Co owners rarely contribute equally. One pays the mortgage while the other pays nothing. One lives in the property while the other rents elsewhere. One pays for a new kitchen on the understanding, never written down, that it will be recognised later. When the property is finally sold these contributions have to be reconciled, and the Property Law Act 2023 sets out how Queensland courts approach the task.
The starting point
The proceeds of sale belong to the co owners in their registered shares. Joint tenants hold equally. Tenants in common hold in the shares recorded on the title, which may be unequal. The registered shares are the starting point, and the adjustments below are deductions from or additions to each co owner’s entitlement, not a rewriting of the shares themselves. A co owner who believes the registered shares do not reflect the true agreement, for example because they paid the whole deposit, is making a different claim, usually a constructive or resulting trust, which has to be pleaded and proved separately.
Outgoings and the mortgage
A co owner who paid more than their proportion of the mortgage instalments, council rates, water, insurance and necessary repairs can ask the court to order reimbursement of the excess from the other co owner’s share of the proceeds. The payments must be proved, usually by bank statements, and the claim is for the amount actually paid above the co owner’s share, not the whole amount. Interest on the excess can be awarded but is in the court’s discretion.
There is a well known qualification. A co owner who occupied the property and claims reimbursement of the mortgage interest and outgoings they paid while living there opens the door to a charge for occupation rent against them. Courts often treat the two as roughly offsetting where the occupying co owner paid the interest and outgoings alone, which can make a claim for reimbursement unattractive.
Improvements
Section 40 requires the court to consider amounts a co owner reasonably spent on improving the property, and leaves the amount of any credit to the court. Under the general law the allowance was limited to the lesser of what the improvements cost and the amount by which they increased the value of the property. On that approach, a new roof that cost $40,000 and added $25,000 to the sale price produces a credit of $25,000, and a landscaping project that cost $15,000 and added nothing produces no credit at all. Evidence from a valuer about the increase in value is usually needed. Routine maintenance and decorating are not improvements and are dealt with, if at all, as outgoings.
Occupation rent
A co owner is entitled to occupy the whole of the property and does not have to pay rent to the other merely because the other chooses to live elsewhere. Occupation rent can be ordered only in three situations identified in section 40: where the occupying co owner seeks compensation, reimbursement or an accounting for money they spent on the property, where the other co owner was excluded from the property, and where the other co owner suffered a detriment because it was not practicable for them to live there with the occupying co owner. Exclusion does not require a changed lock, and a relationship breakdown that makes living together impracticable is the kind of case the third situation is directed to.
The rate is usually a share of the market rent, assessed by a valuer or agent, for the period of sole occupation, less an allowance for the outgoings the occupier paid. Where the occupier also paid the whole mortgage, the two claims frequently cancel out.
Rent received from tenants
Where the property was let to a tenant and one co owner collected the rent, the other co owner is entitled to an account of their share of the net rent after outgoings. Section 41 allows a co owner to apply for an accounting of that kind, and section 42 sets out the orders the court may make to adjust the position between them.
Proving it
These claims live or die on records. Bank statements showing who paid the mortgage, rates notices and receipts, invoices for improvements, photographs, valuation evidence and any written agreement between the co owners should be assembled before the sale proceeding is started, because the court deals with the adjustments at the same time as the appointment of trustees or when the trustees seek directions on distribution. A co owner who cannot prove payments is unlikely to be credited for them.
Agreement first
Because the rules are reasonably predictable, co owners who understand them can often agree the adjustments and avoid a contested hearing. A written proposal that sets out each item with supporting documents is usually the fastest route to a resolution.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.