A product fails. The supplier offers a repair, or says the warranty has expired, or blames the manufacturer. The consumer wants their money back. Who is right depends on the consumer guarantees in the Australian Consumer Law and on whether the failure is major or minor, which is the distinction that determines who gets to choose the remedy.
Who is a consumer and what is guaranteed
A person acquires goods as a consumer if the price was $100,000 or less, or if the goods are of a kind ordinarily acquired for personal, domestic or household use, unless they were bought for resupply or for use in manufacturing. Business purchasers are consumers if the price is within the threshold. The guarantees apply to goods supplied in trade or commerce, which excludes private sales.
Section 54 guarantees that goods are of acceptable quality: fit for all the purposes for which goods of that kind are commonly supplied, acceptable in appearance and finish, free from defects, safe and durable, judged by what a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with the goods’ condition would regard as acceptable, taking into account the price, the description and any statements made about them. Goods are not unacceptable because of a defect that was specifically drawn to the consumer’s attention before purchase, or that an examination by the consumer ought to have revealed if they examined them. Section 55 guarantees fitness for any particular purpose the consumer made known, and section 56 guarantees correspondence with description. The guarantees apply for as long as a reasonable consumer would expect the goods to last, which depends on the goods and the price, not on the length of the manufacturer’s warranty.
Major failures
Under section 260 a failure is major if the goods would not have been acquired by a reasonable consumer fully acquainted with the nature and extent of the failure; if they depart significantly from their description or sample; if they are substantially unfit for their ordinary purpose or a disclosed purpose and cannot easily be made fit within a reasonable time; or if they are unsafe. ACCC guidance also treats a series of failures, none of which is major on its own, as together capable of amounting to a major failure where the goods would not have been bought had the consumer known of them.
For a major failure section 259(3) gives the consumer the choice. The consumer can reject the goods and, under section 263, choose a refund or an identical replacement if one is reasonably available, or can keep the goods and recover compensation for the reduction in their value below the price paid. The supplier cannot insist on repairing a major failure.
Minor failures
Where the failure is not major, section 259(2) requires the consumer to give the supplier an opportunity to remedy it, and the supplier may choose to repair, replace or refund. If the supplier refuses or fails to remedy the failure within a reasonable time, the consumer may have it fixed elsewhere and recover the reasonable cost, or may reject the goods and obtain a refund or replacement. A reasonable time depends on the goods; a few days for a kettle, longer for a complex appliance that requires parts.
Rejection
Rejection must occur within the rejection period, which is the period in which it would be reasonable to expect the failure to become apparent, and is lost if the goods were lost or destroyed, damaged after delivery for reasons unrelated to their condition, or attached to other property so that they cannot be removed without damage. The consumer notifies the supplier and returns the goods unless the cost or difficulty of returning them is significant, in which case the supplier collects them.
Consequential loss
Section 259(4) allows the consumer to recover damages for any reasonably foreseeable loss caused by the failure, in addition to the remedy for the goods themselves: food spoiled by a failed refrigerator, flooring damaged by a leaking washing machine, the cost of hiring a replacement.
Supplier or manufacturer
The supplier is responsible for the guarantees and must provide the refund or replacement; it cannot send the consumer to the manufacturer. The manufacturer is directly liable to the consumer under sections 271 and 272 for damages, including the reduction in value, and a supplier who pays out can recover from the manufacturer. Where the supplier has closed, the manufacturer claim is the fallback, and it must be brought within three years of when the consumer became aware, or ought reasonably to have become aware, of the failure.
Where claims are brought
Claims up to $25,000 are minor civil disputes in QCAT, which can order a refund, a replacement remedy by way of payment, repair work or the return of goods. Larger claims go to the Magistrates Court. A supplier’s refusal to honour the guarantees, or statements that no refunds are available, can also be reported to the Office of Fair Trading, although that office does not resolve individual disputes.
We assist with consumer disputes about goods or services worth more than $10,000. Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.