Most debts are paid, eventually, without anyone going to court. The letter of demand is the step that turns an overdue invoice into a problem the debtor has to deal with, and a good one is specific, calm and credible. A bad one invites the debtor to argue, or to ignore it.
What a demand should contain
Identify the parties correctly. A demand addressed to a trading name rather than the company or person who contracted with you is a demand against no one. Search the ABN and the ASIC register to confirm the legal entity.
State the basis of the debt: the contract or invoice, the date, what was supplied and the agreed price. State the amount claimed, showing how it is made up, including any contractual interest or late fee the agreement allows and the rate. If the agreement does not provide for interest, do not claim it in the demand; the court can award interest later, but the demand should be for what is actually owed.
Set a deadline. Seven to fourteen days is usual. State what will happen if payment is not made by then, and mean it: a claim in QCAT or the Magistrates Court for the debt, interest and costs. Offer to provide copies of the documents, or attach them. Give payment details.
Tone
Keep the letter factual and free of adjectives. A demand that accuses the debtor of dishonesty, threatens to tell their customers or sets out a grievance at length gives the debtor something to respond to other than the debt. A demand that simply sets out the facts, the amount and the consequence is far harder to answer.
What to avoid
Do not threaten to report the debtor to the police or to a regulator in order to obtain payment of a civil debt. Doing so can amount to a criminal offence, and it undermines the demand. Do not threaten steps you do not intend to take, such as bankruptcy proceedings over a debt below the threshold, because the debtor’s adviser will know. Do not contact the debtor’s employer, family or customers about the debt. Do not add charges the agreement does not allow. If the debtor is an individual and you are a business, remember that debt collection conduct is regulated and that harassment and coercion are prohibited under the Australian Consumer Law.
Interest and acknowledgments
If the agreement provides for interest, claim it and show the calculation. If it does not, consider whether the demand should offer to forgo interest for prompt payment, which is a concession that costs little. Be aware that a debtor’s written acknowledgment of the debt, or a part payment, restarts the six year limitation period under the Limitation of Actions Act 1974, so a reply that says the debtor accepts the debt but cannot pay yet is valuable and should be kept.
Offers to settle
Where the debtor disputes part of the debt, a demand can be paired with a written offer to accept a reduced sum in full satisfaction if paid by a date. Make the offer in a separate letter marked without prejudice except as to costs, so that it cannot be used against you on the merits but can be shown to the court on costs if you later recover more than the offer. Once proceedings have started, the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules formalise this with offers to settle that carry costs consequences.
When the deadline passes
Follow up. A short second letter confirming that the deadline has passed and that a claim will be filed, or simply filing the claim, maintains credibility. For debts up to $25,000, QCAT’s minor debt jurisdiction is the usual forum and the debtor has 28 days to respond to the claim. Larger debts go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. Where the debtor is a company and the debt is undisputed, a statutory demand can be considered. The demand letter is the first document the tribunal or court will see, which is another reason to get it right.
Letters from a lawyer
A demand on a law firm’s letterhead is taken more seriously by many debtors, and a lawyer will check the entity, the contract and the amount before sending it.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.