The first question most people ask about a dispute is whether they can make the other side pay their legal costs. The answer depends on where the dispute is heard, how it ends and what offers were made along the way. Understanding the rules at the start changes how a dispute should be run.
QCAT: each party bears its own costs
Section 100 of the QCAT Act provides that each party bears their own costs unless the Act or an enabling Act provides otherwise. Section 102 allows QCAT to order costs where the interests of justice require it, having regard to matters such as a party’s unreasonable conduct, the complexity of the matter, the relative strengths of the parties’ cases and their financial circumstances, but for minor civil disputes the costs that can be awarded are limited to the amounts stated in the rules, essentially the filing fee. Costs orders in other QCAT jurisdictions are made more often, particularly in building and retail lease matters where the parties are represented and one has behaved unreasonably, but they remain the exception. The practical effect is that a party in QCAT should assume that their legal costs will not be recovered and should weigh them against the amount in dispute.
The courts: costs follow the event
In the Magistrates, District and Supreme Courts the general rule under the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules is that costs follow the event: the unsuccessful party pays the successful party’s costs. The court retains a discretion and can depart from the rule where the successful party failed on substantial issues, behaved unreasonably or recovered far less than claimed. Costs are usually assessed on the standard basis, which allows the costs necessary or proper for the attainment of justice according to a scale fixed for each court. Standard costs usually leave a shortfall against what a party actually paid their lawyers, and the shortfall is often larger in the Magistrates Court where the scale is modest. The winner therefore still bears a real cost, and the loser pays both their own costs and a substantial part of the winner’s.
Indemnity costs, which cover all costs reasonably incurred, are awarded where a party’s conduct warrants it, for example where allegations of fraud were made and not proved, where a party pursued a hopeless case, or where a formal offer was unreasonably refused.
Offers to settle
Chapter 9 part 5 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules formalises offers to settle. A plaintiff who makes an offer that the defendant does not accept, and who then obtains a judgment no less favourable than the offer, is generally entitled to costs on the indemnity basis from the day of the offer. A defendant who makes an offer the plaintiff does not accept, where the plaintiff then obtains a judgment no more favourable than the offer, is generally entitled to their costs from the day of the offer, with the plaintiff recovering only costs up to that day. The rules reverse the ordinary presumption and make a well judged offer the most powerful costs tool available.
Calderbank offers, made in correspondence marked without prejudice except as to costs, operate outside the rules and give the court a discretion to award indemnity costs where refusing the offer was unreasonable. They are useful before proceedings start and in QCAT, where the formal rules do not apply, although in QCAT they bear only on the interests of justice discretion.
Security for costs and costs against non parties
A defendant facing a claim from a company with few assets, or from a plaintiff outside Australia, can apply for security for costs, requiring money to be paid into court or a guarantee provided before the claim proceeds. Costs can in some circumstances be ordered against a non party who funded or controlled the litigation.
Family provision and probate
Costs in family provision applications are in the court’s discretion. A successful applicant usually recovers costs from the estate; an unsuccessful applicant may be ordered to pay the estate’s costs, and the older practice of paying everyone’s costs from the estate regardless of outcome has receded. Executors who act reasonably in defending the will have their costs paid from the estate. In probate disputes about validity, costs may come from the estate where the deceased’s conduct caused the litigation, each party may bear their own where there were reasonable grounds for investigation, and an unsuccessful party who pursued a challenge without reasonable grounds pays. Offers to settle affect costs in these matters as in any other.
Review of government decisions
In QCAT review matters each party usually bears their own costs, and orders against unsuccessful applicants are rare, which keeps review of blue card, worker screening and animal management decisions accessible.
Planning for costs
Costs shape strategy. In QCAT the amount at stake must justify the legal spend without recovery. In the courts the prospect of recovering standard costs supports pursuing a sound claim, and the risk of paying the other side’s costs makes a realistic assessment of prospects important before filing. In every forum, a well judged offer made early protects the party who makes it and puts pressure on the party who refuses it. We discuss costs exposure at the first consultation and quote each step before you commit to it.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.