Few things generate as many body corporate disputes as a dog in a unit or a renovation the committee did not approve. The law in Queensland changed significantly on 1 May 2024 for animals, and the general duty to act reasonably governs most of the rest.
Pets: the new rules
Section 169B of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997, together with amendments to the regulation modules, now prevents a by law from prohibiting the keeping of animals on a lot or on common property, or restricting the number, type or size of animals that may be kept. A by law made before 1 May 2024 is enforceable only to the extent it is consistent with section 169B. What a by law can still do is require an occupier to obtain the written approval of the body corporate or the committee before keeping or bringing an animal onto a lot or the common property. The approval can be given on conditions that are reasonable and appropriate in the circumstances, and must not be unreasonably withheld. Guide, hearing and assistance dogs are outside the section. Section 181 of the Act gives a person with a disability who relies on one the right to keep it on their lot, and a by law cannot exclude or restrict that right.
How long the body corporate has to decide
The time for a decision depends on the regulation module that applies to the scheme and on who has power to decide the request. Under the Standard Module, where the committee can decide, section 58A requires the request to be made in writing to the secretary and decided by the committee within 21 days after it is made. If the committee does not decide within that period, it is taken to have approved the request.
Where the request can be decided only at a general meeting, sections 82A and 82B apply instead. A general meeting must be called within 21 days after the request is made, with the request on the agenda as a motion, and the body corporate must decide within six weeks after the notice of the meeting is given. The request is taken to be approved if the meeting is not called in time, or if it is called but the decision is not made within the six weeks. The Accommodation, Commercial and Small Schemes Modules contain equivalent provisions. In either case the body corporate must give written notice of the decision, including a deemed decision.
Grounds for refusal
Approval may be refused only if the body corporate or the committee is satisfied, on reasonable grounds, of one of the matters listed in section 169B(6) of the Act. They include that keeping the animal would pose an unacceptable risk to the health and safety of an owner or occupier that cannot reasonably be managed by conditions, that keeping it would contravene a law, that the animal is a regulated dog under the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008, that keeping it would unreasonably interfere with another occupier’s use and enjoyment of their lot or the common property, or with native fauna, in a way that cannot reasonably be managed by conditions, and that the occupier does not agree to reasonable conditions. A regulation module may prescribe further matters. Section 169B(5) declares a refusal on the ground that no pets are allowed to be unreasonable, and a general preference not to have animals in the building is not one of the listed matters.
Conditions can address matters such as keeping the animal within the lot, carrying it across common property, waste and noise. Under section 169B(7) an approval may be withdrawn if the occupier does not comply with the conditions stated in the written approval. Outside that power, a body corporate that wants to act against an animal already approved generally has to use the by law enforcement process.
Challenging a pet decision
An owner refused approval, or given conditions they consider unreasonable, can apply to the Commissioner’s office for conciliation and, if that fails, adjudication. An adjudicator can set aside a refusal that does not fit the permitted grounds and substitute an approval with conditions. A body corporate that wants to refuse needs evidence, such as a veterinary or behavioural report for a dog said to be dangerous, or records of complaints for an animal said to be interfering with others.
Renovations and improvements
The position for works is different because there is no equivalent of section 169B. Whether approval is needed, and who gives it, depends on the scheme’s by laws and the regulation module. Works wholly within a lot that do not affect the exterior, the structure, common property or utility infrastructure usually need no approval. Works that change the external appearance of the building, penetrate common property such as a slab or a load bearing wall, or involve installing air conditioning, solar panels or hard flooring commonly require approval under the by laws, and improvements to common property for the benefit of a lot are governed by the module, with the committee able to approve smaller improvements and larger ones needing a general meeting resolution.
The constraint on the body corporate is section 94(2) of the Act: it must act reasonably in anything it does in carrying out its functions, including making or not making a decision. A refusal that is based on a genuine concern about structural integrity, water penetration, noise transmission or the appearance of the building, supported by advice, will usually stand. A refusal based on personal preference, inconsistency with approvals given to other owners, or a committee member’s own objection will usually not. Adjudicators can declare a refusal unreasonable and order the body corporate to give approval on conditions.
Works done without approval
An owner who proceeds without an approval that was required faces a by law contravention notice and, ultimately, an adjudicator’s order to remove the works or restore the common property, along with liability for any damage. Where the works were reasonable and would have been approved had the owner asked, adjudicators often grant approval after the event, sometimes on conditions. The owner is in a far weaker position than if approval had been sought first, and the costs of the dispute will typically fall on them.
Practical advice
For pets, put the request in writing to the secretary, give details of the animal, offer reasonable conditions and note the date. If the period for a decision passes without one, check which module applies and who had power to decide before relying on a deemed approval, and ask the body corporate for written notice of the deemed decision. For renovations, read the by laws and the module, ask the committee what information it needs, and obtain the engineering or acoustic advice before applying. If a refusal comes, ask for the reasons in writing.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997 (Qld), ss 94(2), 169B, 181 and 450
- Body Corporate and Community Management (Standard Module) Regulation 2020 (Qld), ss 58A, 58B, 82A and 82B
- Body Corporate and Community Management and Other Legislation Amendment Regulation 2024 (Qld)
- Queensland Government, About adjudication