Agistment is a common arrangement across rural Queensland. A landholder with spare grass takes another producer’s cattle, horses or sheep for a weekly or monthly fee per head. The arrangement is often made over the phone, confirmed by text and never written down. When the client stops paying, the landholder is holding the client’s most valuable asset and wants to know whether they can keep it until they are paid.
No lien at general law
The short answer is that there is no general law lien over agisted stock for unpaid fees. The common law recognised a lien for a person who improved goods by their skill and labour, but courts have long held that an agistor who simply provides pasture does not improve the animals in the relevant sense. In Fearnley v Finlay [2014] QCA 155 the Queensland Court of Appeal also held that the Storage Liens Act 1973 did not assist an agistor, because the Act is directed at warehouse style storage of goods rather than the grazing of livestock. A landholder who refuses to release stock on the basis of an assumed lien is acting without legal right.
Contractual rights
A right to retain stock, and to sell them to recover fees, can be created by agreement. A well drafted agistment agreement will provide that the landholder may retain the stock until all fees are paid, may sell the stock after notice if fees remain unpaid for a stated period, and may apply the proceeds to the debt and the costs of sale. A clause of that kind is a security interest under the Personal Property Securities Act 2009. To be effective against the client’s financier and other creditors, and to survive the client’s insolvency, it should be registered on the Personal Property Securities Register. An unregistered interest is enforceable against the client but can be defeated by a bank with a registered interest over the herd, which is the usual position for a commercial producer.
The agreement should also deal with the matters that produce disputes: the fee and when it is payable, who is responsible for mustering, husbandry, veterinary costs and losses, how stock numbers are verified, the notice required to end the arrangement and what happens to stock left behind.
The risk of holding stock
A landholder who retains stock without a contractual right, or who sells them without one, is liable in conversion or detinue for the value of the animals and any consequential loss, such as a missed sale at peak prices. That liability can far exceed the fees owed. A landholder who wishes to apply pressure should instead give the client written notice to remove the stock by a stated date, make a formal demand for the fees and sue for them.
Duty of care
Whatever the dispute, both the owner and the person in charge of the animals owe them a duty of care under the Animal Care and Protection Act 2001. A landholder who has stock on their land cannot withhold feed or water as leverage, and an owner who abandons stock in a dispute may be prosecuted. Agreements should allocate responsibility for welfare, and in a dispute the landholder should document the condition of the stock and the costs of keeping them.
Recovering the fees
Agistment fees are a debt. For amounts up to $25,000 the claim is a minor debt dispute in QCAT; above that it is brought in the Magistrates Court up to $150,000, and the District Court above that. The evidence is the agreement, or if there is none, the messages that show what was agreed, together with the invoices, the records of stock numbers and the payments made. Where the arrangement was oral, the landholder claims the agreed rate if it can be proved, or a reasonable rate for the agistment actually provided. A claim for the cost of husbandry, feed or veterinary treatment the landholder provided depends on whether the client asked for or agreed to it.
Stock left behind
Where a client simply disappears and leaves stock on the land, the landholder faces ongoing costs and no clear right to deal with the animals. The options include a court order authorising sale and application of the proceeds, and the brands and stock identification systems can help locate the owner. Taking the stock to the saleyards without authority is a conversion.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Fearnley v Finlay [2014] QCA 155
- Murdoch Lawyers, Agistment: non payment of agistment fees and claiming a lien over cattle (discussing Fearnley v Finlay [2014] QCA 155)
- Legal 500, Smooth grazing: trouble free agistment
- Business Queensland, Duty of care for agisted animals
- Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), schedule 3