- Home
- What we help with
- Government appeals
- Dog destruction orders
Dog destruction orders
A destruction order gives the council the power to destroy your dog 14 days after the order is served unless you apply for review. An application for internal review stops the clock, and an application to QCAT automatically stays the order until the review is decided. Nothing else about these matters is automatic, and the evidence you put together in the first days usually decides them. The first step is a fixed fee consultation, which we arrange as quickly as possible when a destruction order is involved.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- 14 daysA destruction order cannot be carried out earlier than 14 days after it is served, and not at all while an internal review application, QCAT review or appeal is on foot.
- Internal reviewAn internal review application must be made within 14 days after the information notice is given, and the council must decide it within 20 days.
- QCATAn application to QCAT must be filed within 28 days of the internal review decision. QCAT automatically stays a destruction order when the review application is made.
- When orderedAn authorised person must make a destruction order for a regulated dog that has seriously attacked a person or animal, and may make one in other cases.
The disputes we see most
- Your dog has been seized after an incident and a destruction order has been served.
- The council says your dog seriously attacked a person or animal and you dispute what happened or how serious it was.
- Your declared dog has been seized for a breach of conditions and the council proposes to destroy it.
- The 14 days are running and you do not know what to file or where.
- The internal review has confirmed the order and you want QCAT to review it.
- Your dog is being held at the pound and you want to see it and confirm its welfare.
When a destruction order can be made
The Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008 gives an authorised person power to make a destruction order for a regulated dog, meaning a declared dangerous or menacing dog, or for a prohibited dog. Where the dog has seriously attacked a person or an animal, the authorised person must make the order. Where it has not, the authorised person may do so. An order can be made at the same time as a regulated dog declaration, before the declaration has taken effect, with a single information notice covering both decisions. To seriously attack a person means to attack in a way that causes death, grievous bodily harm or bodily harm, and to seriously attack an animal means to cause its death or to maim or wound it. In limited circumstances a dog may be destroyed immediately without an order, where the authorised person reasonably believes it is dangerous and cannot be controlled or where the owner asks, and a seized dog with no known owner may be destroyed 3 days after seizure. Outside those cases, the order and its review rights apply.
The 14 days and the stay
A destruction order must be served on the registered owner with an information notice, and it cannot be carried out earlier than 14 days after service. If an application for internal review is made, the dog cannot be destroyed until the review is decided, and then only if the review confirms the order and the time for applying to QCAT passes without an application. If an application for external review is made to QCAT, the dog cannot be destroyed until QCAT confirms the order and the time for an appeal passes, and if an appeal is started, until the appeal is decided. QCAT automatically stays a destruction order when the review application is filed, so unlike a declaration no separate stay application is needed at that stage, although a stay application can be filed with QCAT during the internal review if needed. The internal review application must be made within 14 days after the information notice is given, and the council must decide it within 20 days by a person senior to the original decision maker. The QCAT application must be filed within 28 days of the internal review decision.
What decides these cases
QCAT reviews the decision afresh and decides what the correct and preferable decision is on the evidence before it. The circumstances of the incident matter: whether the dog was provoked, was defending itself or its home, was in pain or was attacked first, and how the people and animals involved behaved. The severity of the injury matters, because it determines whether the council was obliged to make the order or merely permitted to. The dog’s history, the owner’s history of compliance, expert evidence about temperament and risk, and a credible management plan showing that the regulated dog conditions can be met all bear on whether destruction is necessary or whether a declaration with conditions is the appropriate outcome. QCAT’s practice direction for review of decisions about animals sets out a guided process, and these matters move faster than most reviews because the dog is in the pound. An appeal from QCAT’s decision on a destruction order lies only on a question of law.
While the dog is held
A seized dog’s owner must be given a receipt and must be allowed to inspect the dog at reasonable times free of charge unless that is impracticable or unreasonable. A dog held under a destruction order is an exception to the usual requirement that a seized dog be returned within 14 days, so the dog will remain in the pound while the review runs. Welfare concerns can be raised with the council and with QCAT.
What usually happens
When a destruction order is involved we arrange the first consultation as quickly as possible and advise you on the deadlines and the prospects. We lodge the internal review application within the 14 days, prepare the QCAT application if the order is confirmed and assemble the evidence that decides these matters, quoting each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Advise you urgently on the deadlines, the grounds the council relies on and the prospects of setting the order aside.
- Prepare and lodge the internal review application within 14 days and the QCAT review application within 28 days, so that the order cannot be carried out.
- Gather the evidence that decides these cases: witness statements, veterinary records, video, a behavioural assessment and a management plan.
- Represent you at the QCAT hearing and in any appeal on a question of law.
Common questions
How long do I have?
The order cannot be carried out earlier than 14 days after it is served on you. An application for internal review must be made within 14 days after you are given the information notice that accompanies the order, and once it is made the dog cannot be destroyed until the review is decided and the time for applying to QCAT has passed without an application. If the internal review confirms the order, you have 28 days to apply to QCAT, and QCAT automatically stays the destruction order when the application is made. Missing the 14 day internal review deadline is the most common way these matters are lost, so the application should be lodged first and the evidence assembled afterwards.
When can the council make a destruction order?
Under the Animal Management (Cats and Dogs) Act 2008, where a regulated dog, meaning a declared dangerous or menacing dog, or a prohibited dog, has seriously attacked a person or animal, an authorised person must make a destruction order. Where it has not, an authorised person may make one. A destruction order can be made at the same time as a declaration, before the declaration has taken effect. In limited cases a dog can be destroyed immediately without an order, where the authorised person reasonably believes it is dangerous and cannot be controlled, or where the owner asks.
What does seriously attack mean?
In relation to a person, an attack that causes death, grievous bodily harm or bodily harm. In relation to an animal, an attack that causes death or that maims or wounds the animal. Whether the injury meets that definition is often genuinely disputed, and the medical or veterinary evidence of the injury is central. Where the attack was not serious the council has a discretion rather than a duty, and the question becomes whether destruction is the correct and preferable decision given everything known about the dog and its management.
What does QCAT consider?
QCAT reviews the decision afresh and decides what the correct and preferable decision is on the evidence before it. It considers the circumstances of the incident, including provocation and the behaviour of the people and animals involved, the severity of any injury, the dog's history, the owner's history of compliance with conditions, expert evidence about the dog's temperament and the risk of further incidents, and the owner's proposals for managing the dog in future. QCAT's practice direction for animal review applications sets out a guided process, and matters are generally dealt with more quickly than other reviews because the dog is in the pound.
What evidence should I gather?
Statements from anyone who saw the incident, photographs and any video, veterinary or medical records of the injuries, the dog's veterinary and registration history, evidence of training and of the dog's behaviour before and since, and a behavioural assessment from a qualified veterinary behaviourist. A detailed written management plan showing how the dog will be contained, exercised and supervised, and that the regulated dog conditions can be met, is often the difference between destruction and a declaration with conditions.
Can I visit my dog while it is held?
Yes. The council must allow the owner to inspect a seized dog at reasonable times, free of charge, unless that is impracticable or unreasonable, and must give the owner a receipt for the dog. Welfare concerns about a dog in the pound can be raised with the council and, if necessary, with QCAT as part of the review.
Articles on dog destruction orders
A longer answer to one of the questions people ask us most often about dog destruction orders. It sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.