The salesperson said the car had never been in an accident. The brochure said the course was accredited. The listing said the apartment had council approval for the extension. Each statement was false, and the buyer relied on it. The Australian Consumer Law gives a remedy that does not require proof that the seller knew the truth.
Section 18
Section 18 provides that a person must not, in trade or commerce, engage in conduct that is misleading or deceptive or is likely to mislead or deceive. The test is objective: whether the conduct, viewed as a whole in its context, would lead a reasonable person in the position of the buyer into error. The seller’s honesty is irrelevant. A seller who passes on false information from a previous owner in good faith has still engaged in misleading conduct, though the court will consider whether the seller was merely a conduit who disclaimed any belief in the information.
Conduct includes statements, advertising, images, omissions and silence where there was a reasonable expectation that a matter would be disclosed. A half truth, accurate as far as it goes but leaving out what matters, is misleading. Under section 4, a representation about a future matter, such as what a product will achieve or what a business will earn, is taken to be misleading unless the person making it had reasonable grounds for it, and the burden of showing those grounds falls on the maker.
Section 29
Section 29 prohibits specific false or misleading representations in connection with the supply or promotion of goods or services: that they are of a particular standard, quality, value, grade, composition, style or model, or have had a particular history or previous use; that they are new; that a particular person has agreed to acquire them; that they have sponsorship, approval, performance characteristics, accessories, uses or benefits they do not have; about price; about the availability of repairs or parts; about the place of origin; about the need for goods or services; and about the existence, exclusion or effect of any condition, warranty, guarantee, right or remedy. A sign saying no refunds is a representation about the existence of rights and is misleading where the consumer guarantees apply. Breaches of section 29 also attract penalties enforced by the regulator.
What is not actionable
Puffery, meaning vague commendation that no reasonable person would take literally, is not misleading. An opinion honestly held on a reasonable basis is not misleading merely because it turns out to be wrong, although the implied representation that the opinion was held and had a basis can be. A statement that was corrected before the buyer committed is not relied on. And the buyer must have been misled: a buyer who knew the truth, or who did their own investigation and relied on it rather than the statement, cannot recover.
Disclaimers and entire agreement clauses do not exclude liability under section 18, because the Act cannot be contracted out of. They can be relevant to whether the buyer in fact relied on the statement, and a clear disclaimer may prevent the conduct from being misleading at all if it corrects the impression before the buyer acts. A general clause buried in standard terms rarely does so against a specific oral statement.
Remedies
Section 236 allows a person who suffers loss or damage because of a contravention of section 18 or section 29 to recover the amount of the loss from the person who engaged in the conduct, and from anyone involved in it, such as an employee or agent who made the statement knowing it was false. The action must be begun within six years after the cause of action accrued. The usual measure is the difference between what the buyer paid and what the thing was actually worth, plus consequential losses, and the buyer’s own carelessness can reduce damages where the conduct was not intentional. Sections 237 and 243 allow the court to make other orders, including declaring the contract void, varying it, ordering a refund on return of the goods, or ordering repair or replacement.
Evidence
Misleading conduct cases are won on contemporaneous records: the advertisement or listing saved at the time, the brochure, the emails and text messages, notes of what was said and when, and evidence that the statement was false, such as an independent inspection or a search of the relevant register. A buyer who writes to the seller promptly after discovering the truth, setting out the statement relied on and why it was wrong, has preserved both the evidence and the credibility of the claim.
Forum
Claims up to $25,000 against a trader are minor civil disputes in QCAT. Larger claims go to the Magistrates Court up to $150,000 and the District Court above that. Complaints can also be made to the Office of Fair Trading or the ACCC, which may take regulatory action but do not recover money for individuals.
We assist with consumer disputes about goods or services worth more than $10,000. Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.