- Home
- What we help with
- Government appeals
- Blue card negative notices
Blue card negative notices
A letter from Blue Card Services says it is considering issuing you a negative notice because of something in your history, and gives you a deadline to respond. Or the negative notice has already arrived and your job, your volunteering or your business depends on reversing it. The decision turns on a risk assessment, the material you put forward shapes that assessment, and QCAT can take a fresh look. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand and what to do before the deadline.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- The testFor most applicants the question is whether Blue Card Services is satisfied the person poses a real and appreciable risk to the safety of children. For people convicted of a serious offence, or who were once disqualified, a negative notice issues unless the case is exceptional.
- 28 daysAn application to QCAT to review a negative notice, or a refusal to cancel one, must be filed within 28 days of receiving the decision. There is no filing fee.
- No stayQCAT cannot stay a blue card decision. A negative notice remains in force, and working in regulated child related employment with one is an offence.
- CancellationA person who is not disqualified may apply to cancel a negative notice more than 3 years after it was issued, or 2 years for a notice issued before 20 September 2025.
The disputes we see most
- Blue Card Services has written proposing to issue a negative notice and invited submissions.
- You have received a negative notice and your employment, volunteering or business depends on a blue card.
- Your blue card has been suspended because of a charge and you want the suspension ended.
- You applied to cancel a negative notice and the application was refused.
- The information Blue Card Services relied on is old, disputed or relates to a charge that was withdrawn or dismissed.
- You are not sure whether you are a disqualified person who cannot seek review.
How negative notices are decided
The Working with Children Check Act 2000, which until 22 October 2026 was titled the Working with Children (Risk Management and Screening) Act 2000, requires Blue Card Services to assess every applicant and card holder against information about their criminal history, including charges that did not result in a conviction, together with disciplinary, child protection and other prescribed information. Since 20 September 2025, when amendments to the Act commenced, the framework is this. A person who is a disqualified person cannot hold a blue card. A person who has been convicted of a serious offence, or who was once a disqualified person, must be issued a negative notice unless Blue Card Services is satisfied that the case is an exceptional one in which the person would not pose a risk to the safety of children. Any other person must be approved unless Blue Card Services is satisfied that they pose a risk to the safety of children, which the Act defines as a real and appreciable risk, and it is enough that there is a real possibility of the risk without it being likely. In each case a risk assessment must be conducted, and in each case the welfare and best interests of children are the paramount consideration. Reviews that were started before 20 September 2025 continue under the earlier exceptional case test.
Before the decision
Blue Card Services usually writes before issuing a negative notice, setting out the information it holds and inviting written submissions by a stated date. This is the most important stage, because a negative notice once issued remains in force throughout any review and QCAT cannot stay it. Effective submissions deal with each piece of information candidly, explain the circumstances, the passage of time and what has changed, and are supported by evidence: references from people who know the history, practitioner reports where relevant, evidence of stable circumstances and evidence of insight. Where the information is inaccurate or relates to a charge that was withdrawn or dismissed, the court records should be obtained and provided.
Review in QCAT
A person issued a negative notice, or refused cancellation of one, may apply to QCAT for review within 28 days of receiving the decision. There is no filing fee. QCAT sends the application to Blue Card Services, which must provide the material it relied on, and the matter proceeds through directions and a compulsory conference to a hearing if it does not resolve. QCAT decides afresh, on the evidence before it including evidence of events since the decision, what the correct and preferable decision is, and can confirm the decision or set it aside and substitute its own. A disqualified person cannot apply for review except in a case of mistaken identity, and if an applicant becomes a disqualified person during the review QCAT cannot continue. A negative notice remains in force during the review, and working in regulated child related employment while it does is an offence.
Cancelling a negative notice
A negative notice does not expire. A person who is not a disqualified person may apply to cancel it once more than 3 years have passed since it was issued, or 2 years for a notice issued before 20 September 2025. The period runs from the issue of the notice whether or not a review was sought, but where an application to cancel is refused and QCAT confirms the refusal, a further application cannot be made until more than 3 years after QCAT’s decision. An earlier application is allowed in limited cases, including where the decision was based on wrong or incomplete information. Blue Card Services must conduct a new risk assessment before cancelling, and a refusal to cancel can be reviewed by QCAT within 28 days.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on the information held against you, whether review is available and the strength of a response or review. We then prepare the submissions or the QCAT application and the evidence, and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Assess the information held against you, whether you are eligible to apply and the strength of a response or review, and advise you in writing before the deadline.
- Prepare the written submissions to Blue Card Services, with the supporting evidence, before a negative notice is issued.
- Prepare and file the QCAT review application within 28 days, gather the evidence and represent you at the compulsory conference and the hearing.
- Prepare applications to cancel a negative notice once the sit out period has ended.
Common questions
What does Blue Card Services consider?
The Working with Children Check Act 2000 requires a risk assessment that takes into account your criminal history, including charges that did not result in convictions, disciplinary and child protection information, and any submissions you make. Since 20 September 2025, the application of a person who has not been convicted of a serious offence and has never been a disqualified person must be approved unless Blue Card Services is satisfied the person poses a risk to the safety of children, meaning a real and appreciable risk. For a person convicted of a serious offence, or who was once a disqualified person, a negative notice must be issued unless the case is exceptional and the person would not pose a risk. Reviews started before that date continue under the earlier exceptional case test. In every case the welfare and best interests of children are paramount, and the scheme is protective rather than punitive.
Should I respond to the letter proposing a negative notice?
Yes, and carefully. The submissions stage is the best opportunity to avoid a negative notice altogether, because once one is issued it stays in force throughout any review. A good response addresses each piece of information honestly, explains the circumstances and what has changed since, and is supported by evidence: references from people who know the history, reports from treating practitioners where relevant, evidence of stable employment and circumstances, and evidence of insight into the conduct. A response that minimises or disputes everything tends to make matters worse.
How does a QCAT review work?
You file an application within 28 days of receiving the decision, with no fee, and QCAT provides it to Blue Card Services, which must produce the material it relied on. QCAT decides the matter afresh on the evidence before it, including evidence of what has happened since the decision, and reaches what it considers the correct and preferable decision. The process involves directions, a compulsory conference and, if the matter does not resolve, a hearing at which you give evidence and can call witnesses. QCAT's practice direction for blue card reviews sets out the steps. QCAT cannot stay the negative notice while the review runs.
Who cannot apply to QCAT?
A disqualified person, which broadly means a person convicted of a disqualifying offence or subject to certain orders, cannot apply for review, with the single exception of mistaken identity. If you become a disqualified person during the review, QCAT must stop considering it. Whether a particular conviction or order makes you a disqualified person is a question we check first, because it determines whether a review is available at all.
What evidence helps most?
Evidence that addresses risk. Your own detailed written statement about the events, your circumstances then and now and your understanding of why the conduct was wrong. Reports from psychologists or other practitioners where mental health, substance use or anger was involved. References from employers, colleagues and community members who know your history and can speak to your conduct since. Evidence of the passage of time without further incident. And, where the information relied on is disputed or inaccurate, the court records or other documents that show what actually happened.
Can a negative notice be cancelled later?
A person who is not a disqualified person can apply to Blue Card Services to cancel a negative notice once the sit out period has ended. Under the Act that is more than 3 years after the notice was issued, or 2 years for a notice issued before 20 September 2025, and the period runs from the issue of the notice whether or not you applied to QCAT. If an application to cancel is refused and QCAT confirms the refusal, a further application cannot be made until more than 3 years after QCAT's decision. An earlier application is allowed where the decision was based on wrong or incomplete information, or where the notice was issued because you were a disqualified person and you no longer are. Blue Card Services conducts a fresh risk assessment, and a refusal to cancel can itself be reviewed by QCAT within 28 days.
Articles on blue card negative notices
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about blue card negative notices. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Responding to a proposed negative notice from Blue Card Services: the stage that matters mostBefore issuing a negative notice, Blue Card Services usually writes to the applicant setting out the information it holds and inviting submissions by a date. This article explains what the letter means, what Blue Card Services considers, how to prepare submissions and evidence, and how to manage the deadline.
- Blue card reviews in QCAT: time limits, process and what the tribunal decidesA person issued a negative notice can apply to QCAT for a fresh decision. This article explains the 28 day time limit, the absence of any stay, who cannot apply, how the review runs and the possible outcomes.
- The blue card risk assessment: the tests applied since 20 September 2025Amendments to Queensland's working with children legislation that commenced on 20 September 2025 changed the tests Blue Card Services and QCAT apply. This article explains the real and appreciable risk test for most applicants, the exceptional case test for people convicted of serious offences or formerly disqualified, and the information considered.
- Applying to cancel a blue card negative notice after the sit out periodA negative notice does not expire, but a person who is not disqualified can apply to have it cancelled once the sit out period has passed. This article explains the three year period for notices issued from 20 September 2025, the two year period for earlier notices, the exceptions and the evidence that supports cancellation.
- How QCAT reviews government decisions: merits review explainedBlue card, NDIS worker screening and animal management decisions are all reviewed by QCAT in its review jurisdiction. This article explains what merits review means, the 28 day time limit, the decision maker's obligation to produce its reasons and documents, stays, the compulsory conference and hearing, the orders QCAT can make, costs and appeals.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.