Fencing disputes in the country are about kilometres rather than metres, and about cattle in the neighbour’s crop rather than a view of the clothesline. The Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 applies to rural Queensland with specific rules for pastoral land that differ from the suburban ones.
Pastoral land
Section 18 defines pastoral land as rural land of more than half a hectare used for grazing stock on a commercial basis, whether or not it is also used for residential purposes. For two adjoining parcels of pastoral land, section 13 provides that a sufficient dividing fence is one sufficient to restrain livestock of the type grazing on each parcel. A four barb fence that holds cattle may not be sufficient where one neighbour runs goats, and the standard is set by the stock actually grazed, not by what one owner would prefer. Where the owners cannot agree on what is sufficient, QCAT decides.
There is a gap for cropping country. Under section 8(3) the fencing chapter does not apply at all between two adjoining parcels of agricultural land, which is rural land of more than half a hectare used for commercial cropping, so two cropping neighbours are left to their own agreement and the general law. Where one parcel is agricultural and the other pastoral or residential, the Act applies, and because neither of the specific standards fits, the sufficient fence is whatever the owners agree or QCAT decides.
Under section 21 adjoining owners contribute equally to a sufficient fence, and an owner who wants a higher standard pays the extra. The notice to contribute, the one month period to agree and the requirement to apply to QCAT within two months after the notice is given apply exactly as they do in town, and a neighbour who builds first and asks later generally cannot recover.
Fences off the boundary
Rural boundaries often follow creeks and gullies where a fence cannot sensibly be built. Section 12 recognises a fence on a line other than the boundary as a dividing fence where natural features make a boundary fence impracticable, or where pastoral parcels are separated by a watercourse or other feature that will not stop stock at all times. Section 20 requires new or replacement fences to be on the boundary except to the extent that is impracticable, so an owner who wants a give and take fence needs the neighbour’s agreement or a QCAT order.
Owners across a road
Section 15 contains a provision peculiar to rural land. The owners of agricultural or pastoral land on either side of a road can be adjoining owners under the Act if they agree, or if QCAT decides that a fence has been used or could reasonably be used as a dividing fence for the two parcels. That means a responsibility to contribute can attach to a fence on one side of a road, which matters where unfenced road reserves are used for grazing.
When the neighbour subdivides
The most contentious rural fencing situation is a housing estate replacing the farm next door. New residents want a residential standard fence; the grazier wants the stock fence that was always there. Section 22 answers this. Where adjoining land previously consisted of two parcels of prescribed rural land and one is developed residentially, the owner of the remaining rural land is liable to contribute only to a fence that would have been sufficient for the two rural parcels before the development. The extra cost of the fence the residential side needs is borne by the developed land. Section 23 extends the same principle to prescribed land above a size set by regulation.
Lessees
Many grazing properties are leased. Section 24 divides the owner’s share of fencing costs between owner and lessee according to the unexpired term of the lease when the work is done: the owner pays all of it where less than five years remain, 75 per cent where five to seven years remain, half where seven to twelve years remain, and nothing where twelve or more years remain, the lessee paying the balance. The lessee is only liable if the owner passes on the notices as soon as practicable, and a lessee who is given the notices has the same rights as the owner in QCAT and must agree to any settlement.
Straying stock
Fencing disputes often arise after stock have strayed. The Act deals with the fence, not the damage. An owner whose stock damage a neighbour’s crop or pasture may be liable at common law, and under local laws, depending on the circumstances and the state of the fence each owner was obliged to maintain. Section 26 of the Act does not mention livestock. It requires an owner to restore, at their own cost, a fence damaged or destroyed by the owner’s negligent or deliberate act or omission, which can include failing to keep stock contained.
Practical steps
Agree the line and the standard in writing before anyone buys wire. Give the formal notice with a quote even to a neighbour you get on with, because the notice is what makes the contribution enforceable. If the property is leased, involve the lessee from the start. And photograph the existing fence before any work.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.