Policy holders in dispute with an insurer face several different clocks at once. A claim can be perfectly good and still fail because a complaint was lodged too late, a proceeding was started after the limitation period or the insurer was told about the loss long after the event. This article sets out the time limits that matter in Queensland.
The limitation period for a claim on the policy
A claim against an insurer for refusing to pay is a claim for breach of contract. Under section 10 of the Limitation of Actions Act 1974 it must be started within six years of the cause of action accruing. For an ordinary property policy, the cause of action accrues when the insured loss occurs, not when the insurer later refuses the claim. The Queensland Court of Appeal reached that conclusion in Delta Pty Ltd v Mechanical and Construction Insurance Pty Ltd [2019] QCA 62 at [146] to [150], holding that the insurer’s obligation to indemnify arose when the insured incurred the relevant costs and that a claim started more than six years later was statute barred, and the New South Wales Court of Appeal decided the same point by majority in Globe Church Incorporated v Allianz Australia Insurance Ltd [2019] NSWCA 27. The position can differ where the policy makes a claim, or the insurer’s decision on it, a precondition to its liability, so the wording must be checked. The safe course is to treat the six years as running from the date of the loss itself. A proceeding started within six years of the loss will be in time on any analysis.
Some policies are deeds, and some are business contracts with their own contractual limitation clauses. Clauses that attempt to shorten the time in which a claim can be brought are regulated by the Insurance Contracts Act and generally cannot defeat a claim brought within the statutory period.
AFCA’s time limits
AFCA’s Rules require a complaint to be lodged within six years after the complainant first became aware, or should reasonably have become aware, that they suffered the loss, and, where the complainant has been through the insurer’s internal dispute resolution process, within two years of the date of the insurer’s final IDR response. AFCA has a discretion to accept late complaints in special circumstances but does not do so routinely. A complainant who receives an IDR response and then waits must count two years from that letter.
Lodging a complaint with AFCA does not stop the court limitation period running. A complainant who intends to go to court if the AFCA outcome is unfavourable must keep the limitation date in view, and in a long running AFCA matter close to the six year point, protective proceedings may be necessary.
Notifying the insurer
Policies require the insured to notify the insurer of a loss as soon as possible, and sometimes within a stated period. A late notification is an act or omission after the contract was entered, and section 54 of the Insurance Contracts Act applies. The insurer cannot refuse the claim because of the delay alone. It can reduce its liability only by the amount that fairly represents the prejudice the delay caused it, for example because evidence was lost or repairs became more expensive. In many cases the insurer cannot show any prejudice, and the claim is payable in full. The practical lesson is to notify anyway, even years later, and to put the insurer to proof of its prejudice.
Policies that have ended
A claim for a loss that occurred during the period of cover can be made after the policy has expired or been cancelled, subject to the limitation period and the notification analysis above. For claims made policies, which are common in professional and management liability insurance, the position is different because the trigger is the making of the claim against the insured during the period, and late notification can be fatal subject to the statutory provisions that extend cover for circumstances notified during the period.
Catastrophe reviews
The General Insurance Code of Practice allows a customer whose property claim arising from a declared catastrophe was finalised within one month of the event to request a review within 12 months after the claim was finalised, even after a release. That is a Code right rather than a legal time limit, but it can revive a claim that would otherwise be closed.
Keeping track
Record the date of the loss, the date the claim was lodged, the date of every insurer decision, the date of the IDR response and the limitation date six years from the loss. If the matter is going to AFCA, record the two year date from the IDR response. If any of those dates is within months, take advice at once.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.