Insurance repairs are carried out at scale by panel builders working to a scope and a price agreed with the insurer. The results are often good. When they are not, the customer discovers that the builder answers to the insurer, the insurer points to the builder, and the roof still leaks. The law and the Code are clearer than that experience suggests.
The insurer’s responsibility
Under the General Insurance Code of Practice, where an insurer selects and directly authorises a repairer to carry out repairs under a claim, the insurer accepts responsibility for the quality of the workmanship and the materials. The customer’s rights are against the insurer. The insurer cannot discharge its obligation under the policy by appointing a builder who then does the work badly, and it cannot tell the customer to pursue the builder. The repairs are the insurer’s performance of its promise to indemnify, and defective repairs mean the promise has not yet been performed.
This applies whether the defects appear during the work, at handover or months later. There is no Code time limit on raising defects, although delay makes causation harder to prove and policies and limitation periods still apply to the underlying claim.
Documenting the defects
Write to the insurer identifying each defect with photographs and, where relevant, a description of how it has affected the home, such as water entry after the repair. Ask for an inspection within a stated period and a written rectification plan with dates. If the defects are significant, obtain a short report from an independent builder or building consultant that identifies the defective work and what is needed to fix it. Keep every communication. Where the defects cause further damage, such as a poorly fixed roof allowing water into new plaster, record that too, because it is part of the insurer’s responsibility.
If the insurer does not respond
If the insurer does not inspect or does not rectify within a reasonable time, lodge a complaint through internal dispute resolution. The insurer must respond within 30 calendar days. The complaint should attach the defect list, the photographs, any independent report and the chronology. If the response is unsatisfactory, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority can deal with the complaint. AFCA regularly decides repair quality disputes and can require the insurer to rectify, to pay the reasonable cost of rectification by a builder of the customer’s choice, and to pay compensation for non financial loss such as stress and inconvenience where the insurer’s handling fell short. AFCA may also appoint its own expert where the parties’ experts disagree.
Scope versus quality
Not every complaint about insurance repairs is about quality. Often the work was done competently but did not go far enough, because the scope omitted items or specified a lesser standard than the policy required. That is a scope dispute, and it is resolved by comparing the policy standard with what was done. Both issues can be raised together, and both are the insurer’s responsibility where it controlled the repair.
Repairs you arranged
Where the customer took a cash settlement and engaged their own builder, the position is different. The insurer has performed its obligation by paying, and the customer’s remedies for defective work are against the builder under the contract and the statutory warranties in the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991. The usual route is a complaint to the QBCC, which can direct a licensed contractor to rectify defective work, and failing that a claim in QCAT. Fox Piper does not act in building defect disputes, but the distinction matters when deciding whether to accept cash or repair in the first place.
Rectification by another builder
Where the relationship with the panel builder has broken down, customers often want someone else to fix the work. Insurers will sometimes agree to pay another builder on quotes, which converts the matter into a cash settlement for the rectification. Get the agreement, the scope and the amount in writing before any work starts, and make sure the agreement preserves the insurer’s responsibility for any further defects in the original repairs that later emerge.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.