- Home
- What we help with
- Insurance disputes
- Declined home, contents and vehicle claims
Declined home, contents and vehicle claims
A decline letter usually quotes an exclusion and attaches a report. What it rarely explains is that the insurer carries the burden of proving the exclusion applies, that the Insurance Contracts Act limits when a breach of a condition can be used against you, and that the assessor's view is not the final word. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on whether the decline can be challenged.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Burden of proofThe policyholder proves the loss falls within the insuring clause. The insurer proves any exclusion it relies on.
- Section 54An insurer cannot refuse a claim because of an act or omission after the policy began unless it caused or contributed to the loss, and then only to the extent of the prejudice.
- Decision timeUnder the General Insurance Code of Practice, the insurer must decide the claim within 4 months, or 12 months in limited circumstances such as an extraordinary catastrophe.
- ForumAFCA for claims up to $1,263,000, with compensation capped at $631,500 per claim, or court.
The disputes we see most
- A storm or water damage claim has been declined as wear and tear, lack of maintenance, gradual deterioration or a pre existing defect.
- A flood exclusion or a storm surge exclusion has been applied and you dispute how the water entered.
- A theft, fire or vehicle claim has been declined because the insurer doubts your account of events.
- The insurer says a condition was breached, for example about security, occupancy, modifications or who was driving.
- The insurer says the item or event is simply not covered and you read the policy differently.
- The insurer has declined after a long investigation and you want to know whether the decision can be reviewed.
How a decline is tested
An insurance claim has two parts. The policyholder must show that the loss falls within the insuring clause, for example that a storm damaged the roof or that a vehicle was stolen. The insurer must then prove any exclusion it relies on to refuse the claim. Decline letters often read as though the policyholder has to disprove the exclusion, but that is not the law. Where the insurer’s evidence is a brief assessor’s report that asserts wear and tear or a pre existing defect without explaining the mechanism of the damage, the insurer frequently cannot discharge its burden, and the decision does not survive scrutiny.
The Insurance Contracts Act
The Insurance Contracts Act 1984 regulates every general insurance contract in Australia. Section 13 implies a duty of utmost good faith into the contract and the insurer’s handling of the claim. Section 54 prevents the insurer from refusing to pay a claim because of an act or omission of the insured or another person after the contract was entered into, unless the act could reasonably be regarded as capable of causing or contributing to the loss, and where it did contribute the insurer may reduce its liability only by the amount that fairly represents the prejudice it suffered. Late notification, a breach of a security or occupancy condition and a failure to follow a claims procedure are all dealt with under section 54, and they rarely justify a complete refusal.
Common decline grounds
Water and storm claims are declined for wear and tear, gradual deterioration, lack of maintenance and defective construction. Flood claims are declined by distinguishing flood, storm water and storm surge, which frequently requires a hydrologist to resolve. Theft and fire claims are declined on the basis that the insurer does not accept the policyholder’s account, sometimes after a forensic investigation and a recorded interview. Vehicle claims are declined for unlisted drivers, modifications, alcohol and use conditions. Each ground has its own rules about what the insurer must prove, and each is regularly overturned at AFCA where the evidence does not support it.
Where a declined claim is decided
Every insurer must have an internal dispute resolution process and must respond within 30 days. If the dispute is not resolved, a complaint can be made to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, which can deal with claims up to $1,263,000 and award up to $631,500 per claim. AFCA decides what is fair in all the circumstances, taking account of the law, the policy, the General Insurance Code of Practice and good industry practice. The complaint must be lodged within 2 years of the insurer’s final internal response and within 6 years of when the loss was, or should reasonably have been, known, whichever ends first. Court proceedings are the alternative, and the only option above AFCA’s limits.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on whether the insurer has proved its ground and whether the Act cuts across it. Where the decline is weak, a properly argued internal dispute often reverses it. Where expert evidence is needed, we arrange it and present it. Where the insurer holds its position, we prepare the AFCA complaint or the court claim, and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Read the policy, the decision letter and the reports and advise you in writing on whether the insurer has proved the exclusion or condition it relies on and how the Insurance Contracts Act applies.
- Prepare a written dispute to the insurer's internal dispute resolution team setting out why the decision is wrong, with the evidence to support it.
- Arrange independent expert evidence where the dispute turns on causation, such as a hydrologist, engineer or builder.
- Prepare and run the AFCA complaint, or the court proceedings where the amount or the facts make court the better path.
Common questions
The assessor says the damage is wear and tear. Is that the end of it?
No. Wear and tear and maintenance exclusions are the most common reasons for declining water and storm claims, and they are also the most commonly overturned. The insurer must prove that the exclusion applies to the damage claimed, and a short assessor's report that asserts a conclusion without explaining how the water entered will often not do that. Where the damage has more than one cause, the question is which cause was proximate, and that often needs independent expert evidence.
What does section 54 actually do?
Section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 stops an insurer refusing a claim because of some act or omission of the insured after the policy was taken out, unless that act could reasonably be regarded as capable of causing or contributing to the loss. Where the act did contribute, the insurer can reduce the claim only by the amount that fairly represents the prejudice it suffered. It is the provision that most often defeats declines based on late notification, breaches of security conditions and failures to follow policy procedures.
The insurer says I lied about how it happened. What now?
Allegations of fraud or misstatement are serious and the insurer must prove them to a standard that reflects their seriousness. The insurer will have investigation reports and sometimes a recorded interview. We review all of it, identify what the insurer can and cannot prove, and advise on whether to dispute the finding, including at AFCA or in court. Do not sign further statements or attend further interviews before getting advice.
How long should the insurer take to decide?
The General Insurance Code of Practice requires a decision within 4 months of receiving the claim, extended to 12 months only where the claim arises from an extraordinary catastrophe, is fraudulent or reasonably suspected to be, the policyholder has not responded to reasonable requests or has asked for a delay, or the insurer has had difficulty communicating with the policyholder for reasons beyond its control. A claim that has run past those timeframes can be taken to internal dispute resolution and then AFCA on the delay alone.
Should I go to AFCA or court?
AFCA is free, less formal and can deal with claims up to $1,263,000, awarding up to $631,500 per claim. It decides what is fair in all the circumstances and its determination binds the insurer if you accept it. Court is necessary where the claim is above those limits and can be preferable where the dispute turns on contested facts that need cross examination. Our written advice will recommend one path and explain why.
Is there a time limit?
An AFCA complaint must be lodged within 2 years of the insurer's final response to your internal complaint and within 6 years of when you became aware, or should reasonably have become aware, of the loss, whichever ends first. A court claim on the policy must generally be started within 6 years, and for an ordinary property policy that period usually runs from when the insured loss occurred, not from the insurer's refusal. Do not let a decline sit.
Articles on declined home, contents and vehicle claims
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about declined home, contents and vehicle claims. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Wear and tear, lack of maintenance and gradual deterioration: challenging the most common home insurance declinesInsurers frequently decline storm and water damage claims by relying on exclusions for wear and tear, lack of maintenance or gradual deterioration. This article explains who has to prove what, how the cause of loss is analysed, how to test the insurer's report and the Code obligations that apply.
- Flood or storm? The standard flood definition and why it decides so many Queensland claimsSince 2012 Australian home policies must use a standard definition of flood, but storm, rainwater runoff and stormwater overflow are defined by each insurer. This article explains the definition, how insurers and AFCA decide what caused inundation, the role of hydrology reports and what to do if your claim is declined as flood.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.