Once an insurer’s internal dispute resolution process has run its course, a Queensland policy holder has two ways to take the matter further: a complaint to the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, or a claim on the policy in court. They are genuinely different, and the right choice depends on the size of the claim, the nature of the dispute and the evidence.
Internal dispute resolution first
Both routes begin with a complaint to the insurer. AFCA will not accept a complaint until the insurer has had the opportunity to resolve it internally, and the insurer must respond within 30 calendar days. A clear written complaint setting out the decision challenged, the reasons it is wrong and the evidence often resolves the matter at this stage, and it defines the dispute for whatever follows.
AFCA
AFCA is the external dispute resolution scheme for financial firms, including general insurers. Consumers and small businesses can use it without charge. A complaint must usually be lodged within six years of the complainant becoming aware of the loss, and within two years of the insurer’s internal dispute resolution response. AFCA has monetary limits. For complaints lodged on or after 1 January 2024 it can consider claims where the amount in dispute is up to $1,263,000 and can award up to $631,500 per claim for direct financial loss, with lower caps for some categories such as claims against brokers. The figures are indexed every three years and are due to change again for complaints lodged from 1 January 2027, so check the current limits on AFCA’s website before relying on them.
The process is largely on the papers. AFCA gathers the parties’ submissions and documents, may refer the matter to conciliation, and if it does not settle, a case manager issues a preliminary assessment followed, if either party disagrees, by a determination from an ombudsman or panel. AFCA decides what is fair in all the circumstances, having regard to the law, the Code, good industry practice and previous determinations. A determination binds the insurer if the complainant accepts it; if the complainant rejects it, they remain free to go to court. AFCA can award interest, and compensation for non financial loss, within limits.
The advantages are cost, no exposure to the insurer’s legal costs, an experienced decision maker and the fairness standard, which can help where the law is strictly against the complainant. The disadvantages are the limits, the absence of cross examination and discovery, timeframes that can extend well past a year for contested matters, and the fact that AFCA cannot compel the insurer to produce documents in the way a court can.
Court
A claim on an insurance policy is a claim for breach of contract, brought in the Magistrates Court for amounts up to $150,000, the District Court up to $750,000, rising to $1.5 million for proceedings started on or after 1 January 2027, and the Supreme Court above that. The policy holder pleads the policy, the insured event and the insurer’s refusal; the insurer pleads any exclusion or defence and must prove it. Disclosure of documents, expert evidence under court rules, cross examination of the insurer’s assessors and a judgment enforceable as a debt are the advantages. Interest under section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act and costs are available.
The disadvantages are cost and risk. The losing party generally pays a substantial part of the winner’s costs, so a claim that fails is expensive. Court is the only option where the claim exceeds AFCA’s limits, where the dispute turns on contested facts that need cross examination, or where the insurer’s position is legally wrong and the policy holder wants a binding precedent rather than a fairness outcome.
Interaction between the two
A complainant who starts court proceedings about the same dispute generally brings AFCA’s involvement to an end, and AFCA will usually not accept a complaint that is already before a court. A complainant who goes through AFCA and rejects the determination can still sue, and the limitation period continues to run in the meantime, so the timeline must be watched. For claims close to AFCA’s compensation cap, a complainant can accept the capped amount or pursue the full claim in court, but not both.
Making the choice
For a home or motor claim within the limits where the dispute is about the application of the policy to reasonably clear facts, AFCA is usually the right forum. For a large claim, a business interruption claim or a dispute that depends on who is telling the truth, court is often better.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- AFCA, How we resolve complaints and our Rules
- AFCA, Compensation caps and monetary limits adjusted
- AFCA, The process we follow
- District Court of Queensland Act 1967 (Qld), s 68
- Justice and Other Legislation Amendment Act 2026 (Qld), ss 2 and 62 (District Court monetary limit $1.5 million for proceedings started from 1 January 2027)