Many Queensland government decisions that affect a person’s livelihood or property can be taken to QCAT for review. Blue card negative notices, NDIS worker screening exclusions and council decisions about dogs are among them. The process is called merits review, and it differs from an appeal in a way that matters to how a case should be prepared.
What merits review means
Under section 20 of the QCAT Act the purpose of a review is to produce the correct and preferable decision, and QCAT must decide it by way of a fresh hearing on the merits. QCAT is not asking whether the original decision maker made an error. It is making the decision again, applying the same legislation, with all of the functions of the original decision maker under section 19, and on the evidence before it at the hearing. That means events after the original decision count: time that has passed, treatment completed, a dog’s behaviour since the incident. It also means an applicant cannot win simply by pointing to a flaw in the original process; they must persuade QCAT that a different decision is the right one.
Time limits
Section 33 requires an application for review to be filed within 28 days after the applicant is notified of the decision, or, where the applicant has requested a written statement of reasons, within 28 days after the statement is given or was due. Enabling Acts can set different periods. Section 61 allows QCAT to extend time, even after it has expired, but not where that would cause prejudice to another party that cannot be remedied, and an applicant seeking an extension must explain the delay and show the review has substance. Where internal review is a precondition, as it is for council decisions about dogs, the 28 days runs from the internal review decision.
The decision maker’s material
Under section 21 the decision maker must use its best endeavours to help QCAT and must, within 28 days after receiving the application, provide a written statement of reasons and every document or thing in its possession or control that may be relevant. QCAT can require more. The material is provided to the applicant, subject to confidentiality orders in sensitive matters, and it is the foundation of the case: it shows what the decision maker relied on, what it did not have and where its reasoning can be met with evidence.
Stays
Under section 22, starting a review does not affect the operation of the decision. QCAT may stay the decision, on application or on its own initiative, if it considers a stay desirable having regard to the interests of affected persons, the decision maker’s submissions and the public interest, and may impose conditions, as it must when staying a dangerous dog declaration. An enabling Act can exclude stays, and the blue card legislation does, so a negative notice remains in force throughout its review. Stay applications need evidence of the effect of the decision and of the absence of risk in the interim.
The process
After the material is produced, QCAT gives directions for the applicant’s evidence and the decision maker’s response. A compulsory conference commonly follows, conducted by a member, at which the issues are narrowed and settlement explored; decision makers do reconsider in appropriate cases. In animal matters a compulsory conference is held only where QCAT considers it desirable. If the matter does not resolve it is listed for a hearing, at which the applicant and witnesses give evidence and are cross examined and both sides make submissions. QCAT is not bound by the rules of evidence and must act fairly and according to the substantial merits, but it weighs evidence in the ordinary way, and hearsay, unsigned references and assertions without documents carry little weight. Representation requires leave under section 43, which is commonly granted in review matters involving complex issues or where the decision maker is represented.
Orders
Under section 24 QCAT may confirm or amend the decision, set it aside and substitute its own decision, or set it aside and return the matter to the decision maker for reconsideration with directions. A substituted decision takes effect as a decision of the original decision maker.
Costs
Under section 100 each party bears its own costs unless QCAT orders otherwise under section 102 in the interests of justice, having regard to matters such as a party’s unreasonable conduct and the strengths of the cases. Costs orders against unsuccessful applicants in review matters are uncommon, which makes review accessible.
Appeals
The appeal route depends on who decided the review. Where no judicial member constituted the tribunal, a party may appeal to the QCAT appeal tribunal under section 142. Where a judicial member constituted the tribunal, the appeal is to the Court of Appeal under section 149. On either route, an appeal against the final decision on a question of law does not need leave, and an appeal on a question of fact or of mixed law and fact needs leave. Under section 147, an appeal to the appeal tribunal on a question of fact or of mixed law and fact is decided by way of rehearing, with or without additional evidence.
Under section 143, an application for leave to appeal to the appeal tribunal must be filed within 28 days after the relevant day, which is generally the day written reasons are given, or the day the party received notice of the decision where reasons were not given or requested. The appeal itself must be filed within 21 days after leave is given or, where leave is not needed, within 28 days after the relevant day. An enabling Act can set a different period or limit appeals further, as the animal management legislation does for destruction orders.
Preparing
The applicant’s task is to assemble evidence that would persuade a careful decision maker, applying the statutory test, to decide differently. That means a candid account, documents, expert evidence where risk is in issue and witnesses who know the facts. Preparation should begin when the original decision is received, not when the hearing is listed.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.