A deposit is paid in good faith to hold a car, book a venue, commission a kitchen or secure a tradesperson’s time. When the arrangement falls through, the money is often simply kept, and the business says the deposit was non refundable. Whether that is right depends on why the arrangement ended and on what the money actually was.
Deposit or part payment
The law distinguishes between a deposit and a part payment of the price. A true deposit is paid as an earnest, security for the payer’s performance, and the parties agree that it may be forfeited if the payer fails to complete. A part payment is simply the first instalment of the price, and if the contract ends the recipient must return it, subject to a claim for any loss actually suffered. Whether a payment is one or the other depends on the terms and the circumstances; calling it a deposit is strong evidence but not conclusive.
Even a true deposit is only forfeitable if the amount is reasonable as a deposit. Ten per cent is the conventional figure for land, and amounts in that range are routinely upheld. A deposit that is out of all proportion to any loss the recipient could suffer may be treated as a penalty, in which case the recipient can keep only its actual loss and must return the rest.
Who ended the contract and why
If the payer simply changed their mind and withdrew, and the payment was a true deposit of a reasonable amount, the recipient can usually keep it. If the payer withdrew because the recipient could not or would not perform, because the goods were not as described or because the recipient breached the contract, the payer is entitled to terminate and recover the deposit in full. If the contract contained a condition, such as finance or an inspection, and the condition was not met, the deposit is refundable on the terms of the condition. The question is usually who was in breach when the contract came to an end.
Where the contract was never concluded, because the parties did not agree the essential terms, the payment was made for a consideration that failed and is recoverable.
Consumer law
Where the payer is a consumer or a small business and the contract is a standard form, the unfair contract terms provisions of the Australian Consumer Law apply. A term allowing the business to keep the whole deposit whatever the reason for cancellation, including the business’s own default or cancellation, is a strong candidate for an unfair term and is void if found to be one. Since November 2023 a business that proposes or relies on an unfair term is also exposed to penalties. Statements that deposits are never refundable, where the law requires a refund, can be misleading conduct.
Where the deposit was paid for goods or services and the supplier has failed to supply them, the consumer guarantees give a right to a refund of amounts paid in addition to any damages.
Cooling off and statutory refunds
Some transactions carry statutory cooling off rights. A buyer of a used car from a Queensland dealer may cool off within one business day, with the dealer entitled to retain up to $100. A home owner under a regulated domestic building contract, which means a contract for domestic building work worth more than $3,300, may withdraw within five business days after receiving a copy of the signed contract, with the contractor keeping $100 and reasonable out of pocket costs. A consumer who entered an unsolicited consumer agreement, such as a door to door or telemarketing sale, has 10 business days. Residential property buyers have five business days with a 0.25 per cent termination penalty.
Recovering the money
Write to the recipient setting out why the deposit is repayable, the amount and a date for payment. If it is not paid, claims up to $25,000 go to QCAT as minor civil disputes, which can order payment or relief from payment in consumer and trader matters; larger claims go to the Magistrates Court. Keep the receipt, the quote or contract, the terms and conditions you were shown and the messages about the cancellation. If the recipient has gone out of business or is a company that has been deregistered, recovery may be impractical, and an early check of the entity is worthwhile.
Before you pay
Ask whether the payment is a deposit or a part payment, what happens if either side cancels, and get the answer in writing. Pay by a traceable method. And never pay a deposit into an account that does not match the business you are dealing with.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.