- Home
- What we help with
- Business leases
- Make good and bond disputes
Make good and bond disputes
The lease has ended, the keys have been handed back and then the claim arrives: tens of thousands of dollars to strip out the fit out, repaint, recarpet and replace ceiling tiles, with the bank guarantee already called. Make good clauses are often broader than tenants realise and narrower than landlords claim. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- The clause governsA tenant's make good obligation is whatever the lease says it is, read against the condition of the premises at the start. There is no general duty to improve the premises.
- Fair wear and tearMost make good clauses except fair wear and tear, so deterioration from ordinary use over the term is not the tenant's cost.
- Bank guaranteesA landlord can usually call on a bank guarantee without first proving the claim, but a call made for amounts not genuinely owed can be recovered by the tenant.
- ForumRetail tenancy disputes to the Small Business Commissioner then QCAT. Otherwise QCAT for debt claims up to $25,000 and the courts for other claims.
The disputes we see most
- The landlord's make good claim includes items that were never the tenant's responsibility, were already worn at the start, or go beyond what the clause requires.
- The landlord has called on the bank guarantee or kept the bond for a disputed make good or arrears claim.
- The landlord intends to redevelop or has a new tenant who wants the fit out, yet is still claiming the cost of stripping it out.
- A tenant wants to know what it actually has to do before handing back, and whether to do the work or negotiate a payment.
- A landlord has a tenant who left the premises damaged or full of fit out and wants to recover the cost of reinstatement.
- The parties disagree about the condition of the premises at the start because there was no condition report.
The make good obligation
A tenant’s obligation at the end of a lease is defined by the lease. Typical clauses require the tenant to remove its fit out, signage and fixtures, to make good any damage caused by their removal, and to return the premises in the condition they were in at the commencement, fair wear and tear excepted. Some leases require reinstatement to a base building standard described in a plan or condition report, and others require only that the premises be left clean and in good repair. There is no general obligation to improve the premises or to return them in a condition better than at the start. Fair wear and tear, meaning deterioration from ordinary and reasonable use over the term, is excepted in most clauses and is not the tenant’s cost.
Whether a landlord can recover the cost of works it does not intend to do is a question of loss. Damages for breach of a make good obligation are measured by the loss the landlord actually suffers, and where the landlord demolishes, refurbishes or lets the premises with the fit out in place, the loss may be small or nil. Landlords who claim the full cost of reinstatement in those circumstances rarely recover it once the evidence of their intentions is produced.
Proving the condition
The starting condition of the premises is proved by the condition report, if there was one, and otherwise by photographs, plans, invoices and witnesses. The end condition is proved the same way, which is why both parties should photograph the premises thoroughly at handover. Where the dispute is about the scope or cost of works, independent quotes and, in larger disputes, a building consultant’s report are the evidence that decides it.
Bonds and bank guarantees
Most business leases are secured by a cash bond or a bank guarantee. A bank guarantee is an unconditional undertaking by the bank to pay the landlord on demand, and the bank will pay without investigating whether the amount is owed. The lease sets the circumstances in which the landlord may call on it, and a landlord who calls for amounts that are not genuinely owing is liable to repay the excess to the tenant. A cash bond is held on the terms of the lease, and the landlord must account for it at the end of the lease after deducting what is properly owed. Unlike residential tenancies, there is no government bond scheme for business leases in Queensland, so disputes about the security are decided under the lease.
Where these disputes are decided
Under a retail shop lease, make good and bond disputes are retail tenancy disputes that must go to mediation through the Queensland Small Business Commissioner before QCAT, which can decide them up to the District Court’s monetary limit, provided the lease did not end more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged. For other commercial leases, debt claims up to $25,000 can be brought in QCAT as minor civil disputes and larger claims in the Magistrates Court up to $150,000, the District Court up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027, and the Supreme Court above that.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on what the clause requires and what the landlord can actually recover. Most make good disputes settle on a negotiated figure once the claim has been tested against the clause, the condition evidence and the landlord’s real intentions. Where they do not, we prepare the proceedings and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Read the make good clause, the condition report and the landlord's claim and advise you in writing on what is actually owed.
- Obtain independent quotes and, where the condition of the premises is disputed, expert evidence.
- Negotiate make good settlements, including cash payments in lieu of works and agreed scopes.
- Prepare and run QCAT, Small Business Commissioner and court proceedings to recover or defend make good and bond claims.
Common questions
What does make good actually mean?
Whatever the lease says. Clauses range from a simple obligation to leave the premises clean and in good repair, to a requirement to remove all fit out and reinstate the premises to the condition shown in a plan or condition report, including repainting, recarpeting and reinstating services. The obligation is measured against the condition at the start of the lease, not against new, and usually excepts fair wear and tear. Reading the clause carefully, with the condition report if there is one, is the first step in every make good dispute.
The landlord is redeveloping. Do I still have to strip out?
Possibly not in full. Where the landlord intends to demolish or completely refurbish the premises, or has agreed with an incoming tenant to retain the fit out, the landlord may suffer no loss from the tenant's failure to make good, and damages are measured by loss. Landlords sometimes still claim the full cost of works that will never be done. Evidence of the landlord's intentions, such as development approvals or the new lease, can substantially reduce or defeat the claim.
Can the landlord just call on my bank guarantee?
Usually yes, because a bank guarantee is an unconditional promise by the bank to pay the landlord on demand, and the bank does not look behind the demand. The lease will say when the landlord may call on it, typically for amounts the landlord claims are owing. If the landlord calls for amounts that are not genuinely owed, the tenant can sue to recover the excess, and in some circumstances can obtain an injunction before the call if the lease restricts it. A cash bond is held on the terms of the lease and the same principles apply.
There was no condition report. How is the starting condition proved?
By whatever evidence exists: photographs from the start of the lease, the fit out plans, the previous tenant's handover, invoices for works done at the start and the recollection of witnesses. Without a condition report the landlord has the harder task, because it must prove the premises were in better condition at the start than at the end. Tenants should photograph premises thoroughly on both the first and the last day.
Should I do the make good work or pay the landlord instead?
It depends on the cost and the landlord's intentions. If the landlord will refurbish anyway, a negotiated payment is usually cheaper than works nobody wants. If the clause is demanding and the landlord will insist on it, doing the work yourself under your own contractors is often cheaper than paying the landlord's quote. We advise on the realistic exposure and negotiate the outcome.
Where are these disputes decided?
Under a retail shop lease the dispute must go to mediation through the Queensland Small Business Commissioner and then QCAT, which can decide it up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million from 1 January 2027, provided the lease did not end more than one year before the dispute notice was lodged. For other commercial leases, debt claims up to $25,000 can be brought in QCAT as minor civil disputes and larger claims in the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 or the District Court above that.
Articles on make good and bond disputes
A longer answer to one of the questions people ask us most often about make good and bond disputes. It sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.