Property is often bought by siblings, friends, former partners or business associates who later disagree about what to do with it. One wants to sell and the other refuses, or will only sell on their own terms. Queensland law does not leave the co owner who wants out trapped. Part 5 of the Property Law Act 2023 lets any co owner ask the court to order that the property be sold and to appoint trustees to sell it.
The application
A co owner, whether a joint tenant or a tenant in common, may apply to the court under section 33 for the sale of the property and the division of the proceeds, for the physical division of the property, or for a combination of the two. Where it considers it necessary or desirable, the court may appoint a trustee under section 37 to carry out the sale or division, still commonly called a statutory trustee for sale. The Supreme Court has jurisdiction, and the District Court can hear the application where the value of the property is within its monetary limit, which is $750,000 and rises to $1.5 million for proceedings started on or after 1 January 2027. The application is supported by an affidavit setting out the title, the parties’ shares, any mortgage, the history of the dealings between the co owners and a valuation.
Within 30 days after making the application, the applicant must give a copy of it to each person who holds a security interest over the property, such as the bank, whether or not the interest is registered. Those parties may appear and are paid out of the proceeds.
What the court considers
Section 35 expresses a preference for sale over physical division of the land. If the court decides to make an order, it must order a sale unless it considers that division, or a combination of sale and division, would be more just and fair, having regard to the use being made of the property, whether it can practicably be divided, and any particular attachment a co owner has to it, for example because it is unique or has a special value to one of them. The court can refuse to make an order. Under the equivalent provisions of the 1974 Act the courts treated that discretion as narrow, and a co owner who simply did not want to sell, or who preferred to wait for a better market, did not usually have a sufficient reason. Reasons that carried weight included an existing agreement between the co owners not to sell, or a sale that would defeat a trust or arrangement under which one party was entitled to occupy. Where there are family law proceedings on foot between the co owners, section 43 allows the application to be adjourned or stayed so that the family court can deal with the property.
How the sale happens
The trustees appointed are usually independent, often solicitors or accountants nominated by the applicant, though the court can appoint one of the co owners in appropriate cases. The property vests in the trustees, who market and sell it, usually by auction or at a price not less than a valuation. Section 39 lets the court fix terms, including a reserve price, an independent valuation and permission for a co owner to buy at the sale.
From the proceeds the trustees pay the costs of sale, any mortgage, their own remuneration and the costs of the application as ordered. The balance is held for the co owners in their shares, subject to adjustment.
Adjustments between the co owners
Sections 40 to 42 deal with the accounting between the parties, which is where most of the argument usually lies. The court can order compensation, reimbursement or an adjustment of the co owners’ interests, and must consider amounts reasonably spent on improving the property, costs reasonably incurred in maintaining or insuring it, damage caused by unreasonable use, and payments by one co owner of more than their share of rates, mortgage repayments and other outgoings. Occupation rent, a charge against the co owner who lived in the property while the other did not, can only be ordered where the occupying co owner seeks reimbursement for money they spent on the property, where the other co owner was excluded, or where the other co owner suffered a detriment because it was not practicable to live there with the occupying co owner. The court has broad power to do what is just between the parties and will often net these items off against each other.
Costs
The costs of the application are generally paid from the proceeds, so that both co owners bear them in proportion to their shares. A co owner who resists an application without a good reason and forces a contested hearing may be ordered to pay the applicant’s costs personally.
Before applying
An application is rarely the first step. A written proposal to the other co owner, offering a sale on the open market or a buy out at valuation, costs little and often produces agreement once the co owner understands that the court is likely to order a sale anyway. If the proposal is refused, the application follows.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Property Law Act 2023 (Qld), ss 27 and 33 to 43 (co ownership, sale or division and accounting)
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68(1)(b)(vi)
- Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 (Qld), ss 2 and 62 (District Court monetary limit $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027)