South East Queensland floods and storms produce the same dispute again and again. A home is inundated, the policy excludes flood or carries a flood sub limit, and the insurer declares the water to have been flood. The home owner believes it was storm water that could not get away. The answer determines whether a claim worth tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars is paid.
The standard definition
Since 2012 every home building and contents policy must use the definition of flood set out in regulation 34 of the Insurance Contracts Regulations. Flood means the covering of normally dry land by water that has escaped or been released from the normal confines of any of the following: a lake, whether or not it has been altered or modified; a river, creek or other natural watercourse, whether or not altered or modified; a reservoir, canal or dam. The definition applies whether the policy covers flood or excludes it, and insurers cannot use a different or broader meaning.
What the regulation does not do is define storm, rainwater runoff or stormwater. Those are defined by each insurer, and the definitions vary. Most policies cover damage from storm, including rainwater that runs off land or overflows from gutters, downpipes and stormwater drains because they cannot cope with the volume. Water that rises from a creek and crosses a property is flood; water that falls on the street and flows into the garage because the drain is overwhelmed is storm water. The distinction turns on where the water came from.
Mixed causes
In a major event both often happen together. A creek breaks its banks at the same time as intense rain overwhelms the local stormwater system, and the two bodies of water meet in the living room. Where a policy excludes flood but covers storm, the insurer must show which damage the flood caused. If the storm water alone would have reached the same level and caused the same damage, the flood exclusion may not reduce the claim at all. If the flood water arrived first and did the damage before the storm water contributed, the position is different. The analysis depends on timing, levels and the source of the water, and that is what hydrologists are retained to establish.
Hydrology reports
Insurers routinely commission hydrology reports after major events, and in many cases a single report is prepared for a street or suburb. The report will estimate the peak flood level from the watercourse, the timing of its arrival and the contribution of local rainfall. Policy holders are entitled under the General Insurance Code of Practice to a copy of any report the insurer relied on, within 10 business days of asking after a denial. An independent hydrologist can review the insurer’s report and, where the data supports it, give a contrary opinion. The relevant evidence includes the Bureau of Meteorology rainfall and river gauge records, council flood mapping, photographs and videos with time stamps, and the observations of neighbours about where the water came from and when.
Flood cover and sub limits
Where the policy does cover flood, the usual dispute is about the sum insured and the scope, not the cause. Where flood is optional and was declined when the policy was taken out, insurers must have made the option and its consequences clear, and a policy holder who was told flood cover was unavailable or unnecessary may have a separate complaint about the sale. Disclosure documents and call recordings from the time of purchase are relevant.
Catastrophe claims
Where the Board of the Insurance Council declares a catastrophe to be extraordinary, the Code gives insurers up to 12 months, instead of 4, to decide claims arising from it. After any declared catastrophe, the Code also allows a customer whose property claim was finalised within one month of the event to ask for a review within 12 months after the claim was finalised, even after a release has been signed. Claims managers under pressure after a major event make mistakes, and a decline issued on a generic basis without property specific analysis is open to challenge.
What to do
Photograph the water as it rises and as it recedes, noting times. Ask neighbours what they saw. Request the hydrology report and the decline reasons in writing. Lodge a complaint through internal dispute resolution with your evidence, and if it fails, take the matter to AFCA or the courts. The policy wording for storm and the regulation definition of flood should be read side by side before any step is taken.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.