A negative notice closes the door on regulated child related work, but it does not lock it permanently. The Working with Children Check Act 2000 allows a person who is not disqualified to apply to cancel a negative notice once a period has passed, and a successful application restores eligibility for a blue card. The period is long, the assessment is thorough and the application needs to be prepared with the same care as a response to the original notice.
The sit out period
Under section 304G of the Act, a person who holds a negative notice cannot apply to cancel it until more than three years after the notice was issued. For a notice issued before 20 September 2025 the period is two years (section 610). The period runs from the issue of the notice whether or not the person applies to QCAT for a review of it. A different rule applies after a failed application to cancel: if Blue Card Services refuses to cancel the notice and QCAT confirms that refusal, the person cannot apply again until more than three years after QCAT’s decision. Blue Card Services’ published guidance describes the period as starting on the date of the decision or the date the decision was confirmed on appeal, so a person whose matter has been before QCAT should confirm the date that applies before lodging.
Section 304G permits an earlier application in two cases: where the decision to issue the notice was based on wrong or incomplete information, and where the notice was issued because the person was a disqualified person and the person is no longer one. Blue Card Services gives, as an example of when an earlier application may be possible, a person found not guilty of a charge that was pending when the notice was issued. Separately, section 304M allows the chief executive to cancel a negative notice after becoming aware of information that was not known when the decision was made. A person who believes an exception applies should raise it with Blue Card Services with the supporting records rather than waiting out the period.
Who cannot apply
A disqualified person cannot apply to cancel a negative notice, regardless of the time elapsed. A person who becomes a disqualified person after the notice issued is in the same position, as is a person who is the subject of an adverse working with children decision made in another State or Territory that is still in effect.
The reassessment
An application to cancel is not a formality. Blue Card Services obtains current criminal history and other information and conducts a new risk assessment applying the test that governs the person’s circumstances: for a person convicted of a serious offence, or who was once a disqualified person, whether the case is now exceptional and the person would not pose a risk to the safety of children; for anyone else, whether the person poses a real and appreciable risk to the safety of children. The original information remains relevant, and the question is whether the position has changed sufficiently since the negative notice that the test is now met.
What has changed
The application should demonstrate change, not merely the passage of time. Evidence that supports cancellation includes a period of years without any further charge or concern; compliance with the negative notice and with any court orders; completed treatment, counselling or programs relevant to the original conduct, with reports from the practitioners; stable employment, housing and relationships; a candid personal statement showing insight into the original conduct and how its causes have been addressed; references from people who know the history and have observed the person over the period; and where the person seeks to return to a particular kind of regulated work, information about the role and its supervision. Where the original decision identified particular concerns, the application should address each of them directly.
An applicant should also consider whether the original information was accurate and complete. Court records, the police brief and any material produced in a previous QCAT review may reveal inaccuracies that can now be corrected with evidence.
The decision
Blue Card Services either cancels the negative notice, in which case the person may apply for a blue card in the ordinary way, or refuses to cancel it and gives reasons. A refusal to cancel is a reviewable decision, and an application to QCAT must be filed within 28 days of receiving it. There is no filing fee. QCAT conducts a fresh hearing on the merits and decides the correct and preferable decision on the evidence before it, as it does for a review of the original notice. If QCAT confirms the refusal, a further application to cancel cannot be made until more than three years after QCAT’s decision.
Timing and preparation
Because the period is long and the stakes are a person’s return to a career, preparation should begin well before the period ends: gathering reports and references, addressing any outstanding issues in the person’s life that the original decision identified, and obtaining the records of the original decision. An application lodged on the first available day with comprehensive evidence is in a far better position than one lodged later with little.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.