A negative notice is not the end of the matter. QCAT can review the decision and substitute its own. The process has fixed steps and a hard deadline at the start.
Who can apply and when
A person issued a negative notice, or refused the cancellation of one, may apply to QCAT for review. Sections 353 and 354 of the Working with Children Check Act 2000 require the application to be made within 28 days after the person is given notice of the decision. There is no filing fee for blue card reviews. QCAT has power under section 61 of the QCAT Act to extend the time, but it will not do so where that would cause prejudice that cannot be remedied, and an applicant who misses the deadline must explain the delay and show the review has merit. The application states the reasons the decision is wrong; it does not need to contain the evidence, which comes later.
A disqualified person, broadly a person convicted of a disqualifying offence or subject to certain orders, cannot apply for review except on the basis of mistaken identity, and if an applicant becomes a disqualified person during a review QCAT must stop. Whether a particular conviction or order has that effect is the first thing to check.
No stay
Section 22 of the QCAT Act allows the tribunal to stay a reviewable decision unless the enabling Act provides otherwise. The Working with Children Check Act does provide otherwise, so a negative notice remains in force throughout the review and working in regulated child related employment while it is in force is an offence. Applicants should plan for several months without the card.
Blue Card Services’ material
Section 21 of the QCAT Act requires the decision maker to provide QCAT, within 28 days of receiving the application, with a written statement of reasons and every document in its possession that may be relevant. QCAT Practice Direction 5 of 2022 regulates how those documents are handled in blue card matters, including their provision to the applicant and the protection of confidential information. The material usually includes the police information, the agency’s risk assessment and the applicant’s own submissions. Read it carefully, because it shows what the tribunal must be persuaded about.
The process
After the material is produced, QCAT gives directions for the applicant to file evidence, typically a detailed personal statement, references, reports and documents, and for Blue Card Services to respond. A compulsory conference follows, at which a member explores whether the matter can be resolved; Blue Card Services does sometimes reconsider on the strength of the applicant’s evidence. If it does not resolve, the matter is listed for a hearing at which the applicant gives evidence and is cross examined, witnesses can be called and submissions are made. Hearings in blue card matters are generally closed to the public and non publication orders are common.
What QCAT decides
Under section 20 the review is a fresh hearing on the merits and the purpose is to produce the correct and preferable decision. QCAT stands in the shoes of Blue Card Services, applies the same test under the Act and considers the evidence before it at the time of the hearing, which includes everything that has happened since the original decision. Under section 24 it can confirm the decision, set it aside and substitute its own, or set it aside and return the matter for reconsideration with directions. The welfare and best interests of children are paramount in every case, and the tribunal is concerned with risk, not punishment.
The evidence that matters
Tribunal decisions in these matters turn on insight, change and protective factors. The applicant’s own account must be candid and consistent with the records. Evidence of the time elapsed since the conduct, of stable employment, relationships and housing, of treatment where relevant and of a realistic understanding of the triggers for the past conduct and how they are managed carries the most weight. Expert evidence from a psychologist addressing risk is often valuable. References must come from people who know the history. Evidence that the applicant has complied with the law and with the negative notice since it issued is also relevant.
Outcomes and appeals
If the review succeeds, Blue Card Services issues a blue card. If it fails, the negative notice stands and the applicant may apply to cancel it under section 304G of the Working with Children Check Act once more than three years have passed since the notice was issued, or two years for a notice issued before 20 September 2025. An appeal from QCAT’s decision lies to the appeal tribunal, or to the Court of Appeal where a judicial member decided the review. An appeal on a question of law does not need leave, and an appeal on a question of fact or of mixed law and fact needs leave. The application for leave, or an appeal that does not need leave, must generally be filed within 28 days after the relevant day, which is usually the day written reasons are given.
Costs
Under section 100 of the QCAT Act each party bears its own costs unless QCAT orders otherwise in the interests of justice under section 102, so an unsuccessful applicant is not usually ordered to pay Blue Card Services’ costs.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.