- Home
- What we help with
- Insurance disputes
- Disputes about repairs and cash settlements
Disputes about repairs and cash settlements
The insurer has accepted the claim but wants to settle it on its terms: a panel builder whose work has already failed once, a scope that leaves half the job out, or a cash figure that no licensed builder will touch. The policy and the General Insurance Code of Practice set standards for repairs and cash settlements, and the insurer's discretion has to be exercised fairly. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Repair qualityWhere the insurer selects and directly authorises the repairer, the Code makes the insurer responsible for the quality of the work and the materials.
- Cash settlement informationAn insurer offering a cash settlement under a home building policy must explain how it works and how the amount was decided, and a cash settlement fact sheet is required by law.
- Fair settlementAFCA tests a cash settlement against the scope of works, the quotes, contingencies and the transfer of risk to the policyholder.
- Review after catastropheIf a property claim from a declared catastrophe was finalised within one month after the event, the Code gives you 12 months from finalisation to ask for a review if the assessment was not complete or accurate.
The disputes we see most
- The insurer's builder has done the repairs and they have failed, are incomplete or have caused further damage.
- The scope of works will patch the damage rather than restore the property to the standard the policy promises.
- The insurer wants to cash settle and you want the repairs done, or the cash figure is well below any quote you can obtain.
- The repair has stalled for months and the insurer and the builder blame each other.
- You accepted a cash settlement after a storm or flood and the money has proved nowhere near enough.
- The insurer refuses to cover compliance upgrades, matching of materials or consequential damage that any repair will involve.
Repairs by the insurer’s builder
Where an insurer selects and directly authorises a repairer, paragraph 86 of the General Insurance Code of Practice makes the insurer responsible for the quality of the work and the materials used, and requires complaints about the repairer to be handled through the insurer’s complaints process. Many policies go further and guarantee authorised repairs for the life of the building. Failed or incomplete repairs are therefore a dispute with the insurer, not with the tradesperson, and the insurer cannot refer the policyholder to the builder and step back. The evidence that matters is the scope that was authorised, photographs of the work and, where the failure is technical, an independent report.
Cash settlements
Most home building policies give the insurer a choice between repairing, rebuilding and paying the cost. That discretion is not unlimited. It must be exercised fairly and consistently with the duty of utmost good faith under section 13 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984, and the Australian Financial Complaints Authority has said that cash settlement should not be a first option, that it requires good communication and that it must be supported by reasonable information. A cash settlement transfers the risk of the repair, including cost increases and defects, from the insurer to the policyholder, and the amount must be enough to actually complete the work.
Paragraph 79 of the Code requires an insurer offering a cash settlement under a home building policy to provide information about how cash settlements work and how the decision was made, and the law requires a cash settlement fact sheet where both cash settlement and insurer managed repair are available. AFCA assesses the fairness of a cash settlement by looking at the policy wording, the scope of works the figure is based on, the repair quotes, the inclusion of a contingency and whether all relevant policy benefits have been included. The scope is the most important factor, and a scope that does not identify all claim related damage or describe the work in enough detail to obtain comparable quotes will not support a fair settlement.
Settlements after a catastrophe
Where a property claim arising from a declared catastrophe was finalised within one month after the event, the Code requires the insurer to allow the policyholder 12 months from finalisation to ask for a review of the claim if the policyholder thinks the assessment of the loss was not complete or accurate, even where a release was signed. Outside that situation, a release signed on inadequate information can still be challenged, and the circumstances in which it was obtained are relevant to what AFCA regards as fair.
Where these disputes are decided
Complaints start with the insurer’s internal dispute resolution process, which must respond within 30 days, and then go to AFCA for claims up to $1,263,000 with compensation capped at $631,500 per claim, or to court. An AFCA complaint must be lodged within 2 years of the insurer’s final response and within 6 years of when the loss was, or should reasonably have been, known, whichever ends first.
What usually happens
Our first step is a written advice on whether the scope, the repairs or the cash figure meet what the policy and the Code require. Where they do not, an independent scope and a detailed internal dispute often produce a revised offer. Where the insurer will not move, we prepare the AFCA complaint or court claim and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Read the policy, the scope, the settlement offer and the fact sheet and advise you in writing on what you are entitled to and whether the insurer's approach is fair.
- Obtain independent scopes, quotes and, where needed, an expert report on the failed repairs.
- Prepare the internal dispute and the AFCA complaint, including the case for a revised scope, a proper cash figure or completion of the repairs by the insurer.
- Act in court where the amount or the issues make that the better path.
Common questions
The insurer's builder did a bad job. Who is responsible?
The insurer. Paragraph 86 of the General Insurance Code of Practice provides that where the insurer selected and directly authorised the repairer, the insurer accepts responsibility for the quality of the work and the materials, and complaints about the repairer are handled under the insurer's complaints process. Many policies also contain a lifetime guarantee on authorised repairs. You do not have to pursue the builder yourself.
Can the insurer force me to take a cash settlement?
Most policies give the insurer the choice between repairing, rebuilding and paying the cost, but that discretion must be exercised fairly and consistently with the duty of utmost good faith. AFCA has said cash settlement should not be a first option and should be supported by reasonable information, and that a fair cash settlement must be enough to actually complete the repairs. Where the insurer could manage the repair and the policyholder is unlikely to be able to, cash settling may be unfair.
What has to be in a cash settlement offer?
Under the Code the insurer must give you information to help you understand how cash settlements work and how the amount was decided, and the law requires a cash settlement fact sheet where both cash settlement and insurer managed repair are available. AFCA expects the offer to be based on a scope that identifies all claim related damage, to include a contingency reflecting the transfer of risk, to reflect realistic prices for when the work will be done and to include all relevant policy benefits.
I already signed a release and the money was not enough. Is it too late?
Not necessarily. Where a property claim arising from a declared catastrophe was finalised within one month after the event, the Code requires the insurer to give you 12 months from finalisation to ask for a review if you think the assessment was not complete or accurate, even if you signed a release. Outside that situation, a release can still be set aside where it was obtained unfairly or on inadequate information, and AFCA considers the circumstances in which it was signed.
Does the insurer have to pay for compliance upgrades and matching?
It depends on the policy, but most home building policies cover the cost of meeting current building standards that apply to the repair and of matching undamaged areas where a reasonable match cannot be achieved, often up to a limit. These items are frequently left out of insurer scopes and are a common source of the gap between the insurer's figure and independent quotes.
Where is this decided?
Internal dispute resolution first, with a 30 day response, then AFCA for claims up to $1,263,000 or court. An AFCA complaint must be lodged within 2 years of the insurer's final response and within 6 years of when the loss was, or should reasonably have been, known, whichever ends first.
Articles on disputes about repairs and cash settlements
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about disputes about repairs and cash settlements. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- Cash settlement or repair: which to accept when the insurer gives you a choiceAfter a home claim is accepted the insurer may offer to repair through its builder or to pay a cash settlement. This article explains what each option means, the Code requirements for cash settlements, who carries the risk of defective work and the questions to ask before signing a release.
- The insurer's builder did a poor job: who is responsible for defective insurance repairsWhen repairs arranged by an insurer after a claim are defective or incomplete, the General Insurance Code of Practice makes the insurer responsible for the workmanship and materials. This article explains how to document the defects, what to demand, how AFCA deals with repair complaints and the position when the work was arranged by the customer.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.