Retaining walls hold back soil where one block sits higher than its neighbour. When they lean, crack or collapse, the cost of replacement can run to tens of thousands of dollars, and each neighbour tends to assume the other should pay. Queensland law does not give a simple half and half answer.
Not a fence
The Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 governs dividing fences, and section 11(2)(a) expressly excludes a retaining wall from the definition of a fence. The equal contribution rule, the notice to contribute and QCAT’s fence jurisdiction therefore do not apply to retaining walls. QCAT may order work on a retaining wall only under section 35(1)(f), where the work is necessary to carry out fencing work, for example where a fence cannot be rebuilt until the wall beneath it is stabilised. The Queensland Law Reform Commission considered retaining walls in its 2015 review of the Act and recommended that its scope not be expanded to cover retaining wall disputes.
Who is responsible
The answer depends on why the wall is there. An owner who excavates near the boundary removes support that the higher land previously had and can be liable if that land subsides, so that owner is generally expected to build and maintain whatever is needed to replace the support. Equally, an owner who fills their land above the natural level has created a need for retention that did not exist before and is generally responsible for the wall that holds the fill back.
So the first question is which lot was cut and which was filled, and by whom. In a subdivision where the developer created the levels, the wall usually serves the lot it retains, and successive owners of that lot are often regarded as responsible for maintaining it. Where the wall was built by a later owner for their own benefit, that owner’s lot carries the responsibility. Where the wall was built jointly, or sits astride the boundary and benefits both, the position is less clear and a court looks at who built it, on whose land it stands and who it protects.
The duty of care about support
Since 1 August 2025, section 179 of the Property Law Act 2023 has governed support between neighbouring parcels. For the law of negligence, the owner of supporting land owes the owner of supported land a duty of care not to do or omit to do anything that adversely affects the support the supporting land provides, and the owner of the supported land owes a matching duty to the owner of the supporting land. The duty covers support for structures as well as for the land itself, support provided by structures such as a retaining wall, and parcels that do not share a boundary. It can be excluded or modified by express agreement, which binds later owners if it is contained in a registered easement. The section also abolishes any common law right to sue in nuisance for loss of support, so a claim about loss of support is now brought in negligence and the Civil Liability Act 2003 applies to it. Under the Property Law Act 1974 the obligation was not to withdraw support from other land or from buildings on it, and a loss of support that occurred before 1 August 2025 may still be decided under the earlier law.
Approvals and standards
Retaining walls above one metre in height, or that support a surcharge such as a building or a driveway, generally require building approval and engineering design under the Building Act 1975 and the Queensland Development Code. A wall built without approval, or not to the engineer’s design, can be evidence of fault when it fails. Councils can also issue notices requiring dangerous structures to be made safe. Check the council’s records for the approval and the engineering before taking a position.
Where disputes go
Because QCAT’s jurisdiction is limited, retaining wall disputes between neighbours are decided in the Magistrates Court for claims up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. The claim is for the cost of the work and for damage caused by the failure, and the defendant commonly argues that the wall has simply reached the end of its life, that the claimant’s own drainage or planting caused the failure, or that the claimant benefits from the wall and should contribute. Engineering evidence about the cause of failure and the appropriate remedial design is usually central.
A practical approach
Walls fail slowly. An early engineer’s inspection, shared with the neighbour, often produces an agreed scope and a negotiated split that reflects the benefit each lot receives. Insurance may respond where the failure was sudden, such as after a storm, so check both policies. If a wall is dangerous, make it safe first and argue about the cost second, keeping the engineer’s report and invoices.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 (Qld), s 11(2)(a) and s 35(1)(f)
- Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), s 179 (duty of care in relation to support for land)
- Queensland Law Reform Commission, Report 72: Review of the Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 (December 2015), p 57
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68