The end of a lease frequently produces the largest dispute of the whole term. The tenant wants to hand back the keys and move on. The landlord sends a make good schedule running to pages, priced at tens of thousands of dollars, and holds the bank guarantee. What the tenant actually has to do is a question of reading the lease properly.
The clause controls
There is no standard make good obligation in Queensland law beyond the fallback terms described below. The obligation is whatever the lease says. Clauses range from a requirement to leave the premises clean and tidy with the tenant’s property removed, through an obligation to return the premises to the condition they were in at commencement, to an obligation to strip the premises back to a bare shell regardless of their condition when the tenant moved in. The Small Business Commissioner’s guidance encourages parties to define the obligation precisely at the start, because vague clauses breed disputes at the end.
Read the clause with the definition of premises, the fit out provisions, any landlord’s works clause and any licence for alterations, because the obligation to remove fit out often depends on whether the landlord consented to it and on what terms. A clause requiring the tenant to remove its fixtures but to leave the landlord’s fixtures requires the parties to know which is which, and the condition report and fit out approvals are the evidence.
What the Act implies if the lease is silent
Section 139 of the Property Law Act 2023 implies the standard terms in schedule 1 into every lease of land, subject to any agreement to the contrary, so they only matter where the lease does not deal with the point. Clause 3 requires the tenant to keep the premises, excluding structural elements, in good condition and to hand them back in at least the repair and condition they were in at the start of the lease, but not to repair damage caused by reasonable wear and tear or by fire, flood, storm, earthquake or any other risk the landlord has insured against. Clause 12 requires the tenant to remove its own fixtures, fittings, plant and other items before or at the end of the lease and to repair any damage caused by the removal; anything left for a month after the lease ends is treated as abandoned, and the landlord may remove, sell or dispose of it and recover the cost from the tenant. Most commercial leases replace these terms with something more detailed, but they fill the gaps in short or informal leases.
Condition at commencement
Where the obligation is to return the premises to their condition at the start of the lease, the condition report prepared at commencement is the key evidence. Without one, the parties argue from memory and photographs. A tenant who took over premises with worn carpet and marked walls cannot be required to deliver new carpet and freshly painted walls unless the lease says so. Tenants should insist on a detailed condition report with photographs at the start of every lease and keep it.
Fair wear and tear
Most clauses except fair wear and tear, meaning the deterioration that results from ordinary use over the term. Scuffed walls, worn carpet in traffic areas and faded blinds are fair wear and tear; holes in walls, damaged doors and stained carpet from spills are not. The line is one of degree and is a common point of argument in make good disputes.
If the tenant does not do the work
Where the tenant hands back without making good, the landlord’s remedy is damages for breach of the covenant. The measure is generally the reasonable cost of doing the work the tenant should have done, but section 178 of the Property Law Act 2023 caps damages for breach of an obligation to keep or put premises in good repair at the lesser of the actual cost of remedying the breach and the amount by which the breach has reduced the value of the landlord’s reversion. No damages can be awarded for that breach if the tenant proves that the premises have been or will be demolished, or structurally altered in a way that makes the repair worthless. Whether a particular make good obligation, such as a strip out to a bare shell, is an obligation to repair for the purposes of the cap is a question of construction, but the general principle is the same: the landlord is entitled to be put in the position it would have been in had the covenant been performed, not to a windfall. Quotes obtained by the landlord should be tested against independent quotes, and the tenant is entitled to ask whether the work was actually done.
Some leases allow the landlord to accept a payment in lieu of make good, and negotiating such a payment before the end of the term is often cheaper for both sides than a dispute afterwards.
Holding over
A tenant who is still removing fit out after the lease has ended may be liable for rent for the period, and many leases provide for rent at a higher rate during a holding over. Plan the make good so that it is complete by the expiry date, or agree an extension in writing.
Bonds and bank guarantees
The landlord may apply the security deposit or call on the bank guarantee to recover amounts the tenant owes, including make good costs. The bank will pay on a compliant demand without investigating the dispute. That does not end the matter. A tenant who disputes the amount can sue for the return of any excess, and a landlord who calls on a guarantee for an inflated or unsupported make good claim can be ordered to repay the excess. Keep the correspondence about the make good schedule, your own quotes and photographs of the premises at handover.
Retail leases
For retail shop leases, make good disputes go through the Small Business Commissioner’s mediation process and then QCAT. For other leases they are decided in the Magistrates or District Court.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.