Boundaries on the ground do not always match the plan. A survey done for a sale, a pool or an extension reveals that the neighbour’s garage is 400 millimetres over the line, or that the fence everyone assumed was the boundary sits two metres inside one lot. Queensland deals with a building over the boundary through the encroachment provisions of the Property Law Act 2023, which replaced the equivalent provisions of the 1974 Act. A misplaced fence is treated differently, as explained below.
What counts as an encroachment
An encroachment is an encroachment by a building onto land, and includes overhang and intrusion on, into or under the soil. A building is a substantial structure of a permanent character and includes part of such a structure, such as a wall. The overhanging eaves of a house are therefore covered. An ordinary dividing fence is unlikely to be a building for this purpose, and whether a retaining wall, paving or an awning qualifies depends on its substance and permanence. A dividing fence that is off the boundary is dealt with under the Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011, under which QCAT can decide the line on which a fence is to be built. A structure built wholly on someone else’s land in the genuine but mistaken belief that the builder owned that land is dealt with separately under section 188, which does not apply to fences.
Who can apply
A person with an interest in the land onto which the encroachment extends, called the affected owner, or a person with an interest in the land from which it extends, called the encroaching owner, may apply to the Supreme Court for relief. The affected owner usually wants the building removed or wants to be paid for the land. The encroaching owner usually wants the land transferred or an easement so the building can stay. The court has a broad discretion and can make any order the nature of the case requires.
The orders available
Under section 185 the court may order the affected owner to transfer or lease the land affected, or to grant an easement or another interest in it, may order the encroaching owner to pay compensation, and may order that the encroachment be modified or removed. It can also make orders about land reasonably required as curtilage and for access, and require a plan of survey. In deciding, the court may take into account who is applying, the circumstances in which the encroachment was made, its nature and extent, the purposes for which it may be used, the situation and value of the land affected, the operation of the Planning Act 2016 including the planning scheme, the loss or damage to the affected owner, and the loss or damage the encroaching owner would suffer if removal were required. Removal is more likely where it is practical and the encroachment is more than trivial, or where the encroaching owner behaved badly. Where a substantial building has stood for years, the court is more likely to order a transfer with compensation.
Compensation
Where the court orders compensation, section 186 sets a minimum. If the encroaching owner satisfies the court that the encroachment was not intentional and did not arise from negligence, the minimum is the market value of the interest in the land affected. Otherwise the minimum is three times that market value. In deciding whether to award more than the minimum, the court must take into account the value of the interest, the loss or damage to the affected owner, including from any order made in favour of the encroaching owner, and the circumstances in which the encroachment was made. Because the encroaching owner carries the burden, records showing how the encroachment came about, such as the original survey and building approval, matter.
Adverse possession does not help
Owners sometimes assume that an encroachment which has been in place for more than 12 years has ripened into ownership. In Queensland it has not. Section 98 of the Land Title Act 1994 prevents an application for registration based on adverse possession where the possession arises from an encroachment, and expressly includes land enclosed by a fence that is not on the true boundary. The encroachment provisions, not adverse possession, are the route to regularising the position.
Getting the facts right
The starting point is an identification survey by a cadastral surveyor showing the true boundary and the extent of the encroachment. That survey is the evidence on which everything else rests. A valuer then assesses the market value of the land affected. With those two documents, the parties can usually negotiate a transfer and a boundary realignment without the court, since the registration of a new plan and the transfer of the sliver of land is all that is ultimately needed. The court is for the cases where one owner refuses to engage or insists on removal.
Costs
The costs of the application are in the court’s discretion. An encroaching owner who caused the problem will generally be expected to meet the costs of regularising it, including the survey, the plan and the registration fees, and often the affected owner’s reasonable legal costs.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), ss 183 to 186 (encroachment of buildings) and s 188 (improvements under mistake of title)
- Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), s 98 (adverse possession not available for encroachments)
- Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 (Qld), s 35 (orders about fencing work)