Before a dispute can be decided, it has to be filed somewhere. Queensland has a tribunal and three levels of court with civil jurisdiction, and the right one depends mainly on how much is in issue and sometimes on what the dispute is about. Filing in the wrong place wastes time and money and can affect the costs you recover.
QCAT
The Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal’s minor civil disputes jurisdiction covers debts, consumer and trader contract claims, vehicle property damage and dividing fences up to $25,000, with parties generally representing themselves and bearing their own costs. QCAT also has specialist jurisdictions conferred by other Acts with different limits: motor vehicle disputes against licensed dealers up to $100,000; retail shop lease disputes, after mediation through the Queensland Small Business Commissioner, up to the District Court’s monetary limit; domestic building disputes with no monetary limit and commercial building disputes up to $50,000 unless the parties consent; body corporate matters in defined circumstances; and review of government decisions such as blue card negative notices and dangerous dog declarations. In those specialist jurisdictions the ordinary monetary limit and the usual costs position may differ.
The Magistrates Court
The Magistrates Court hears civil claims up to $150,000. It is the forum for most unpaid invoices, loans, deposits, consumer and services disputes and property damage claims that exceed QCAT’s limit or that do not fit its definitions, such as a dispute between two private individuals about a car sale. Proceedings follow the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, with a claim and statement of claim, a defence, disclosure and a trial, and costs generally follow the event on a scale fixed for the court. Simplified procedures apply to smaller claims.
The District Court
The District Court hears claims above the Magistrates Court limit up to $750,000. The Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 raises that limit to $1.5 million for proceedings started on or after 1 January 2027 (proceedings already on foot stay subject to the $750,000 limit), which will bring many disputes currently heard in the Supreme Court into the District Court. Section 68 of the District Court of Queensland Act 1967 also gives the court jurisdiction in particular matters within the limit, including specific performance of contracts for the sale of land, applications for the sale of co owned property and family provision applications. Costs follow the event on the District Court scale.
The Supreme Court
The Supreme Court has unlimited civil jurisdiction and hears claims above the District Court limit and matters reserved to it regardless of amount, including probate and the administration of estates, most applications for equitable relief such as injunctions and declarations outside the lower courts’ powers, statutory rights of use and encroachment orders under the Property Law Act 2023, and corporate insolvency. It also hears appeals from the District Court and, through the Court of Appeal, from QCAT’s appeal tribunal on questions of law.
Matters with a fixed forum
Some disputes go to a particular forum whatever the amount. Retail shop lease disputes must go through the Small Business Commissioner’s mediation before QCAT. Dividing fence disputes go to QCAT. Body corporate disputes about by laws and management go to the Commissioner for Body Corporate and Community Management’s conciliation and adjudication before QCAT. Residential building disputes go through the QBCC’s process before QCAT. Insurance disputes within AFCA’s limits can go to AFCA or to a court. Reviews of government decisions go to QCAT. Checking the enabling legislation before filing is part of choosing the forum.
Claiming less to stay in a lower forum
A claimant can abandon the excess of a claim above a court’s limit to bring it within that court. That is permanent, and it is a commercial decision that weighs the excess against the cost and time saved.
Filing in the wrong court
A proceeding filed in a court that lacks jurisdiction can be transferred to the correct court under the Civil Proceedings Act 2011, and a proceeding filed in a higher court than necessary can be transferred down. The costs consequences matter: a claimant who recovers an amount within a lower court’s jurisdiction after suing in a higher court may have costs limited to the lower court’s scale. Where the amount is uncertain, the court in which the claim is likely to be decided is the right choice.
Cost and time
QCAT is usually the quickest and cheapest forum but offers little costs recovery and limited remedies. The Magistrates Court is the workhorse for mid range claims with costs recovery on a modest scale. The District and Supreme Courts have fuller procedures and higher costs, and recovery on the standard basis typically returns only a portion of actual legal costs. The forum should be chosen with those economics in mind, and the decision about whether to pursue a claim at all often turns on them.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 (Qld), ss 2 and 62 (District Court monetary limit $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027)
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68
- Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), schedule 3
- QCAT, Motor vehicle disputes
- QCAT, Domestic and commercial building disputes
- Queensland Small Business Commissioner, Leasing disputes