A note in the letterbox asking for half the cost of a new fence is one of the most common neighbour disputes in Queensland. The Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 sets out when a neighbour must contribute, how much and what happens if they refuse.
The basic rule
Adjoining owners are liable to contribute in equal shares to carrying out fencing work for a sufficient dividing fence. A dividing fence is a fence on the common boundary, or on a line as close to the boundary as practicable, that separates the two parcels. Between two parcels of residential land, a sufficient dividing fence is one that is between 0.5 and 1.8 metres high and made substantially of a prescribed material, which includes timber, chain wire, metal panels, bricks, rendered cement, concrete blocks and hedges, unless a local law provides otherwise. Between two parcels of pastoral land the test is a fence sufficient to restrain the livestock grazed on each parcel. In any case, a fence the owners agree is sufficient, or QCAT decides is sufficient, meets the standard.
Equal contribution applies to a sufficient fence. If one owner wants something better, higher or more decorative than that, the owner who wants it pays the difference. If the existing fence is a sufficient one and simply old, the neighbour cannot be made to contribute to replacing it merely because the other prefers new.
Who is an owner
The Act applies to the owners of adjoining land. A tenant is not the owner, so the notice must go to the landlord, although a landlord can pass part of its share on to a tenant whose lease has five or more years to run if it gives the tenant a copy of the notice. Where the adjoining land is a community titles scheme, the body corporate is the owner for common property boundaries. A local government is not treated as an owner of land used as a public park, the Act does not apply to unallocated State land or stock routes, and no contribution is payable between two parcels of agricultural land. A fence along a park or a road is therefore usually the private owner’s own cost, although owners of rural land on either side of a road can agree, or QCAT can decide, that a fence on one side of the road is their dividing fence.
The notice to contribute
The obligation to contribute is triggered by a written notice to contribute for fencing work under section 31. The notice must be in the approved form, which is available through QCAT and the Queensland Government website. It must describe the land and the line on which the fence is proposed, the type of fencing work and the estimated cost including labour and materials, and must be accompanied by a copy of at least one written quotation. An owner who proposes that the cost be shared other than equally must state the proposed proportions. A verbal request or a text message does not start the process, and a neighbour who builds the fence first and asks for money afterwards will usually find that nothing is recoverable because the required notice was never given.
Once the notice is given the owners have one month to agree. If they agree, the agreement should be put in writing because it binds the parties and can be enforced. If they have not agreed within one month after the notice is given, either owner may apply to QCAT, but the application must be made within two months after the notice is given. Both periods run from the notice, so in practice about one month is left in which to apply. An owner who misses that window will usually have to start again with a fresh notice.
QCAT orders
QCAT deals with fence disputes as minor civil disputes, where the amount in issue is up to $25,000. It can order whether fencing work is needed, the type of fence, where it goes, who does the work, how the cost is shared and when payment is due. It can also deal with a dispute about the line of the boundary for the purpose of the fence, though it cannot decide title. The tribunal expects the parties to have made a reasonable effort to resolve the matter and to have given the notice. Parties usually represent themselves, and legal representation requires leave.
Urgent and damaged fences
Two exceptions to the notice requirement are worth knowing. Where a fence is damaged or destroyed and needs urgent work, for example after a storm, an owner may carry out the work without a notice to contribute if it is impracticable to give one, and then give a notice afterwards seeking contribution. If the owners have not agreed about their contributions within one month after that notice is given, either may apply to QCAT, again within two months after the notice is given. Separately, where a fence is damaged or destroyed by a negligent or deliberate act or omission of one owner, or of a person who entered that owner’s land with the owner’s express consent, such as a tenant or visitor, that owner must restore it at their own cost and cannot ask the neighbour to contribute.
Retaining walls
A retaining wall is not a dividing fence, and the Act does not require a neighbour to contribute to one. QCAT can order work to a retaining wall only where it is necessary to carry out the fencing work. Disputes about who pays for a failing retaining wall are decided under different principles.
What to do
If you want a new fence, get two quotes, serve a proper notice to contribute, keep proof of service and note the date two months after the notice is given, which is the last day to apply to QCAT if there is no agreement. If you receive a notice, respond in writing within the month, either agreeing, proposing a different fence or disputing the need for the work. Either way, do not start building until there is an agreement or an order.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.