Blue card decisions are made by applying statutory tests to information about a person’s history. The tests changed on 20 September 2025, and on 22 October 2026 the legislation itself was renamed the Working with Children Check Act 2000, having previously been the Working with Children (Risk Management and Screening) Act 2000. Anyone facing an assessment or a review needs to know which test applies to them and what it requires.
The information considered
Blue Card Services obtains the applicant’s national criminal history, which includes charges that were withdrawn, dismissed or resulted in acquittal as well as convictions, spent convictions and convictions for which no conviction was recorded. It also receives disciplinary information from professional bodies, child protection information, information about domestic violence orders in some circumstances and other prescribed information. An applicant cannot exclude any of this from consideration; the question is what weight it carries in the assessment of risk. In every case the welfare and best interests of children are the paramount consideration, and the scheme is protective rather than punitive.
Disqualified persons
A disqualified person cannot hold a blue card. The category covers people convicted of disqualifying offences, which are the most serious offences against children, and people subject to certain orders such as reporting obligations under child protection offender legislation. A disqualified person cannot apply for a card, cannot apply to QCAT for review except to establish mistaken identity, and cannot apply to cancel a negative notice. Whether a conviction is for a disqualifying offence depends on the offence and, for some offences, on whether an imprisonment order was imposed or whether the offence was committed against a child. An offence committed when the person was a child is not a disqualifying offence. This is the first thing to establish.
Serious offences: the exceptional case test
For a person who has been convicted of a serious offence, which is a defined list including serious violent and sexual offences and other offences of particular concern, the Act requires a negative notice unless the decision maker is satisfied that the case is an exceptional one in which the person would not pose a risk to the safety of children. The same test applies to a person who was once a disqualified person but no longer is, unless the conviction, sentence or order that made them disqualified was set aside on appeal. The applicant bears the practical burden of showing that the case is exceptional. Exceptional does not mean unusual in a statistical sense; it means that the circumstances take the case out of the ordinary rule that a person with such a conviction should not hold a card, having regard to all of the risk and protective factors.
Everyone else: the real and appreciable risk test
For a person who has not been convicted of a serious offence and has never been a disqualified person, whatever else is in their history, the Act requires the application to be approved unless the decision maker is satisfied that the person poses a risk to the safety of children. The Act defines that as a real and appreciable risk, and it is enough that there is a real possibility of the risk without the risk being likely. The threshold is low in one sense, because likelihood is not required, and protective in another, because a speculative or remote risk is not enough. The decision maker must actually be satisfied that the risk exists on the material.
Transitional cases
Reviews that were started before 20 September 2025 continue under the earlier test, under which a blue card was issued unless the case was exceptional for a person without a serious offence conviction, and a negative notice was issued unless the case was exceptional for a person with one. Applicants whose matters straddle the date should confirm which test governs.
The factors that decide assessments
Whichever test applies, the assessment weighs the same kinds of factors. On the risk side: the nature and seriousness of the conduct, whether it involved children or positions of trust, how recent it was, whether there is a pattern, the circumstances in which it occurred and whether those circumstances persist. On the protective side: the time that has passed without further conduct, the person’s insight into what happened and why, treatment or counselling undertaken, stability of employment, relationships and housing, the nature of the regulated work and its supervision, and the evidence of people who know the person and the history. Charges without conviction are considered on the underlying facts as best they can be established, and the person’s account of them matters.
What it means for applicants
A person with an old, isolated offence and a stable life since has a strong position under the real and appreciable risk test, provided they engage with the process and provide evidence. A person with recent or repeated conduct, or conduct involving children, faces a harder task and needs expert evidence addressing risk. A person with a serious offence conviction must build a case that the circumstances are exceptional, which is possible but demands comprehensive evidence of change.
Where the tests are applied
Blue Card Services applies the tests when deciding whether to issue a negative notice and when deciding an application to cancel one. QCAT applies the same tests on review, on the evidence before it at the hearing, and decides for itself what the correct and preferable decision is.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.