Parents help children into houses. Siblings cover each other’s shortfalls. Partners pay off each other’s debts. Very little of it is documented, and when relationships end the same payment is remembered by one side as a loan and by the other as a gift. Queensland courts decide these disputes on evidence of what was intended at the time the money changed hands, and the party who kept the better records usually wins.
Who has to prove what
The person who says the money must be repaid bears the onus of proving that it was a loan. A loan is a payment made on the understanding, shared by both parties, that it would be repaid. A gift is a payment made with no expectation of repayment. The court asks what the parties actually intended when the payment was made, judged by their words and conduct then, and gives little weight to what they now say they meant.
The presumption of advancement
Where a parent pays money to a child, or a husband to a wife, the law presumes the payment was intended as a gift. The High Court confirmed in Bosanac v Commissioner of Taxation [2022] HCA 34 that the presumption of advancement remains part of Australian law, while emphasising that it and the related presumption of resulting trust are only starting points that give way to evidence of what the parties actually intended at the time. The presumption is rebuttable by evidence that a loan was intended, but it means that a parent who paid a deposit for a child’s house and later wants it back must positively prove the loan. Between siblings, friends, de facto partners in some situations and other relatives there is no presumption either way, and the question is simply one of evidence.
Evidence that matters
The most persuasive evidence is a document created at the time: a loan agreement, however informal, an email or text message saying the money is a loan and when it will be repaid, a bank transfer reference reading loan, or a note in the payer’s records. Next comes conduct consistent with a loan: repayments, however small, interest payments, references to the debt in later messages, or the recipient’s acknowledgment of it in a will, a financial statement or a family law disclosure. Evidence that the payer treated the money as gone, such as describing it as a gift to others or making no demand for years, points the other way.
Family law proceedings between a child and their spouse frequently bring these disputes to a head, because a parent’s loan is a liability of the relationship while a gift is a contribution by one party. Parents in that situation should expect the other spouse to contest the loan vigorously, and the court to look hard at the documents.
Terms of the loan
Where a loan is established but nothing was said about repayment, the law treats it as repayable on demand, with no interest unless agreed. Where repayment was tied to an event, such as the sale of a house or a change in circumstances, the loan becomes due when the event occurs, and a loan that is only repayable when the borrower can afford it requires evidence that they can.
Limitation periods
A loan repayable on demand is generally treated as due from the moment it is made, so the six year limitation period under the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 runs from the advance, not from a later demand. Family loans made many years ago can therefore be out of time. Two things revive the period: a written acknowledgment of the debt signed by the borrower, or a part payment, each of which starts the six years again under sections 35 and 36. A parent holding an old undocumented loan should look for any repayment or written acknowledgment within the last six years before assuming the debt is recoverable.
Loans secured over property
Where a family loan was used to buy property and the lender’s contribution was intended to be protected, the lender may have an interest under a resulting or constructive trust rather than a simple debt, which has different consequences and is not subject to the same limitation analysis. That is a question for specific advice.
Where the claim is brought
A family loan is a debt. Claims up to $25,000 are brought in QCAT as minor debt claims, larger claims in the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. The hearing will turn on the documents and on the credibility of the people who made the arrangement.
Before the money goes
For those reading this before lending: write it down. A one page document signed by both parties recording the amount, that it is a loan, when and how it is repayable and whether interest is charged would prevent many of these disputes.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.