People assume they have a right to cancel. Often they do not. The starting point in Australian law is that a contract binds, and a consumer who simply changes their mind has no right to a refund unless the business’s policy gives one. Around that starting point sit a set of specific rights that do allow cancellation, and a set of rules about what a business may require when a consumer cancels.
Statutory cooling off periods
Unsolicited consumer agreements, meaning contracts made as a result of a seller approaching the consumer at home, by telephone or in a public place without invitation, carry a cooling off period of 10 business days under section 82 of the Australian Consumer Law, during which the consumer can terminate by notice, with longer periods where the seller did not comply with the disclosure requirements. In Queensland a buyer of a used car from a licensed dealer has one business day, a buyer of residential property has five business days, and a home owner under a regulated domestic building contract, meaning domestic building work worth more than $3,300, has five business days after receiving a copy of the signed contract. Each of those periods has its own rules about notice and the amount the other party may keep, and none applies to private sales or auctions.
Refunds under the guarantees
Where goods or services have failed to meet the consumer guarantees, the consumer’s remedies arise regardless of the business’s refund policy. A refund for a major failure, or for a minor failure the business did not fix within a reasonable time, is a right. A business may not require the consumer to return goods to the manufacturer, may not insist on a credit note in place of a refund where the consumer is entitled to one, and may not deduct a restocking fee from a refund the law requires.
What a business may say
Section 29(1)(m) makes it a false or misleading representation to say anything about the existence, exclusion or effect of a guarantee, right or remedy that is untrue. Signs reading no refunds, no refunds on sale items, or no refunds after seven days, are misleading because they suggest the consumer has no rights when the guarantees are not met. A business is free to have a no change of mind policy, and to say so, provided the words do not suggest that the statutory rights are also excluded.
Unfair cancellation terms
Standard form contracts with consumers and with small businesses are subject to the unfair contract terms provisions in sections 23 to 28. A term is unfair if it would cause a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights, is not reasonably necessary to protect the legitimate interests of the business and would cause detriment if relied on, judged in the context of the contract as a whole and the transparency of the term. Terms allowing the business to cancel or vary the contract at will while locking the consumer in, imposing cancellation fees far above the business’s actual loss, automatically renewing a contract without notice, or allowing the business to keep the whole of a deposit regardless of the reason for cancellation, are the usual candidates. An unfair term is void, and the contract continues without it. Since 9 November 2023 a business that proposes, applies or relies on an unfair term is exposed to substantial penalties, which has changed the negotiating position of consumers who identify one.
Subscriptions and memberships
Gym memberships, subscriptions and service plans often combine a minimum term with automatic renewal and a cancellation fee. The minimum term is generally enforceable. Automatic renewal is enforceable if it was clearly disclosed and the consumer was given notice; a renewal buried in terms the consumer never saw is a strong candidate for an unfair term. Cancellation fees must reflect the business’s loss, and a fee that recovers the full balance of the contract where the business saves its own costs by not providing the service is open to challenge.
Gift cards
Gift cards sold since 1 November 2019 must be redeemable for at least three years from the date of supply, must display the expiry date and cannot carry post supply fees, under section 99B and the associated provisions. A card that a business refuses to honour within that period gives rise to a claim for its value.
Events and services that did not happen
Where the business cancelled, or could not deliver what was contracted, the consumer is entitled to a refund of what was paid for services not provided, and a credit note can be refused. Where the consumer cancelled, the terms of the contract govern, subject to the unfair terms provisions and the rule that the business can keep only a genuine estimate of its loss. Where an event was cancelled because of a circumstance beyond either party’s control, the rights depend on the contract’s force majeure clause, if any, and on the law of frustration.
Recovering the money
Write to the business identifying the right you rely on and the amount. If it is not paid, claims up to $25,000 go to QCAT as consumer and trader disputes. Where the payment was by card, a chargeback through the card issuer is a practical alternative for services not provided, and should be requested promptly because the schemes impose time limits.
We assist with consumer disputes about goods or services worth more than $10,000. Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.