Once an insurer accepts a home building claim, the customer is often offered a choice: let the insurer’s panel builder do the work, or take a cash settlement and arrange the repairs independently. Each has consequences that are not obvious at the time, and the General Insurance Code of Practice imposes obligations on the insurer about how the choice is presented.
Repair by the insurer
Where the insurer arranges the repairs through a builder it selects and directly authorises, the Code provides that the insurer accepts responsibility for the quality of the workmanship and materials. If the repairs are defective, the customer’s complaint is against the insurer, which must have the work rectified. That is a significant protection, because the customer has no contract with the panel builder and would otherwise have difficulty enforcing anything against it. The insurer’s responsibility continues after the work is finished, and a customer who discovers defects months later should go back to the insurer, not the builder.
The disadvantages are practical. The customer has little control over the builder, the program or the trades, panel builders are often stretched after major events, and disputes about the scope tend to surface during the work. The customer is entitled to the policy standard, which is usually restoration to the condition before the loss, and does not have to accept a lesser specification because it is what the panel builder proposes.
Cash settlement
A cash settlement pays the customer an amount in place of the repairs. The customer then engages their own builder, carries the risk of cost increases, defects and delays, and has to deal with any hidden damage discovered during the work. Insurers like cash settlements because they close the claim. Customers sometimes prefer them because they want to choose their own builder or to do different work.
Where an insurer offers a cash settlement under a home building policy, the Code requires it to give the customer information to help them understand how cash settlements work and how decisions about them are made. In practice the key question is whether the amount is sufficient to have the policy standard of repair carried out by a builder the customer can actually engage. Insurers calculate settlements using their panel builder’s rates, which reflect volume discounts the customer cannot obtain. AFCA has generally required insurers to pay the amount a customer would reasonably have to pay, where the customer’s quotes are reasonable and the insurer’s figure cannot realistically be achieved. A customer who accepts a cash settlement based on panel rates and then finds the work costs more has a difficult task reopening the claim.
Questions to ask before deciding
Ask for the full scope of works and the insurer’s costing. Obtain at least one independent quote from a licensed builder on the same scope. Ask whether the figure includes GST, which depends on the customer’s registration status, and whether it includes the costs of a building approval if one is required. Ask how hidden damage will be dealt with, and get the insurer’s agreement in writing that the scope will be revisited if the work reveals more. Ask whether contents, temporary accommodation and removal of debris are included or separate. And ask what happens to the sum insured for the balance of the period.
Releases
Insurers typically ask the customer to sign a release when a cash settlement is paid. A release is a contract, and it generally prevents the customer from claiming anything further for the event. Before signing, make sure every component of the claim is covered. For property claims arising from a declared catastrophe the Code gives a right to request a review within 12 months after the claim was finalised, where it was finalised within one month of the event, even after a release, but that is a narrow exception.
Partial cash settlements
A combined approach is common: the insurer repairs the structure and cash settles contents or items the customer wants to handle differently. Each component should be documented separately so that the insurer’s responsibility for the repaired work remains clear.
If the repairs are defective
Where the insurer’s builder has done defective work, the customer should report it to the insurer in writing, ask for an inspection and rectification, and if the insurer does not act, complain through internal dispute resolution and AFCA. The Code places the responsibility on the insurer, and AFCA can order rectification or payment for it.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.