When one party to a contract for the sale of land refuses to complete, the other has a choice. They can accept the refusal, terminate and claim damages, or they can insist on the bargain and ask a court to order the defaulter to settle. The second remedy is specific performance, and for land it is more readily available than for most other contracts.
Why land is different
Courts treat every parcel of land as unique, so damages are presumed to be an inadequate remedy for a buyer who loses it. The same presumption applies, by a kind of mutuality, to sellers. The result is that a court will usually order a defaulting party to complete a valid contract for the sale of land, provided the party seeking the order has done what the contract required of them and there is no good reason in fairness to refuse it.
What the applicant must show
The party seeking specific performance must prove a binding contract, their own readiness, willingness and ability to complete, and the other party’s failure or refusal. A buyer must be able to show the funds were available on the settlement date, or would have been available had the seller indicated an intention to settle. A seller must show clear title and the ability to deliver vacant possession or the agreed tenancy.
The applicant must also not have terminated. A party who sends a termination notice and then changes their mind cannot generally revive the contract. The decision between terminating and affirming must be made deliberately and promptly, and a party who equivocates for weeks may be found to have elected one way or the other by their conduct.
Defences
Specific performance is discretionary. A court may refuse it where the applicant has been guilty of misrepresentation or sharp practice, where hardship to the defaulting party would be out of all proportion to the benefit to the applicant, where the applicant delayed unreasonably, or where completion has become impossible, for example because the seller has sold to a third party who has registered the transfer. In those cases the remedy is damages instead, and the court can award damages in addition to or in substitution for specific performance.
Which court
The District Court has jurisdiction to order specific performance of a contract for the sale of land where the value of the property does not exceed its monetary limit. That limit is $750,000 and rises to $1.5 million for proceedings started on or after 1 January 2027. Above the limit the claim is brought in the Supreme Court. Claims often include alternative relief: specific performance, or if that is not ordered, damages for loss of bargain and the return of the deposit.
Protecting the position with a caveat
A buyer under a contract has an equitable interest in the land that supports a caveat under the Land Title Act 1994. A caveat prevents the seller from registering a transfer to someone else while the dispute is resolved. It is not a step to take lightly. A caveat lapses three months after lodgement unless the caveator has started a proceeding to establish the interest and notified the Registrar, and the seller can serve a notice that shortens that period to 14 days. A caveat lodged without reasonable cause exposes the caveator to compensation for any loss it causes, so the buyer’s entitlement should be clear before it is lodged.
Damages as the alternative
A party who prefers to walk away terminates and claims damages. For a seller that means resale at a loss, holding costs and the costs of the second sale, less the forfeited deposit. For a buyer it means the difference between the contract price and the market value at the date of breach, together with wasted costs. Damages are measured at the date of termination or when the innocent party should reasonably have gone back to the market.
Deciding which way to go
The choice depends on what you actually want. A buyer who has found a better house will prefer damages. A buyer who has sold their own home to fund the purchase usually wants the property, and should hold the contract open, lodge a caveat and start proceedings promptly. A seller with a rising market may prefer to resell; a seller with a falling market may want to compel completion. The decision needs to be made before any notice is sent, because the notice fixes the election.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68(1)(b)(iii)
- Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 (Qld), ss 2 and 62 (District Court monetary limit $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027)
- Land Title Act 1994 (Qld), ss 122, 126 and 130 (caveats)
- Queensland Law Society, REIQ property contracts