods
A business that has been asked to hold goods and has not been paid for storage has a contractual claim for the storage charges, and legislation regulates how uncollected goods may eventually be disposed of after notice. An owner who has left goods uncollected for a long period should expect to pay reasonable storage before recovering them, and should act before the disposal process is engaged.
Evidence
Keep the quote and any authorisation for work, the invoices, the messages and photographs of the goods when delivered. For a repairer dispute, an independent assessment of the work done and its value supports both the recovery of the goods and the claim about the bill.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.