An easement gives the owner of one lot a right over another: to drive across it, to run water and sewer pipes beneath it, to drain onto it or to have it kept clear for light or support. Once registered under the Land Title Act 1994 the easement is noted on both titles and binds every future owner of the burdened land. Problems arise when the servient owner treats the easement as their own: a car parked across the access strip, a gate padlocked, a shed built over the drainage line.
Start with the document
The rights depend on the registered easement document and the plan. A right of way may be limited to pedestrian access, to vehicles of a certain kind or to particular hours. A services easement may allow pipes to be laid and maintained but not a driveway built over it. The plan shows the exact area. Before any complaint is made, obtain a copy of the registered easement and the plan from the titles registry and read them against what is happening on the ground.
Interference
The servient owner remains the owner of the land and may use it in any way that does not substantially interfere with the dominant owner’s rights. The question is one of degree. A gate that the dominant owner can open is usually not an interference; a locked gate without a key is. Landscaping that narrows a driveway so a standard vehicle cannot pass is an interference; a garden bed at the edge that leaves ample room is not. Building a permanent structure over a drainage easement that prevents access for repair is a clear interference even if the pipe keeps working.
Substantial interference with an easement is actionable as a private nuisance. The dominant owner can seek an injunction requiring the obstruction to be removed and restraining future interference, together with damages for loss suffered, such as the cost of alternative access or repair of pipes that could not be reached. These claims are brought in the District Court, where the value of the dispute is within its monetary limit, or the Supreme Court. QCAT does not have jurisdiction over easement disputes between owners.
Self help
The dominant owner may do what is reasonably necessary to exercise the right, such as removing a chain across a right of way, but must not go further, must not damage the servient owner’s property beyond what is unavoidable and must not use force against people. Removing a locked gate or demolishing a structure is a step that should not be taken without legal advice and usually not without an order, because an error exposes the dominant owner to a claim for trespass and damage. A written demand setting out the easement terms, the interference and a date by which it must be removed is the usual first step, followed by an application for an injunction if the demand is ignored.
Maintenance and repair
Who pays to grade the driveway or replace the pipe depends first on the easement document. Many modern easements set out maintenance obligations and cost sharing. Where the document is silent, the general position is that the dominant owner is entitled to maintain and repair the easement at its own expense and has an implied right of access to do so, but neither owner is obliged to repair for the benefit of the other. Where both owners use the way, courts have apportioned costs according to use, and a written agreement is far better than litigation about gravel.
Excessive use
Interference runs in both directions. A dominant owner who uses a right of way for a purpose outside the grant, for example commercial traffic over an easement granted for residential access, or who allows the land they benefit to be subdivided so that the easement serves more lots than intended, can be restrained by the servient owner.
Extinguishment and modification
Easements do not lapse through non use alone. They can be surrendered by agreement and registration, and section 181 of the Property Law Act 2023 allows a person with an interest in the burdened land to apply to the court for an order modifying or extinguishing an easement. The grounds include that the easement has become obsolete because of a change in the use of the benefited land or the character of the area, that its continued existence would impede a reasonable use of the burdened land or would not provide a practical benefit of substantial value to anyone entitled to it, that the benefited owners have abandoned it, or that they have agreed to or would not be substantially injured by the change. The court must take the planning scheme into account and can make any order the case requires. Those applications are relatively uncommon and need valuation and planning evidence.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.