- Home
- What we help with
- Land disputes
- Easement disputes
Easement disputes
A shared driveway the neighbour has gated, a drainage easement they have built over, a right of way that no longer gets you where you need to go, or a block that has no legal access at all. Easements are creatures of their registered terms, and most disputes are resolved by reading them properly. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- The documentA registered easement means what its registered terms say. The rights, the maintenance obligations and the area are set out in the easement document and plan.
- InterferenceAn owner who substantially interferes with an easement, by gates, parking, structures or works, can be ordered to remove the obstruction and to pay damages.
- No accessWhere land has no adequate access or services, the Supreme Court can impose a statutory right of use over neighbouring land if it is reasonably necessary, with compensation to the neighbour.
- ForumEasement disputes are court matters: the Magistrates, District or Supreme Court depending on the amount and the orders sought.
The disputes we see most
- A neighbour has locked a gate, parked vehicles or built across a right of way or shared driveway.
- The parties disagree about what the easement allows: vehicles or foot traffic only, how many lots, trucks and machinery, or use for a new development.
- A shared access way or drainage line needs repair and the neighbour will not contribute or will not allow the work.
- Someone has built a shed, pool or retaining wall over a sewer, stormwater or electricity easement.
- Your land is landlocked or has no practical access or services, and the neighbour will not grant an easement.
- A neighbour wants an easement over your land, or wants to vary or remove an existing one, and you need to know what you must accept.
How easements work
An easement is a right that one parcel of land has over another: a right of way, a right to drain water or run services, a right of support. In Queensland most easements are registered on the title under the Land Title Act 1994, and the registered easement document and plan define the rights granted, the area they cover and any obligations about maintenance and cost. The owner of the land that benefits may use the easement for the purposes granted. The owner of the land it crosses may use their land in any way that does not substantially interfere with those rights.
Most easement disputes are about one of three things: whether a particular use falls within the grant, whether something the servient owner has done amounts to an interference, and who pays to maintain the shared way or line. All three start with the words of the document, read in light of how the land was used when the easement was created.
Where land has no access
Land that cannot be used effectively without crossing a neighbour’s land, or without connecting to services across it, is dealt with by the neighbouring land provisions of the Property Law Act 2023. The Supreme Court may impose a statutory right of use over the neighbouring land where it is reasonably necessary for the effective use and development of the applicant’s land, where the owner of the neighbouring land can be adequately compensated and has unreasonably refused to agree after reasonable attempts to reach agreement, and where the right is consistent with planning law and the public interest. The applicant ordinarily pays compensation and the costs of the proceeding. The same provisions give the Supreme Court power to modify or extinguish an easement that has become obsolete, that impedes a reasonable use of the burdened land or that no longer provides a practical benefit of substantial value.
Where these disputes are decided
Claims for injunctions, declarations and damages about an easement are brought in the Magistrates Court (to $150,000), the District Court (to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027) or the Supreme Court, depending on the amount and the relief sought. Applications for a statutory right of use and for modification or extinguishment of an easement are made to the Supreme Court.
What usually happens
A letter that attaches the registered easement, explains what it permits and identifies the breach resolves many of these disputes, because the other owner has often never read the document. Where the problem is that the easement no longer suits either property, the practical answer is usually a new or varied easement, with compensation if one side gains, registered so that it binds future owners. Where interference continues, a court can act quickly to stop it.
What we do
- Obtain and read the registered easement, the plan and the title, and advise you in writing on what the easement permits, who must maintain it and whether what the neighbour is doing is a breach.
- Write to the other owner setting out the position and the orders you will seek, and negotiate an agreed outcome, including a new or varied easement and compensation where appropriate.
- Act in court for injunctions to stop interference, declarations about the meaning of the easement and damages, and defend claims brought against you.
- Prepare and run applications for a statutory right of use, or for the modification or extinguishment of an easement, in the Supreme Court.
Common questions
My neighbour has put a gate across the right of way. Can they do that?
It depends on the terms of the easement and the degree of interference. A gate that is unlocked and does not substantially interfere with the use of the easement may be permitted. A locked gate, parked vehicles or a structure that prevents or substantially obstructs the use the easement grants is an actionable interference, and a court can order it removed and award damages. The first step is to read the registered terms.
Who maintains a shared driveway?
The easement document usually says. Many provide that the cost is shared equally, or in proportion to use, and some place the burden on the owner of the land that benefits. Where the document is silent, the owner who benefits from the easement is generally responsible for maintaining it, and the owner of the land it crosses must not obstruct it. We check the document first and advise from there.
Can an easement be used for a new development or a different purpose?
An easement can only be used for the purposes, and to the extent, that its terms allow. A right of way granted for a single house may not be used to serve a subdivision or a commercial operation if that substantially increases the burden on the land it crosses. Whether a particular change is permitted turns on the words of the grant and the nature of the use when it was created.
My land has no legal access. What can I do?
If the neighbour will not agree to grant an easement on reasonable terms, the Property Law Act 2023 allows an application to the Supreme Court for a statutory right of use. The court must be satisfied that the right is reasonably necessary for the effective use and development of your land, that it is consistent with planning law and the public interest, that the neighbour can be adequately compensated, and that you made reasonable attempts to reach agreement which failed because the refusal was unreasonable. The applicant pays compensation and, unless there are special circumstances, the costs of the proceeding.
Can an easement be removed?
Easements can be surrendered by agreement and registered accordingly. Without agreement, the Supreme Court can modify or extinguish an easement where it has become obsolete, where its continued existence would impede a reasonable use of the burdened land or would provide no practical benefit of substantial value, where it has been abandoned, or where the people entitled to it have agreed or would not be substantially injured. Those applications are decided on evidence about how the easement is actually used.
I built over a drainage easement without knowing. What happens?
The authority that holds the easement, usually the council or a utility, can require the structure to be removed and can refuse to approve works over it. Some authorities will permit minor structures by agreement. It is also a disclosure issue if you sell. We can advise on the authority's rights and negotiate a practical outcome.
Articles on easement disputes
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about easement disputes. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- No legal access to your land? Statutory rights of use under the Property Law Act 2023Where a Queensland landowner needs access, drainage or services across a neighbour's land and the neighbour refuses, the Supreme Court can impose a statutory right of use under section 180 of the Property Law Act 2023. This article explains the test, the compensation and the costs.
- When a neighbour blocks a registered easement: rights, remedies and maintenanceA registered easement in Queensland binds every owner of the burdened land, but neighbours still park across driveways, lock gates and build over pipes. This article explains what the dominant owner can do, the limits on self help and who pays for maintenance.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.