A letter cancelling a home, business or motor policy mid term is alarming, and it is sometimes unlawful. The Insurance Contracts Act 1984 confines insurers to specific grounds and a specific procedure, and it separately limits the use insurers can make of things the insured did after the policy started.
The only grounds for cancellation
Section 60 provides that an insurer may cancel a contract of general insurance only where the insured has failed to comply with the duty of the utmost good faith, where there was a relevant failure before the contract was entered such as a misrepresentation or non disclosure that would have entitled the insurer to a remedy, where the insured has failed to comply with a provision of the contract including a provision for payment of premium, where the insured has made a fraudulent claim under the contract or another contract providing cover during the same period, or where the insured has failed to notify the insurer of a specified act or omission as required by the contract. A cancellation that does not rest on one of these grounds has no effect.
Insurers sometimes cancel because they have changed their appetite for a type of risk, because the insured made too many legitimate claims, or because an inspection revealed something they do not like. None of those is a ground under section 60. The insurer’s remedy in those situations is to decline to renew at the end of the period, with the notice the Act requires for non renewal.
The procedure
Section 59 requires the insurer to give the insured written notice of the cancellation. For a general insurance policy, the cancellation takes effect at 4pm on the third business day after the day the notice is given, or at 4pm on the fourteenth business day where the cover is in force only because of section 58, which continues a policy when the insurer did not give the required notice before it expired, or at any later time stated in the policy or the notice. Until that time the cover continues. The notice must be given in a way the Act permits, and a notice sent to an old address or an email the insured did not provide is open to challenge.
Where the insurer cancels for non payment of premium, the contract usually also contains its own procedure and grace period, and both must be complied with. A premium paid late but before cancellation takes effect will often keep the policy on foot.
Claims after an invalid cancellation
If a loss occurs after a purported cancellation that did not comply with section 60 or section 59, the policy was still on foot and the claim is payable. Insureds who receive a cancellation notice should keep it, record the date it arrived, continue to pay premiums if they can and challenge the cancellation in writing. If an alternative policy is taken out in the meantime, both insurers should be notified of the position.
Acts and omissions after the contract began
Section 54 is one of the most important provisions in the Act for insureds. Where the effect of the contract would be that the insurer may refuse a claim because of some act or omission of the insured or another person after the contract was entered, the insurer may not refuse the claim on that ground alone. Instead, its liability is reduced by the amount that fairly represents the prejudice it suffered as a result of the act. If the insurer suffered no prejudice, the claim is paid in full. Only where the act could reasonably be regarded as capable of causing or contributing to the loss can the insurer refuse the claim, and even then the insured can recover to the extent they prove that no part of the loss was caused by the act.
The section covers late notification of a claim, failure to comply with a security or maintenance condition, driving in breach of a licence condition and many other situations. An insurer that refuses a claim because notification was late must show what it lost by the delay, which it often cannot.
What to do
Read the cancellation or refusal letter for the ground relied on and the section of the Act or policy cited. Ask the insurer in writing to identify the statutory ground. Gather the evidence that answers it, such as proof of premium payment or the circumstances of the alleged breach. Then raise a complaint through internal dispute resolution and, if necessary, with AFCA or the courts.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.
- Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 59 (cancellation procedure)
- Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 58 (insurer to notify of expiration of contracts of general insurance)
- Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 60 (cancellation of contracts of general insurance)
- Insurance Contracts Act 1984 (Cth), s 54 (insurer may not refuse to pay claims in certain circumstances)