Disputes between owners and contractors about a domestic building contract in Queensland are usually decided by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal, although a court can also hear them. QCAT’s building jurisdiction has features that distinguish it from its minor civil disputes work, and parties who understand the process at the outset tend to do better in it.
Jurisdiction
QCAT may decide a domestic building dispute of any value. There is no monetary cap in this jurisdiction, so a dispute about a $900,000 contract and a dispute about a $9,000 deck are both heard there. Commercial building disputes, meaning disputes about building work that is not domestic, are within QCAT’s jurisdiction up to $50,000, or above that amount if the parties consent; otherwise they go to the courts. Disputes between a contractor and a subcontractor are building disputes too, though Fox Piper does not act in subcontractor disputes.
The QBCC process comes first
Before a party can file a building dispute application, they must have participated in the QBCC’s dispute resolution process. The QBCC attempts to resolve complaints between owners and contractors through its early dispute resolution service, and when it cannot, it issues a letter confirming that the process has been completed. That letter must accompany the QCAT application. An application filed without it will be rejected or stayed, so the first practical step in any building dispute is the QBCC complaint.
The application
The application sets out the parties, the contract, what happened and the orders sought, which may include payment of money, a declaration about the contract, an order requiring something to be done, and interest and costs. It is accompanied by the contract, the relevant correspondence and the QBCC letter. The applicant must serve the application on the respondent, who then has 14 days to file a response. A respondent who has their own claim files a counter application at the same time.
Directions and evidence
Once the response is in, the tribunal gives directions for the filing of evidence. Each party files statements of evidence from the people who can speak to the facts and, where the dispute involves technical matters, an expert report. Expert evidence in QCAT is subject to the tribunal’s practice direction, which generally requires experts for both sides to confer and produce a joint report identifying the matters on which they agree and disagree. In a contract dispute about variations, payments and termination, the key evidence is usually the documents: the contract, the variations, the progress claims, the payments and the notices.
Compulsory conference
Most building disputes are listed for a compulsory conference before a member of the tribunal. The conference is confidential and aims to settle the dispute or at least narrow the issues. A substantial proportion of building disputes resolve at or soon after this stage. Parties should attend with authority to settle and with a clear understanding of their best and worst outcomes.
Hearing
If the matter does not settle, it proceeds to a hearing, where witnesses give evidence and are cross examined and the parties make submissions. Hearings in building disputes can run for one to several days depending on the issues. The tribunal gives written reasons. An appeal generally lies to the QCAT appeal tribunal, without leave on a question of law and only with leave on a question of fact or of mixed law and fact.
Representation and costs
Parties in QCAT generally represent themselves unless the tribunal gives leave for legal representation, which is commonly granted in building disputes because of their complexity. Costs in a building dispute are governed by section 77(3)(h) of the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991, which gives the tribunal a broad discretion to award costs, rather than by the general rule in the QCAT Act that each party bears its own costs. Costs do not automatically follow the event, and the tribunal asks whether it is just and fair to order costs in favour of the successful party (Contrast Constructions Pty Ltd v Allen (No 2) [2026] QCAT 516 at [88] to [89]). Parties should therefore budget on the basis that they may not recover their legal costs even if they win, which makes early and realistic settlement discussions valuable.
Timeframes
A building dispute that runs to hearing commonly takes a year or more from filing. Interim relief, such as an order preserving evidence or restraining a party from dealing with money, is available but exceptional.
Tell us what has happened through our enquiry form. If we can assist, we will confirm the proposed first step, its scope and fee before you decide whether to proceed. Sending an enquiry does not engage us to act or suspend any deadline. If a deadline is approaching, seek advice promptly.
Sources
The legislation, decisions and official guidance this article relies on. Each link opens the published source in a new tab.