- Home
- What we help with
- Insurance disputes
- Underpaid or delayed claims
Underpaid or delayed claims
The insurer accepted the claim, which should have been the hard part. Instead the scope of works leaves out half the damage, the settlement figure is thousands short of every quote you can get, or the claim has simply stalled for months. The policy, the Insurance Contracts Act and the General Insurance Code of Practice all set standards for how a claim must be paid and how quickly. The first step is a fixed fee consultation on where you stand.
Every enquiry is read by a lawyer. If we can help, we reply with a fixed fee for the first step. That step is usually a consultation by phone or in person in Brisbane, and nothing is charged until you decide to go ahead.
- Decision timeThe insurer must decide the claim within 4 months of receiving it, or 12 months in limited circumstances, and must tell you about its complaints process if it misses the deadline.
- InterestWhere an insurer unreasonably withholds payment, section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act requires it to pay interest from the date payment should reasonably have been made.
- Scope of worksA settlement must be based on a scope that identifies all claim related damage and restores the property to the standard the policy promises.
- ForumInternal dispute resolution within 30 days, then AFCA or court.
The disputes we see most
- The insurer's scope of works leaves out damage that is plainly related to the event, or specifies repairs that will not bring the property back to its previous condition.
- The cash settlement offered is far below the quotes you have obtained from licensed builders.
- Contents have been valued at depreciated amounts or replaced with inferior items when the policy promises new for old.
- Temporary accommodation or loss of rent benefits have been cut off while the property is still uninhabitable.
- The claim has been with the insurer for more than 4 months with no decision and no explanation.
- The insurer has paid part of the claim and gone silent on the rest.
What the policy promises
A home building policy typically promises to repair or rebuild the damaged part of the home to the condition it was in when new, or to pay the reasonable cost of doing so. A contents policy typically promises replacement on a new for old basis. Those promises define what the insurer must pay, and a scope of works or a valuation that falls short of them is a breach of the contract, not merely a difference of opinion. The product disclosure statement also sets the additional benefits that attach to a claim: temporary accommodation, loss of rent, removal of debris, professional fees and the cost of meeting current building standards. Underpaid claims commonly ignore several of those benefits.
Scopes of works
The Australian Financial Complaints Authority regards the scope of works as the most important factor in whether a settlement is fair. The scope must identify all of the claim related damage, describe the materials and labour required with enough detail to allow comparable quotes, and be consistent with the standard of repair the policy promises. An insurer that relies on a brief scope prepared by a panel builder, excluding consequential damage, access, matching and compliance items, will usually be required to revisit it when an independent scope shows what was left out. We arrange independent scopes where the gap justifies it.
Delay
The General Insurance Code of Practice requires an insurer to decide a claim within 4 months of receiving it, or within 12 months where the claim arises from an extraordinary catastrophe, is suspected to be fraudulent, the policyholder has not responded to reasonable requests, communication has been impossible for reasons beyond the insurer’s control or the policyholder asked for a delay. If the deadline is missed, the insurer must tell the policyholder in writing about its complaints process. Section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act 1984 requires an insurer that unreasonably withholds payment to pay interest from the date payment should reasonably have been made, and AFCA can award compensation for the non financial consequences of poor claims handling.
Where these disputes are decided
The first step is a complaint to the insurer’s internal dispute resolution team, which must respond within 30 days. If that does not resolve the matter, AFCA can deal with claims up to $1,263,000 and award up to $631,500 per claim, and a complaint must be lodged within 2 years of the insurer’s final response and within 6 years of when the loss was, or should reasonably have been, known, whichever ends first. Court is the alternative and the only path above AFCA’s limits.
What usually happens
Most underpaid claims move once the policyholder sets out, item by item, what the policy promises and what the insurer’s scope or valuation leaves out, supported by an independent scope or quotes. Our written advice does that work, and where the insurer still refuses to move we prepare the AFCA complaint or the court claim and quote each step before you commit to it.
What we do
- Read the policy and the insurer's scope and valuation and advise you in writing on what the policy entitles you to and where the shortfall lies.
- Obtain independent scopes and quotes, and prepare a detailed written dispute to the insurer's internal dispute resolution team.
- Pursue interest, additional benefits and compensation for delay where the insurer has unreasonably withheld payment.
- Prepare and run the AFCA complaint or court claim where the insurer will not move.
Common questions
The insurer's builder says the repairs will cost half of what my builder quoted. Who is right?
Usually the difference lies in the scope rather than the rates. Insurer scopes are often prepared quickly and leave out consequential damage, access costs, matching of materials and compliance work that any licensed builder would have to do. AFCA treats the scope of works as the most important element of a fair settlement, and expects it to identify all claim related damage with enough detail that the policyholder can get comparable quotes. We obtain an independent scope and compare the two line by line.
Can the insurer depreciate my contents?
Only if the policy says so. Most home contents policies promise replacement on a new for old basis, in which case depreciation is not permitted. Where the policy does allow indemnity or depreciated settlement for particular items, the deduction must be reasonable and explained. The product disclosure statement controls, so the first step is to read it carefully.
The claim has taken more than 4 months. What can I do?
The General Insurance Code of Practice requires a decision within 4 months of receiving the claim unless one of the exceptions in paragraph 78 applies, in which case the limit is 12 months. If the insurer misses the deadline it must tell you about its complaints process. A delayed claim can be taken to internal dispute resolution and then to AFCA, which can award compensation for the consequences of delay, and section 57 of the Insurance Contracts Act requires interest on amounts unreasonably withheld.
The insurer has stopped paying for our rental. Can it do that?
Temporary accommodation and loss of rent benefits are governed by the policy, which usually provides them for a fixed period or until the property is habitable, whichever is sooner, up to a limit. Where the delay in repairs is the insurer's, AFCA has regularly required insurers to continue the benefit beyond the policy period or to compensate for the consequences. The correspondence about the repair delays is the key evidence.
Should I accept a partial payment?
You can usually accept an undisputed part of a claim without giving up the disputed balance, but check the wording of anything you are asked to sign. A release or a full and final settlement should not be signed while any part of the claim is in dispute. If you have already signed one, the circumstances in which it was obtained can still be reviewed.
What are the time limits?
A complaint to AFCA must be made within 2 years of the insurer's final internal dispute resolution response and within 6 years of when the loss was, or should reasonably have been, known, whichever ends first. A court claim on the policy must generally be started within 6 years, and for an ordinary property policy that period usually runs from when the insured loss occurred, not from the insurer's refusal. Where a property claim arising from a declared catastrophe was finalised within one month after the event, the Code allows you to ask for a review within 12 months of finalisation.
Articles on underpaid or delayed claims
Longer answers to the questions people ask us most often about underpaid or delayed claims. Each one sets out the law in plain terms and lists its sources.
- When the insurer's scope of works is too low: disputing the repair estimateAn insurer that accepts a home claim will often produce a scope of works and a repair estimate well below what independent builders quote. This article explains what the policy promises, how to challenge the scope, the treatment of matching, upgrades and hidden damage, and the approach AFCA takes to inadequate cash settlements.
- Delayed insurance claims: the Code timeframes, section 57 interest and how to move a stalled claimThe General Insurance Code of Practice sets specific timeframes for deciding claims, and the Insurance Contracts Act requires insurers to pay interest on money withheld unreasonably. This article explains the timeframes, when they can be extended, how interest is calculated and the steps that actually move a stalled claim.
Tell us what happened.
A lawyer will read your enquiry and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step. There is no charge until you decide to go ahead. Everything you send is confidential.
- New enquiries
- Start with the form so that a lawyer can read what happened before we quote.
- Existing clients
- (07) 3473 5078, Monday to Friday, 8:30am to 5pm.
- Where we act
- Anywhere in Queensland, by phone. In person at Level 7, 193 North Quay, Brisbane City, by appointment.
- What to have ready
- Nothing yet. Once the first step is confirmed we will tell you which documents, photos or messages to send.
Thank you. Your enquiry has been received.
A lawyer will read it and, if we can help, we will reply with a fixed fee for the first step and what that step involves. Nothing is charged unless you decide to go ahead.