The ordinary process for dividing fence work in Queensland is notice first, agreement or QCAT order second, and work last. Real life does not always allow that. A storm takes the fence down and the dog is out, or a neighbour’s contractor reverses into it. The Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 has specific provisions for both situations.
Urgent fencing work
Section 28 applies where a dividing fence has been damaged or destroyed and fencing work is needed urgently. If it is impracticable to give the neighbour a notice to contribute before the work is done, the owner may carry out the work without a notice and then seek contribution afterwards. Impracticability is judged realistically. If the neighbour is contactable and the damage is cosmetic, notice is practicable and should be given. If the fence is down, stock or pets are escaping, children or a pool are involved, and the neighbour is away, an owner who acts promptly is on firm ground.
The work done should be limited to what is urgent and reasonable. Restoring the fence to its previous standard is recoverable; upgrading it to something better is not, unless the neighbour later agrees. Keep photographs of the damage before and after, obtain a quote if time allows, and keep every receipt.
The notice after urgent work
Once the work is done, an owner who wants a contribution must give the other owner a notice under section 32. The notice must be in the approved form and state the land on which the work was carried out, the reason urgent fencing work was required, the type of work carried out and the cost incurred, with a receipt for the cost. An owner who proposes that the cost be shared other than equally must state the proposed proportions. Under section 32(6), if the owners have not agreed about their contributions within one month after the notice is given, either owner may apply to QCAT, but must do so within two months after the notice is given. The notice and the time limit are not optional. An owner who repairs the fence and simply sends an invoice, or who gives the notice and then lets the two months pass, will usually be met with the answer that no valid notice was given or that the application is out of time.
Fences damaged by a neighbour
Section 26 deals with a different situation. Where a dividing fence is damaged or destroyed by a negligent or deliberate act or omission of an owner, or of a person who entered the owner’s land with the owner’s express consent, that owner must restore the fence to a reasonable standard, having regard to its state before the damage, at their own cost. The neighbour is not required to contribute. A tenant, a visitor or a tradesperson the owner engaged will usually be a person on the land with the owner’s express consent. The section does not mention livestock, so damage done by an owner’s animals is covered only where it results from the owner’s negligent or deliberate act or omission, such as failing to keep stock contained.
If the responsible owner does not restore the fence, the Act points to two courses. The other owner may give a notice to contribute under section 31, proposing that the responsible owner bear the whole cost, or, where urgent work is required and it is impracticable to give that notice first, may carry out the work and then give a notice under section 32. If the owners have not agreed within one month after the notice is given, either owner may apply to QCAT within two months after the notice is given (sections 31(6) and 32(6)). QCAT hears dividing fence disputes up to $25,000 as minor civil disputes. The claim is for the reasonable cost of restoring the fence to its prior condition, not for a new and better fence. Where the fence was old, an argument about betterment can be expected.
Trees and natural causes
A fence crushed by a neighbour’s falling tree is not automatically the neighbour’s responsibility under section 26, because a tree falling in a storm is not usually a negligent or deliberate act. The position changes if the neighbour knew the tree was dangerous and did nothing. The Act’s tree provisions, which make the tree keeper responsible for serious damage caused by the tree, and the general law of negligence and nuisance then come into play. A fence damaged by weather alone, with no one at fault, is repaired under the ordinary equal contribution rules.
Insurance
Many home policies cover fence damage from storm or impact. Check the policy before paying for the repair, because the insurer may pay for the whole fence and recover from the neighbour itself. If you do claim on your own insurance, tell the insurer about the neighbour’s involvement so the insurer’s recovery rights are preserved.
Evidence
Every one of these claims is decided on evidence of the damage, its cause and the reasonable cost of repair. Photographs with dates, a short written record of what happened, the names of witnesses, quotes and receipts are what QCAT looks for. A letter to the neighbour setting out the facts and asking for payment within a stated period, before any application, both satisfies the Act’s expectation that the parties try to agree and often ends the matter.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.