When a claim is lodged, insurers look back at what was said when the policy was taken out or renewed. If something in the application was wrong or incomplete, the insurer may seek to avoid the policy from the start, or to reduce the claim to nothing. For consumer insurance the rules changed in October 2021, and the change favours policy holders who answered honestly.
The new duty
For consumer insurance contracts entered into, renewed or varied from 5 October 2021, section 20B of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 imposes a duty to take reasonable care not to make a misrepresentation to the insurer. This replaces, for those contracts, the former duty to disclose every matter the insured knew to be relevant. A consumer insurance contract is one obtained wholly or predominantly for personal, domestic or household purposes, which covers home, contents, motor, travel and most personal policies.
Whether the insured took reasonable care is judged by what a reasonable person in the insured’s circumstances would have done, taking into account matters such as the type of policy and its target market, the explanatory material the insurer gave, how clear and specific the insurer’s questions were, how clearly the insurer explained the importance of answering accurately and the consequences of not doing so, whether the insurer had reason to know the insured’s circumstances, and whether an agent was acting for the insured. The insured’s particular characteristics, if known to the insurer, are also relevant. A misrepresentation made fraudulently is always a breach of the duty.
What the insurer must prove
The insurer must identify the question it asked and show that the answer was a misrepresentation made without reasonable care. The emphasis on clear and specific questions is deliberate. An insurer that asks whether the insured has made any claims in the last five years cannot complain about a claim made six years ago, and an insurer that asks a vague question cannot complain about a reasonable interpretation of it. An insured who did not know a fact cannot have misrepresented it, and an insured who answered a renewal notice by not correcting information the insurer pre filled is judged against what the renewal documents actually asked.
For non consumer insurance, the former duty of disclosure continues, and the insured must disclose matters they know or a reasonable person would know to be relevant, subject to the insurer’s obligation to inform them of the duty.
The remedies in section 28
Section 28 governs what the insurer can do for general insurance. Where the misrepresentation was fraudulent, the insurer may avoid the contract from inception, treating it as if it never existed, and may refuse every claim under it. Where it was not fraudulent, the insurer cannot avoid the contract. Instead its liability for the claim is reduced to the amount that would place it in the position it would have been in had the misrepresentation not been made. If the insurer can show it would not have issued the policy at all on any terms, the reduction can be to nil. If it would have issued the policy on different terms, for example at a higher premium or with an exclusion, the claim is adjusted accordingly. The insurer must prove what it would have done by reference to its underwriting guidelines at the time.
Relief against avoidance
Section 31 allows a court, and AFCA applying it, to disregard an avoidance for fraudulent misrepresentation where it would be harsh and unfair not to do so, and where the insurer has not been prejudiced by the failure or any prejudice is minimal or insignificant. The court can then order the insurer to pay the whole or part of the claim. This is a discretionary power reserved for cases where the fraud was peripheral to the risk.
Responding to an avoidance
Ask the insurer in writing for the application or renewal documents, the questions asked and the answers recorded, the evidence of the alleged misrepresentation, and the underwriting evidence of what it would have done. Check whether the contract is a consumer insurance contract and when it was entered. Consider whether the answer was in fact accurate, whether the question was clear, and whether a reasonable person in your position would have answered as you did. Then challenge the decision through internal dispute resolution and, if necessary, AFCA or the courts.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.