Trees are a common source of friction between neighbours, and the common law gave neighbours very little: the right to cut branches at the boundary and return them, and a claim in nuisance only when real damage had been done. Chapter 3 of the Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 replaced that with a structured scheme for Queensland. It helps to know what the scheme does and does not allow before a dispute starts.
Who is the tree keeper
The person responsible for a tree is its tree keeper, which section 48 defines, for a tree on freehold land, as the registered owner of the land where the tree’s trunk stands. Sections 41 and 52 make the tree keeper responsible for the proper care and maintenance of the tree, for cutting and removing branches that overhang a neighbour’s land and for ensuring the tree does not cause serious injury, serious damage or substantial ongoing and unreasonable interference with a neighbour’s use of their land. Section 52 states responsibilities; it does not of itself create a right to sue, and the remedies come from the notice procedure and QCAT.
Under section 42 the chapter does not apply to trees on rural land, on a parcel of more than four hectares or on council land used as a public park. For a tree in a council park, the local council’s own processes apply.
Overhanging branches: the notice procedure
Section 57 provides a self help route for lower branches. It applies to a branch that extends at least 50 centimetres over the neighbour’s land from the common boundary, to the extent the branch is 2.5 metres or less above the ground. The neighbour may give the tree keeper a written notice asking for the branches to be cut and removed. The notice must state a time, at least 30 days after the notice is given, by which the work is to be done. It must give the tree keeper or their contractor permission to enter the neighbour’s land between 8am and 5pm on a day the tree keeper notifies in writing beforehand, and it must be accompanied by at least one written quotation for the work and a copy of the relevant part of the Act. A neighbour cannot give the notice if they have given another one to the same tree keeper, for any tree, within the previous 12 months.
If the tree keeper does nothing, section 58 allows the neighbour to have the branches cut and to recover up to $300 from the tree keeper as a debt, which can be claimed in QCAT. The limit is modest by design; the procedure is for routine pruning, not major work.
For branches that do not meet the height and overhang thresholds, the neighbour retains the common law right to cut back to the boundary at their own expense, provided the tree is not protected by a vegetation protection order or local law and the cutting does not damage the tree.
More serious problems: QCAT
Sections 61 and 62 allow a neighbour to apply to QCAT where land is affected by a tree. Land is affected if branches overhang it, or if the tree has caused, is causing or is likely within the next 12 months to cause serious injury to a person on the land, serious damage to the land or property on it, or substantial, ongoing and unreasonable interference with the neighbour’s use and enjoyment of the land. Roots lifting a driveway, branches threatening a roof, and persistent heavy leaf fall into a pool or gutters can qualify, though ordinary leaf litter and shade rarely do.
Before applying, the neighbour must have made a reasonable effort to reach agreement with the tree keeper, and where the branch notice procedure was available, must have used it. QCAT can order the tree keeper to cut, remove or maintain the tree, to carry out work to prevent damage, to pay compensation for damage already caused, and to pay for an arborist’s report. It can also authorise the neighbour to enter the land to do work the tree keeper fails to do.
Sunlight and views
Section 66(3) sets a high bar. QCAT can make an order about obstruction of sunlight or a view only where the tree rises at least 2.5 metres above the ground and the obstruction is severe: severe obstruction of sunlight to a window or roof of a dwelling on the neighbour’s land, or severe obstruction of a view, from a dwelling on the neighbour’s land, that existed when the neighbour took possession of the land. The comparison is between the view from the dwelling when the neighbour took possession and the view now. The fact that the tree was already growing at that time does not by itself rule out an order, but section 75 allows QCAT to consider whether the tree existed before the neighbour acquired the land. The provision protects a view from a dwelling, not every outlook from the property. The tribunal weighs the tree’s contribution to amenity, privacy, habitat and the landscape against the obstruction, and orders removal only as a last resort.
Before you cut or apply
Check whether the tree is protected by local law or a vegetation protection order, photograph the problem, measure the overhang and height, and write to the tree keeper first. If the branch notice applies, use the Queensland Government’s Form 3, Notice for removal of particular overhanging branches. If the problem is more serious, obtain an arborist’s view before applying.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.