A neighbour’s tree can do expensive damage. Roots lift driveways and crack slabs, branches come through roofs and carports, and a tree that has been dying for years finally falls on the fence and the car. The Neighbourhood Disputes (Dividing Fences and Trees) Act 2011 gives Queensland neighbours a direct route to compensation and to orders that stop the damage recurring.
Who is responsible
The tree keeper, defined in section 48, is the registered owner of the land on which the tree’s trunk is situated. Under section 52 the tree keeper is responsible for ensuring the tree does not cause serious injury to a person, serious damage to a neighbour’s land or property on it, or substantial, ongoing and unreasonable interference with the neighbour’s use and enjoyment of their land. Under section 47 a tree is situated on the land where the base of its trunk is wholly or mainly situated, so a tree whose trunk straddles the boundary usually has one tree keeper, the owner of the land that holds most of the base. Where a tree has more than one tree keeper, section 53 shares the responsibilities and liabilities equally. Where the tree is on land the tree keeper has sold, the new registered owner becomes the tree keeper, and section 68 deals with trees that have been removed before an order is made.
Land affected by a tree
QCAT’s jurisdiction depends on the neighbour’s land being affected by the tree, as defined in section 46. Land is affected if branches overhang it, or if the tree has caused, is causing, or is likely within the next 12 months to cause serious injury, serious damage or substantial ongoing unreasonable interference. Serious damage is not defined by a dollar figure, but a cracked slab, a damaged roof, a blocked and broken sewer line or a lifted retaining wall will usually qualify. A dropped limb that dented a gutter may not.
The neighbour must have made a reasonable effort to reach agreement with the tree keeper before applying. A letter identifying the tree, describing the damage with photographs and asking for the tree keeper’s insurer’s details or a proposal for repair is the minimum.
What QCAT can order
Section 66 gives QCAT wide powers. It can order the tree keeper to carry out work on the tree, including pruning, root barriers or removal, to pay compensation for damage to the neighbour’s land or property, to pay the cost of repairing damage, to pay for an arborist’s or other expert’s report, and to allow the neighbour to enter the tree keeper’s land to carry out work the tree keeper fails to do. There is no cap on the compensation QCAT can order under the tree provisions, which distinguishes tree claims from most other QCAT matters. The tribunal considers the tree’s contribution to amenity, shade, privacy and habitat, the risk of harm, whether the tree was there before the neighbour, and anything the neighbour did that contributed to the problem.
Negligence and nuisance
The Act does not replace the general law. A neighbour whose property is damaged by a tree can also sue in negligence, where the tree keeper knew or should have known the tree was dangerous and failed to take reasonable steps, and in nuisance where roots or branches interfere unreasonably with the use of land. Those claims are brought in the courts rather than QCAT and can matter where the damage exceeds what QCAT would realistically deal with, where the tree keeper’s insurer is involved, or where the tree has already been removed. Storm damage from a healthy tree that no one could have foreseen is usually no one’s fault, and the neighbour’s own insurance is the realistic source of recovery.
Proving the claim
Tree claims are won on expert evidence. An arborist can say whether the roots causing the damage come from the tree in question, whether the tree is structurally sound, what work would address the risk and whether removal is necessary. A builder or engineer can cost the repairs. Photographs over time, plumbing camera footage for root intrusion and correspondence showing the tree keeper was told about the problem complete the picture. QCAT can order the tree keeper to pay for the report if the application succeeds.
Selling land subject to a tree dispute
Sections 83 to 86 require a seller whose land is the subject of a QCAT tree application or order to give the buyer a copy before the contract is signed. If the seller fails to do so, the buyer may terminate the contract before settlement and recover the deposit within 14 days. The order binds the new owner once registered, which is why buyers should search for tree orders and sellers should resolve disputes before marketing.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.