Having a claim accepted is only half the battle. Insurers accept storm, fire and water damage claims every day and then present a scope of works prepared by their panel builder that leaves out items, prices others at rates no local builder will match and proposes patching where replacement is needed. The home owner’s own quotes come in at two or three times the figure. Resolving that gap is a dispute about what the policy actually promises.
What the policy promises
Most home building policies promise to repair or rebuild the damaged part of the home to the same condition and standard as it was before the loss, or to pay the cost of doing so, up to the sum insured. Some promise replacement with new materials. The policy, not the insurer’s builder, defines the standard, and an estimate that would not achieve the promised result is simply the wrong number.
Comparing scopes
The first step is to obtain the insurer’s scope of works in full, with the line items, quantities and rates. Under the General Insurance Code of Practice the insurer must, on request, give the customer access to the information it relied on in handling the claim, including reports from its service suppliers and external experts. Then obtain an independent scope and quote from a licensed builder who has inspected the property, ideally one with insurance repair experience. Compare the documents item by item. Disputes typically fall into three categories: items the insurer’s scope omits altogether, items it includes but at a lower specification or quantity, and items both include but at different rates. Identifying which category each difference falls into is what moves the negotiation.
Matching
Where a damaged section cannot be repaired without a visible mismatch, for example tiles no longer manufactured or a carpet in an open plan area, the question is whether the policy requires undamaged areas to be replaced to achieve a reasonable match. Policies address this in different ways, and some limit matching to the room or the nearest break. Read the clause and apply it to the facts; insurers do not always apply their own wording.
Upgrades and compliance
Repairs must comply with current building law, which may require upgrades the original home did not have, such as current electrical standards, smoke alarms, waterproofing or wind rating. Many policies include an allowance for additional costs of meeting current legal requirements; others limit or exclude it. Where the policy includes it, the scope should too.
Hidden damage
Water and fire damage is often worse than it looks until linings are removed. A scope prepared from a visual inspection should state that assumption, and the insurer should agree to revisit the scope once the work opens up. Get that agreement in writing before accepting a figure.
Cash settlement
Where the insurer offers to cash settle instead of repairing, the amount is often based on the insurer’s panel builder rates, which the insurer can obtain because of volume but which the customer cannot. AFCA has generally taken the view that a cash settlement should be sufficient for the customer to actually have the repairs done, and has required insurers to pay the difference where a customer’s reasonable quotes exceed the insurer’s figure. Where an insurer offers a cash settlement under a home building policy, the Code requires it to give the customer information to help them understand how cash settlements work and how decisions about them are made. A customer who prefers repair by the insurer is usually entitled to insist on it where the policy gives that option.
Delay and interest
An insurer that drags out a scope dispute can be liable for interest under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act from the date it was unreasonable to withhold payment, and the Code sets timeframes for decisions and updates. Keep a chronology of every request and response.
Escalating
Put the independent quote and the item by item comparison to the insurer in writing through internal dispute resolution, which must be decided within 30 calendar days. If the response is inadequate, AFCA can decide the dispute for claims within its limits, and it frequently appoints its own expert where the scopes conflict. Alternatively the claim can be litigated as a claim on the policy. In either forum, the party with the better documented scope usually prevails.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.