A storm comes through, the ceiling collapses, and the insurer’s assessor concludes that the roof was old, the flashings were failing and the water had been getting in for years. The claim is declined for wear and tear and lack of maintenance. This is the single most common home insurance dispute in Queensland, and the outcome depends on evidence and the policy wording rather than on who sounds more confident.
Who proves what
The insured must prove, on the balance of probabilities, that the loss was caused by an event the policy insures, such as storm, impact or escape of liquid. Once that is established, the insurer bears the onus of proving that an exclusion applies. That allocation matters. An insurer who declines a claim by asserting that the damage could be wear and tear, without evidence that it actually was, has not discharged its onus. Equally, an insured who cannot show that a storm occurred and caused the damage has not got past the first step.
Cause of loss
Most policies cover storm damage and exclude damage caused by wear and tear, gradual deterioration, rust, corrosion, rot, mould and lack of maintenance. Real losses often involve both. A roof in fair condition that would have lasted another decade is lifted by a severe storm; a bathroom membrane that had been slowly failing finally gives way after heavy rain. The question is what the effective or proximate cause of the damage was. If the storm was the effective cause and the condition of the roof merely made it vulnerable, the storm damage is covered. If the storm was merely the occasion on which long term deterioration finally produced a loss, the exclusion is likely to apply. Policies differ in how they treat concurrent causes, and the wording must be read.
A frequent error in assessors’ reports is to identify pre existing deterioration and stop there, without analysing whether the storm independently caused damage. Rainwater entering through a storm damaged tile is storm damage even if an adjacent flashing was also deteriorated. The report should be read for that distinction.
Getting the insurer’s material
Under the General Insurance Code of Practice, if a claim is denied the insurer must tell the insured in writing the reasons for the decision and that they have the right to ask for the information the insurer relied on and for copies of any reports from its service suppliers or external experts. Copies of the reports and other information the insurer relied on must be provided within 10 business days of the request, subject to limited exceptions. The decline letter and the assessor’s report, including the photographs, are the starting point for any challenge.
Your own evidence
An insurer’s report can be met with a report from an independent builder, roofer or engineer who inspects the damage, considers the weather data for the date of the event and expresses an opinion about the cause. The report should address the insurer’s report point by point. Photographs taken immediately after the event, repair invoices from before the event showing maintenance had been done, and weather records from the Bureau of Meteorology all help. Do not dispose of damaged materials until the insurer has inspected and, if possible, your own expert has too.
Maintenance exclusions
Lack of maintenance exclusions require the insurer to show that the insured failed to maintain the property and that the failure caused the loss. An ordinary home owner is not expected to be a building inspector. Evidence that gutters were cleaned, that the roof was inspected periodically and that known problems were fixed will often answer the exclusion unless the deterioration was obvious and ignored.
Section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth) can also matter here, because a failure to maintain is an omission of the insured after the policy was taken out. Where the omission could reasonably be regarded as capable of causing or contributing to the loss, the insurer may refuse the claim, but it must pay the claim, or the relevant part of it, if the insured proves that the loss or that part of it was not caused by the omission. Where the omission could not have caused the loss, the insurer can only reduce the claim by the amount of any prejudice it suffered. The section reinforces the point that the insurer cannot rely on a general assertion of poor maintenance without connecting it to the damage claimed.
The dispute process
A declined claim should first be challenged through the insurer’s internal dispute resolution process, with the independent report and a written explanation of why the decision is wrong. The insurer must respond within 30 calendar days. If the decision stands, a complaint to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority is available at no cost for claims within its limits, or the dispute can be taken to court. AFCA regularly decides wear and tear disputes and publishes its approach, which places the onus on the insurer to prove the exclusion with cogent evidence.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.